Election politics should not be part of independence day celebration. Prime minister's address from Red fort is really a message to nation and the entire world. Modi's action to compare his address with PM's is utterly ridiculous and makes no sense whatsoever.

I beg to differ sir, Our PM speaks on 15 August only and if he speaks to public to address its problems, public needs a clear vision of government's policies and what it is doing to rectify whatever has gone wrong. If we find someone reading a written speech, without a real motive behind it but a repeat of what a PM has been saying for last decade, the questions are bound to open.
We do not have system where prime minister addresses public weekly on radio and TV keeps informed about latest developments like in other democracies. But we have a PM who addresses public only once in a year so expect lots of questions from public and opposition. We have right to know what is our government doing and my emphasis is on DOING and not thinking. They only tell us what they are going to do which in fact they never do.

Actually This time Govt need to be change and BJP is one of the choice but we can not avoid third morcha because in case of to avoid both party people will go for third front.

Actually I feel it has more to do with the two indiviuals rather than their designations....PM is afterall a peoples rep, whereas here he is not even that, since he has been elected by Sonia Gandhi...Manmohan Singh is definitely not above criticism and that when it is valid and true! It is precisely because of that, the congress party and others who feel they can curry some favor with Congress at a later date are coming out with statements like one should not criticise the PM on Independance day ...

Actually I feel it has more to do with the two indiviuals rather than their designations....PM is afterall a peoples rep, whereas here he is not even that, since he has been elected by Sonia Gandhi...Manmohan Singh is definitely not above criticism and that when it is valid and true! It is precisely because of that, the congress party and others who feel they can curry some favor with Congress at a later date are coming out with statements like one should not criticise the PM on Independance day ...

Prime minister is a constitutional post and his speech on independence day is a solemn occasion. It is irrelevant to point out who selected him and how. In party based democracy, always party leadership and party parliamentarians decide and select PM. Sonia Gandhi being Congress President has definitely an important role to select P.M. and once decided, no doubt, he will get support from all party and allies members. Manmohan singh was elected not by just Sonia Gandhi but by all MPs belonging to Congress and allies. It makes no sense to repeatedly harp on the theme of his selection by sonia gandhi, which makes absolutely no sense.

Narendra Modi has definitely lowered the prestige of entire nation and also BJP by comparing his speech to that of PM at Red Fort.

Actually I feel it has more to do with the two indiviuals rather than their designations....PM is afterall a peoples rep, whereas here he is not even that, since he has been elected by Sonia Gandhi...Manmohan Singh is definitely not above criticism and that when it is valid and true! It is precisely because of that, the congress party and others who feel they can curry some favor with Congress at a later date are coming out with statements like one should not criticise the PM on Independance day ...

Prime minister is a constitutional post and his speech on independence day is a solemn occasion. It is irrelevant to point out who selected him and how. In party based democracy, always party leadership and party parliamentarians decide and select PM. Sonia Gandhi being Congress President has definitely an important role to select P.M. and once decided, no doubt, he will get support from all party and allies members. Manmohan singh was elected not by just Sonia Gandhi but by all MPs belonging to Congress and allies. It makes no sense to repeatedly harp on the theme of his selection by sonia gandhi, which makes absolutely no sense.

Narendra Modi has definitely lowered the prestige of entire nation and also BJP by comparing his speech to that of PM at Red Fort.

The congress leaders and even L K Avani was not too happy about the comments and referneces made by Modi in his speech about manmohan Singh's performance. So what would have been the right time to do so? In my opinion he has got the maximum impact by doing it today and after all thats what Congress does and is good at....


{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 10784]}

I may not be too happy about his other comments but here I have no complaints against him. In fact he has voiced questions which have been agitating my mind for quite some time!!![/quot

I don't see there was anything wrong with the timing with questions coming from Modi regarding PM's points of speech? What is the use if you beat the bush after the snake is gone? What have we done apart from making false promises for the Indian masses? Advani is no more a force to recon, he never was.

Narendra Modi and BJP will certainly pay for their bad conduct in coming elections. Let us take a break on this particular issue please....

Sudden change !!!! :huh:

Actually This time Govt need to be change and BJP is one of the choice but we can not avoid third morcha because in case of to avoid both party people will go for third front.

Actually This time Govt need to be change and BJP is one of the choice but we can not avoid third morcha because in case of to avoid both party people will go for third front.

Santosh ji forgot third morcha. It is desire of only Mulayam Singh. It is assured that in coming general elections SP will disapper from UP.