The immunity granted by governor's post makes them do funny things.

Funny things cannot be tolerated if they are defaming a world renowned Nobel Laureate  who clarified long ago that the word "Adhinayak "was never intended to refer the then British Emperor. People in the power should act with  magnanimity and dignity.

I agree with a user that Governor has immunity. we are not asking for any action against the governor but only stating our position in the matter. Also the high diginiataries like governors are supposed to speak with care and avoid controversial matters. 

While replying the poster who referred immunity that a person like Governor should think twice before what he  utters. Speaking with responsibility and dignity would have saved the situation.

No one has gone in to the history of our National anthem but let me say Kalyan is neither the first nor will be the last. The controversy started right from the time it was accepted as our National anthem otherwise what was the need for Gurudev became angry at the reactions coming from different sectors. BJP was nowhere in picture then

http://www.thehindu.com/features/friday-review/history-and-culture/100-years-since-jana-gana-mana-was-born/article2752111.ece

suni51 wrote:

No one has gone in to the history of our National anthem but let me say Kalyan is neither the first nor will be the last. The controversy started right from the time it was accepted as our National anthem otherwise what was the need for Gurudev became angry at the reactions coming from different sectors. BJP was nowhere in picture then

http://www.thehindu.com/features/friday-review/history-and-culture/100-years-since-jana-gana-mana-was-born/article2752111.ece

 

A very informative article dealing about the Controversy surrounding Jana Gana Mana...

Though the BJP was not anywhere in the picture controversies were there since it was introduced. This is why Gurudev was obliged to offer an explanation. Since then until today controversies are continuing. And the clarifications are also continuing. And this will continue.

 

rambabu wrote:

suni51 wrote:

No one has gone in to the history of our National anthem but let me say Kalyan is neither the first nor will be the last. The controversy started right from the time it was accepted as our National anthem otherwise what was the need for Gurudev became angry at the reactions coming from different sectors. BJP was nowhere in picture then

http://www.thehindu.com/features/friday-review/history-and-culture/100-years-since-jana-gana-mana-was-born/article2752111.ece

 

A very informative article dealing about the Controversy surrounding Jana Gana Mana...

Though the BJP was not anywhere in the picture controversies were there since it was introduced. This is why Gurudev was obliged to offer an explanation. Since then until today controversies are continuing. And the clarifications are also continuing. And this will continue.

 

There should be no more controversy. Any controversy and discussion was okay before we selected the national anthem. Once Jana Gana Mana accepted as national anthem, we must avoid all controversy and honor the national anthem. However if Kalyan singh's views are shared by ruling alliance, they can well change the national anthem in a constitutional way instead or uttering such remarks time to time. 

Sunil has referred to my comment in an earlier post that the song Jana Gana Mana is in praise of British emperor. Truly speaking, this is what I knew and wrote. There are many others who know only so much that the song was in praise of British Emperor. Now an explanation is given that this was not so. Well then we may be corrected. I was not then aware of explanation by Tagore that the song was not in praise of King George Vth. . 

 

 

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

rambabu wrote:

suni51 wrote:

No one has gone in to the history of our National anthem but let me say Kalyan is neither the first nor will be the last. The controversy started right from the time it was accepted as our National anthem otherwise what was the need for Gurudev became angry at the reactions coming from different sectors. BJP was nowhere in picture then

http://www.thehindu.com/features/friday-review/history-and-culture/100-years-since-jana-gana-mana-was-born/article2752111.ece

 

A very informative article dealing about the Controversy surrounding Jana Gana Mana...

Though the BJP was not anywhere in the picture controversies were there since it was introduced. This is why Gurudev was obliged to offer an explanation. Since then until today controversies are continuing. And the clarifications are also continuing. And this will continue.

 

There should be no more controversy. Any controversy and discussion was okay before weselected the national anthem. Once Jana Gana Mana accepted as national anthem, we must avoid all controversy and honor the national anthem. However if Kalyan singh's views are shared by ruling alliance, they can well changethe national anthem in a constitutional way instead or uttering such remarkstime to time. 

 

Yes sir. This is an ideal solution. Facts should be accepted. If there are controversies solution is always there through accepted constitutional ways.

 

 

 

I also feel so, once accepted as national anthem the matter should end  here. There is no use going into history otherwise there will be more controversies arise from many/different quarters.

True Sunil. Instead of digging the past and involve in  controversies, better to indulge in constructive matters to build India.