Reservation and donations a bane on our education system

2.7K Views
0 Replies
2 min read

In a month or two we would witness the great rush for professional colleges all over India. Speaking about Karnataka which has a record number of professional colleges , one can see the anxiety faced by middle class parents belonging to general category having neither the cash nor caste or minority reservation that ensures their children a seat . I was witness to a heated argument between two ladies when be of them was happily talking about being able to choose a professional college for her son when he finishes his Pre university regardless of what he scores because she comes under the reserved category. This irritated the other lady whose son had no such privilege and inspite of working hard and scoring much better marks , is not guaranteed of a seat and led to an argument and may people present there were supporting the lady .

Our previous politicians have messed up the nation with reservation and later donation seats which takes away almost 18 percent of the total seats. The general category gets just 20 percent of the seats , so one can imagine the pressure on those students .. the reservation is carried forth to jobs and even promotions and some politicians want to take it even further ..

Should the govt ban both ..

2 Likes

20 Replies

In Harward and other universities abroad they do have some criteria based on which they take students with donations. It will seems not free for all like here ..As far as reservation s concerned some states like Karnataka want to bring in some ridiculous reservations like dalit  muslims , the height of communalism..

It gets worse when certain groups start staging violent protests to get Reservations. They "paralyze" the daily routine of a city or even a state by creating a ruckus in public places. And when they succeed, other groups realize that violence is the only way to force the government to listen to their grievances. Not good for the country as a whole.

Like it happened with the Patel agitation which has thankfully quietened down now ! All that reservation has done is divide the society further more and give a reason for people to blackmail the government. In my own town recently we had an agitation by the fisherfolk since they come under backward and not SC or ST category which gets them many more benefits. And these people are well to do with fishing trawlers and boats of their own and government given land near the sea, free education etc ..

Abhishek Sharma wrote:

It gets worse when certain groups start staging violent protests to get Reservations. They "paralyze" the daily routine of a city or even a state by creating a ruckus in public places. And when they succeed, other groups realize that violence is the only way to force the government to listen to their grievances. Not good for the country as a whole.

Protests can be done in a  peaceful manner.

But if protest are done in a violent way day to day life will be disturbed.

Of course, as you said violent ways to protest sends a wrong message that Violence is the only way to to demand anything.

Discussing the problems with the concerned authorities  is the ideal way

The kind f benefits reserved categories get is mind blowing, so naturally there would be protests and violence when any attempt is made to either reduce or even change the structure ..Since all of this is funded through tax payers money , one can imagine the fury of the people belonging to general category , who not only don't get any benefits, but suffer because​ of the reservations , also indirectly fund others get benefits which many of them don't deserve..

Reservations oil the politicians and donations oil the rich. So the general category can go to _____.

Can go to Hell ? I do not agree with you, Reservations must be there. But not caste basis, but on Merit basis.

What is the logic for having merit based reservations. Indians will go and buy merit. Let only merit be the basis.

If at all  reservation is a must then it should be based upon economic condition because there are many meritorious students who are forced to take up meager jobs as they lack the required fund for higher studies. Reservation based upon caste is definitely a bane.

Buying  the merit is the trait of Congress party.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

If at all  reservation is a must then it should be based upon economic condition because there are many meritorious students who are forced to take up meager jobs as they lack the required fund for higher studies. Reservation based upon caste is definitely a bane.

I agree with you. Reservations based on caste should not be there. Unfortunately reservations based on caste is in vogue. This is because some selfish political parties want to build up their Vote Banks

rambabu wrote:

Buying  the merit is the trait of Congress party.

Why do you ve to bring Congress in everything? What has this got to do with a political party?

Because Congress party in order to lure the people, Congress party  generally uses these trick.

It says, no merit is needed. It is enough if you belong to  Backward castes.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

If at all  reservation is a must then it should be based upon economic condition because there are many meritorious students who are forced to take up meager jobs as they lack the required fund for higher studies. Reservation based upon caste is definitely a bane.

I agree , merit /means is the  only reservation that is worth having for students. If they start a fund with all that money that is being spent on reservations I am sure the deserving poor students would benefit greatly and so ill our country which will have better quality of students graduating !

Reservation on basis of cast of economic condition but it must be only for one time. If some selected for job with help of reservation, what is the need of reservation for his/her children. 

 Reservation should not be there, once the candidate gets a job. But such situation or condition is there ?

Right now only reservations basing on caste is prevailing in the Country

rambabu wrote:

 Reservation should not be there, once the candidate gets a job. But such situation or condition is there ?

Right now only reservations basing on caste is prevailing in the Country

It is also only for one time. It is funny that a person have to pay Income tax if earning is more than 2.5 lacks but limit for creamy layer is 6 lakcs. Means person specific cast is backward if his earning is 6 lacks PA.

anil wrote:
rambabu wrote:

 Reservation should not be there, once the candidate gets a job. But such situation or condition is there ?

Right now only reservations basing on caste is prevailing in the Country

It is also only for one time. It is funny that a person have to pay Income tax if earning is more than 2.5 lacks but limit for creamy layer is 6 lakcs. Means person specific cast is backward if his earning is 6 lacks PA.

Yes it was increased to  4.5 lakhs in 2008 from 3 lakhs and was again increased to Rs 6 lakhs in 2013 just before the general elections by the UPA govt.

anil wrote:

Reservation on basis of cast of economic condition but it must be only for one time. If some selected for job with help of reservation, what is the need of reservation for his/her children. 

It has by now spread to everything possible -education, career , promotion, income tax, housing benefits , travel benefits ...They want to bring in more !

Wait for some years they will claim reservation in private sectors. It is better government give reservation to upper cast in ratio of their population. At present maximum limit of reservation is 50%. Means rest 50% is for non reserve class.But reserve class have right to chose general catogery or reserve. But upper cast have not this right.

Topic Author

Topic Stats

Created Tuesday, 04 April 2017 13:48
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.7K
Likes 2

Share This Topic