Anti India slogan in JNU, Delhi

The students were instigated by political parties and hired goons of vested interests.

The students were instigated by political parties and hired goons of vested interests.

the students should use there mind that political parties are using them 

It is easy for the political parties to influence Young minds. Hence, Politicians and political parties use youngsters to achieve their selfish ends.

Babu saroj wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Well my thinking is that the student should focus on their studies rather than doing all this. and if they want to do all this then there are other ways of doing that because they are students and this kind of behaviour is not meant for the students 

Students are the future of a country and so they need to voice their opinion. Yes, what is required is a right mentor who can guide them on the path that leads to a better country. Student politics is not new but they should not be misguided. Even the students played important role in our Freedom Struggle. A link for you:

http://www.merinews.com/article/role-of-students-in-the-indian-independence-movement/15908767.shtml

that's only i was saying that they are students and they are educated so why they are doing all these there are many other ways also to get justice. i mean to say that this is not the proper way for a student to do all these, this doesn't set a good example.

The problem is that most of the students fail to keep themselves away from college politics because the political parties usually in some or the other way drag them into it. Some students smartly avoid it but some definitely get trapped and that's where the problem is.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Well my thinking is that the student should focus on their studies rather than doing all this. and if they want to do all this then there are other ways of doing that because they are students and this kind of behaviour is not meant for the students 

Students are the future of a country and so they need to voice their opinion. Yes, what is required is a right mentor who can guide them on the path that leads to a better country. Student politics is not new but they should not be misguided. Even the students played important role in our Freedom Struggle. A link for you:

http://www.merinews.com/article/role-of-students-in-the-indian-independence-movement/15908767.shtml

that's only i was saying that they are students and they are educated so why they are doing all these there are many other ways also to get justice. i mean to say that this is not the proper way for a student to do all these, this doesn't set a good example.

The problem is that most of the students fail to keep themselves away from college politics because the political parties usually in some or the other way drag them into it. Some students smartly avoid it but some definitely get trapped and that's where the problem is.

 No politician drags a student in to politics, unless the student is willing. Politicians need not be blamed.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Well my thinking is that the student should focus on their studies rather than doing all this. and if they want to do all this then there are other ways of doing that because they are students and this kind of behaviour is not meant for the students 

Students are the future of a country and so they need to voice their opinion. Yes, what is required is a right mentor who can guide them on the path that leads to a better country. Student politics is not new but they should not be misguided. Even the students played important role in our Freedom Struggle. A link for you:

http://www.merinews.com/article/role-of-students-in-the-indian-independence-movement/15908767.shtml

Student politics is OK, but involvement of political parties in collage politics is not acceptable.

Yes and this has to be understood by the different political leaders. They must not engage the young minds for their selfish motive and ruin the lives of these students. In the larger context the country will be at a huge loss when such young minds take a wrong path.

President of JLNU is member of CPI, just think who is supporting him, Communists are always anti Hindu as well India.  

 

 

 

 

rambabu wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Well my thinking is that the student should focus on their studies rather than doing all this. and if they want to do all this then there are other ways of doing that because they are students and this kind of behaviour is not meant for the students 

Students are the future of a country and so they need to voice their opinion. Yes, what is required is a right mentor who can guide them on the path that leads to a better country. Student politics is not new but they should not be misguided. Even the students played important role in our Freedom Struggle. A link for you:

http://www.merinews.com/article/role-of-students-in-the-indian-independence-movement/15908767.shtml

that's only i was saying that they are students and they are educated so why they are doing all these there are many other ways also to get justice. i mean to say that this is not the proper way for a student to do all these, this doesn't set a good example.

The problem is that most of the students fail to keep themselves away from college politics because the political parties usually in some or the other way drag them into it. Some students smartly avoid it but some definitely get trapped and that's where the problem is.

 No politician drags a student in to politics, unless the student is willing. Politicians need not be blamed.

it is not right that most of students like collage politics, only who wants to join politics as profession involve in collage politics.

It is right that directly politicians don't drag students in politics, but their representive in collage done this work.

 

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

Babu saroj wrote:

Well my thinking is that the student should focus on their studies rather than doing all this. and if they want to do all this then there are other ways of doing that because they are students and this kind of behaviour is not meant for the students 

Students are the future of a country and so they need to voice their opinion. Yes, what is required is a right mentor who can guide them on the path that leads to a better country. Student politics is not new but they should not be misguided. Even the students played important role in our Freedom Struggle. A link for you:

http://www.merinews.com/article/role-of-students-in-the-indian-independence-movement/15908767.shtml

that's only i was saying that they are students and they are educated so why they are doing all these there are many other ways also to get justice. i mean to say that this is not the proper way for a student to do all these, this doesn't set a good example.

The problem is that most of the students fail to keep themselves away from college politics because the political parties usually in some or the other way drag them into it. Some students smartly avoid it but some definitely get trapped and that's where the problem is.

 No politician drags a student in to politics, unless the student is willing. Politicians need not be blamed.

it is not right that most of students like collage politics, only who wants to join politics as profession involve in collage politics.

It is right that directly politicians don't drag students in politics, but their representive in collage done this work.

 

It seems @rambabu thought I meant to say that the popular politicians go to the campuses and apply force to drag the students into politics. Every political party has a student's wing and they are very much controlled by their parent body. The student's wing work according to the parent body's instruction and so those students who show a little more interest in politics are usually counselled and motivated. This is a fact.  

Student politics is not wrong. There can be few bad elements and they need to be dealt properly. 

Is this tolerance ! Can anyone in this forum justify that this is tolerance 

anil wrote:

vijay wrote:

No activist who opposed US participation in Vietnam war, and there were huge protests, was convicted. How weakness of Hinduism comes out is not clear. The ruling ideology is trying to spread its tentacles in all fields including education institutes and JNU is a prize catch. Foul play cannot be ruled out to malign left wing students. I also agree that anti Indian slogan raisers should be punished but let us not draw biased conclusions till matter is more clear.

India is not country in which some one punished within 2 or 3 days. Country have proper system of enquiry and investigation. No one can raise finger on impartiality of Indian courts.

Indian courts and its judicial system do not have a good record/ many times the Indian judicial system came under scanner. Jayalililata's case is an example.

 

There is a time and place for everything and students coming out with statements saying we are capable of doing this and also taking sides with bad, criminal elements can never be tolerated! It is because the politicians use them that the student community has begun to think that they can manipulate the government by going on strikes ! It is a totally wrong precedence because they are just mis guided missiles fired by the politicians who harm the fabric of the society and before they come to their senses they would have done a lot of damage ! I feel the government is doing the right thing in curbing these elements, who are just tools used by the opposition parties to vent out their own frustrations..

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

SC did not refuse the bail but it said that he must file the bail petition in HC first and that's why it did not hear the case. I know it is in the court but, do you think we should not have any voice about any case which is in court? We can easily discuss issues among ourselves. Next is if anyone called a meeting without permission means he/she is anti-nationalists, isn't it too much?  

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

SC did not refuse the bail but it said that he must file the bail petition in HC first and that's why it did not hear the case. I know it is in the court but, do you think we should not have any voice about any case which is in court? We can easily discuss issues among ourselves. Next is if anyone called a meeting without permission means he/she is anti-nationalists, isn't it too much?

Don't forgot agenda of meeting. Afzal guru! It is opinion that one should not be allowed to favor a person who is punished by court. 

 

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

SC did not refuse the bail but it said that he must file the bail petition in HC first and that's why it did not hear the case. I know it is in the court but, do you think we should not have any voice about any case which is in court? We can easily discuss issues among ourselves. Next is if anyone called a meeting without permission means he/she is anti-nationalists, isn't it too much?

Don't forgot agenda of meeting. Afzal guru! It is opinion that one should not be allowed to favor a person who is punished by court. 

The very purpose of the meeting was to protest against the hanging of Afzal Guru.

 

 

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

SC did not refuse the bail but it said that he must file the bail petition in HC first and that's why it did not hear the case. I know it is in the court but, do you think we should not have any voice about any case which is in court? We can easily discuss issues among ourselves. Next is if anyone called a meeting without permission means he/she is anti-nationalists, isn't it too much?

Don't forgot agenda of meeting. Afzal guru! It is opinion that one should not be allowed to favor a person who is punished by court. 

The very purpose of the meeting was to protest against the hanging of Afzal Guru.

He is not yet punished by the court so I think everyone has the right to opine. Secondly, you must not forget that even The Delhi Police Commissioner has stated that if the accused student make a bail plea then the police department will not oppose it. I think this whole episode is quite deep rooted so we from outside should not judge on the basis of what we are made to see. I always feel that we come up with judgement very easily when the accused is not our own but that's not fair when we know that in many ways students do get trapped. So, let's pray that if the accused is really responsible for all kind of negative protests then he should not be spared but if otherwise then his life should not be shunted as it is being done now. 

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

The whole incident reminds me of the bollywood movie Maachis where an innocent youth was picked up by the police. It actually happens and for the police the soft target is the innocent young minds and ultimately their lives get thrashed. If we go by the media report then we are now very sure about one fact that the JNU student's union President got falsely implicated. This is not a fair handling of a situation.  

Now this case is in court, SC refused for bail of president of JNU. It is job of court declare some one innocent or guilty. What you write here may be right but why president called meeting in university campus without permission of Adm.

SC did not refuse the bail but it said that he must file the bail petition in HC first and that's why it did not hear the case. I know it is in the court but, do you think we should not have any voice about any case which is in court? We can easily discuss issues among ourselves. Next is if anyone called a meeting without permission means he/she is anti-nationalists, isn't it too much?

Don't forgot agenda of meeting. Afzal guru! It is opinion that one should not be allowed to favor a person who is punished by court. 

The very purpose of the meeting was to protest against the hanging of Afzal Guru.

He is not yet punished by the court so I think everyone has the right to opine. Secondly, you must not forget that even The Delhi Police Commissioner has stated that if the accused student make a bail plea then the police department will not oppose it. I think this whole episode is quite deep rooted so we from outside should not judge on the basis of what we are made to see. I always feel that we come up with judgement very easily when the accused is not our own but that's not fair when we know that in many ways students do get trapped. So, let's pray that if the accused is really responsible for all kind of negative protests then he should not be spared but if otherwise then his life should not be shunted as it is being done now. 

 

I'm amazed seeing those who still think that innocents are framed by the Administration of the university and the central Government. What happened in JNU and aftermath is a clear cut case of Treason.

Culprits must be punished.