Government Jobs vs Private Jobs. Which one is better?

53K Views
0 Replies
1 min read
Hi All,

Here is this week's topic for group discussion.

"Government Jobs vs Private Jobs. Which one is better?"

To know more about this contest Click Here

We are giving 50 points for all the members who post atleast 3 valid replies on Group Discussion topic. Replies should be in a constructive manner either oppose of supporting the topic.

Wish you all the best and be creative, informative and be sportive in taking feedback.

20 Replies

Yes Abid Areacode i am agree with you that the private sector is paying much money then govt sector and for that they are getting more work from then.
I have one more point in favor of govt sector is that private sector are getting lot of worker from there workers because they paying more money.So of this i have seen that this why there is lot of health problem to people in young age because of tension,as to perform well to get his job secure,listen to boss what he says etc this gives lot of tension in minds of the private worker people where as there is not tension and person work of his own and his not much effect on his mind.
As Per The GD Topic "Government Jobs vs Private Jobs. Which one is better?"

It is said that if you have dreams in your eyes and you wanna make it fulfill, then you have to put efforts for that dreams.

Government job is good because we don't have so much work load in that job and it makes lazyness inside the person. There is a growth in Government jobs but its after a long year of time. You will get promotion after 7 or 8 years normally. You can't be financially free. So i can't fulfill my dreams through government job.

In private sector SUCCESS = YOUR EFFORTS. i can put my best efforts, so i will get my dreams fulfill. In private sector we can get growth in couple of months and there is respect of our position and efforts in private sector. In private jobs no corruption is there. Very handsome salary. For getting a government job, firstly we have to arrange some lakhs rupess for corrupted persons.

In my words I am in favor private jobs.
Santosh Kumar Singh wrote:
[quote]As per my point of view

Govt job has more security and income vs private job but disadvantage of Govt job is there may be less growth but if we get money then there is no problem.

6th pay commission still not implemented in private sectors so if I have offer from both sector for job then i will select Govt. Job first.

so Govt job is best in anyway.[/quote]

Mr. Santosh sir, you are saying six pay commission is not implemented in private jobs. But i think there is no so much effect if six pay commission is not implement in private sector because in private jobs private job salary > Govt job + Six pay commission salary.

Getting money is not the issue. Money is coming in both types of jobs but the point is how much.
soubhagya das wrote:
[quote]I think private jobs are much more better than Government jobs.
Jobs are always depend upon the ability and patience of the employee so it is not that Government jobs are always safe than Private.

In private jobs they pay the salary as per the work, they have intensive extra remunerations etc.[/quote]

soubhagya das wrote:
[quote]In Private jobs people are mostly young and the selection process is very good because they check the over all of a person but in government job they just got selected by his certificate and just a formality personal interview.
Thats the main reason for which tough selection means quality employee in the organization.

In private jobs senior authority listen to the advise and suggestion of junior employee for improvement but in Government job they have a fixed rule for a certain period and they do work as per that term.
But Time never wait for any one but Government officers work always with old mind set up[/quote]


Yes sir i am agree with you in these words.
Lohit seth wrote:
[quote]As Per The GD Topic "Government Jobs vs Private Jobs. Which one is better?"

It is said that if you have dreams in your eyes and you wanna make it fulfill, then you have to put efforts for that dreams.

Government job is good because we don't have so much work load in that job and it makes lazyness inside the person. There is a growth in Government jobs but its after a long year of time. You will get promotion after 7 or 8 years normally. You can't be financially free. So i can't fulfill my dreams through government job.

In private sector SUCCESS = YOUR EFFORTS. i can put my best efforts, so i will get my dreams fulfill. In private sector we can get growth in couple of months and there is respect of our position and efforts in private sector. In private jobs no corruption is there. Very handsome salary. For getting a government job, firstly we have to arrange some lakhs rupess for corrupted persons.

In my words I am in favor private jobs.[/quote]

In my view it depends on the person which job he has to do govt.job or private job.Everybody has his/her choice.
Like Lohit you said there is no corruption in private sector in this point i am not totally agree with you.In private sector there is also lot of corruption.Here is some ex.When person don't give installments of the car then bank company take that car with them-self.Then workers used to sell that car to there relatives or other people by getting bride.I am studying in final year lot of private company came to college for placement they charged money from college where as govt companies came they don't charged anything from the college.So this too is corruption so corruption is also in private sector.
jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]As i am a student of final year and i also wanted to do Govt. job because in Govt. job your future is secure for your whole life as compare to privates job.In privates job you work very hard to earn money but now a days price rises of all the commodity is very high and its very difficult for private worker to afford very much for commodity because he/she has to save money for his health problem in future.Here are some points of different between the importance of the govt. job and private job.

1)In govt. jobs worker has not much tension of his/her work in every department of govt. where as in private sector person has to do well in in his job to get promotion.

2)In govt job there is not much pressure from the boss on the worker where as in private job worker as to work according the what boss has said.

3)In govt job there is pension after retirement from his/her job which is at least a secure life for the person in old age where as there is no pension in private sector after retirement from his/her job.person has to do work after his retirement to run his/her life in old age.

4)now a days health is now source of problem in all the age groups.The worker of Govt sector gets full treatment money from the Govt. where as in private sector person has to treatment of his/her now money.

In my view its better for person to worker in govt sector then private sector.[/quote]

Mr. Jasmeet Singh, i don't know why people going for government jobs. After reading your words, i think you are not updated with the private sector and government sector completely.

Firstly i wanna tell you, there is no future secure in government jobs or private jobs. Its in your destiny. You have to put your efforts, and i think you are not dedicated to your work because you don't wanna put efforts.

I am also a final year student of B.TECH, and i can also get government job easily as per my father's jack with starting salary of 20000, but i will not apply. I kneed to put my efforts to get success in this world.

you are saying about pension in government jobs. you know from where a government employee get his pension. From starting of his job to last year of his job, government cut some amount of money from his salary of every month. And in last that person get pension from this money which got cut from starting to last.

Now about Private sector pension plan. In these time private sector also giving pension. And there are a lot of plans which you can get regarding pension. pension in private sector is more than government sector and you will get from just your starting of retirement. In government jobs you have to give money to Corrupted person to get your pension.


About tension point, i think more tension in government sector, Prices are rising high and high, private jobs provides you financially free service not government job. Less salary in government jobs make you to take loans and loans which will give you more tension.

And hard work is the part of your life. you are a lazy person you don't wanna do hard work so go for government jobs and be corrupted. We are dedicated persons who wanna put our efforts in our success.
jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]Lohit seth wrote:
[quote]As Per The GD Topic "Government Jobs vs Private Jobs. Which one is better?"

It is said that if you have dreams in your eyes and you wanna make it fulfill, then you have to put efforts for that dreams.

Government job is good because we don't have so much work load in that job and it makes lazyness inside the person. There is a growth in Government jobs but its after a long year of time. You will get promotion after 7 or 8 years normally. You can't be financially free. So i can't fulfill my dreams through government job.

In private sector SUCCESS = YOUR EFFORTS. i can put my best efforts, so i will get my dreams fulfill. In private sector we can get growth in couple of months and there is respect of our position and efforts in private sector. In private jobs no corruption is there. Very handsome salary. For getting a government job, firstly we have to arrange some lakhs rupess for corrupted persons.

In my words I am in favor private jobs.[/quote]

In my view it depends on the person which job he has to do govt.job or private job.Everybody has his/her choice.
Like Lohit you said there is no corruption in private sector in this point i am not totally agree with you.In private sector there is also lot of corruption.Here is some ex.When person don't give installments of the car then bank company take that car with them-self.Then workers used to sell that car to there relatives or other people by getting bride.I am studying in final year lot of private company came to college for placement they charged money from college where as govt companies came they don't charged anything from the college.So this too is corruption so corruption is also in private sector.[/quote]

Dear jasmeet singh, priavte sector charges money for coming in colleges, then they have rights for this. If they are providing you good service then you have to do this. For every good thing you have to pay. Nothing is free int his world. Government sector not provides you all types of service. there is difference between implementation of rules and written rules.
Lohit seth wrote:
[quote]jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]As i am a student of final year and i also wanted to do Govt. job because in Govt. job your future is secure for your whole life as compare to privates job.In privates job you work very hard to earn money but now a days price rises of all the commodity is very high and its very difficult for private worker to afford very much for commodity because he/she has to save money for his health problem in future.Here are some points of different between the importance of the govt. job and private job.

1)In govt. jobs worker has not much tension of his/her work in every department of govt. where as in private sector person has to do well in in his job to get promotion.

2)In govt job there is not much pressure from the boss on the worker where as in private job worker as to work according the what boss has said.

3)In govt job there is pension after retirement from his/her job which is at least a secure life for the person in old age where as there is no pension in private sector after retirement from his/her job.person has to do work after his retirement to run his/her life in old age.

4)now a days health is now source of problem in all the age groups.The worker of Govt sector gets full treatment money from the Govt. where as in private sector person has to treatment of his/her now money.

In my view its better for person to worker in govt sector then private sector.[/quote]

Mr. Jasmeet Singh, i don't know why people going for government jobs. After reading your words, i think you are not updated with the private sector and government sector completely.

Firstly i wanna tell you, there is no future secure in government jobs or private jobs. Its in your destiny. You have to put your efforts, and i think you are not dedicated to your work because you don't wanna put efforts.

I am also a final year student of B.TECH, and i can also get government job easily as per my father's jack with starting salary of 20000, but i will not apply. I kneed to put my efforts to get success in this world.

you are saying about pension in government jobs. you know from where a government employee get his pension. From starting of his job to last year of his job, government cut some amount of money from his salary of every month. And in last that person get pension from this money which got cut from starting to last.

Now about Private sector pension plan. In these time private sector also giving pension. And there are a lot of plans which you can get regarding pension. pension in private sector is more than government sector and you will get from just your starting of retirement. In government jobs you have to give money to Corrupted person to get your pension.


About tension point, i think more tension in government sector, Prices are rising high and high, private jobs provides you financially free service not government job. Less salary in government jobs make you to take loans and loans which will give you more tension.

And hard work is the part of your life. you are a lazy person you don't wanna do hard work so go for government jobs and be corrupted. We are dedicated persons who wanna put our efforts in our success.[/quote]

Thank so much sir saying lazy person,not hard working person and not putting efforts in my life.Thanks for this wishes sir God bless you for your future.Sir i have lot of words to describe this posts answer but i don't think its right to explain my feeling to you.Thanks
jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]Lohit seth wrote:
[quote]jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]As i am a student of final year and i also wanted to do Govt. job because in Govt. job your future is secure for your whole life as compare to privates job.In privates job you work very hard to earn money but now a days price rises of all the commodity is very high and its very difficult for private worker to afford very much for commodity because he/she has to save money for his health problem in future.Here are some points of different between the importance of the govt. job and private job.

1)In govt. jobs worker has not much tension of his/her work in every department of govt. where as in private sector person has to do well in in his job to get promotion.

2)In govt job there is not much pressure from the boss on the worker where as in private job worker as to work according the what boss has said.

3)In govt job there is pension after retirement from his/her job which is at least a secure life for the person in old age where as there is no pension in private sector after retirement from his/her job.person has to do work after his retirement to run his/her life in old age.

4)now a days health is now source of problem in all the age groups.The worker of Govt sector gets full treatment money from the Govt. where as in private sector person has to treatment of his/her now money.

In my view its better for person to worker in govt sector then private sector.[/quote]

Mr. Jasmeet Singh, i don't know why people going for government jobs. After reading your words, i think you are not updated with the private sector and government sector completely.

Firstly i wanna tell you, there is no future secure in government jobs or private jobs. Its in your destiny. You have to put your efforts, and i think you are not dedicated to your work because you don't wanna put efforts.

I am also a final year student of B.TECH, and i can also get government job easily as per my father's jack with starting salary of 20000, but i will not apply. I kneed to put my efforts to get success in this world.

you are saying about pension in government jobs. you know from where a government employee get his pension. From starting of his job to last year of his job, government cut some amount of money from his salary of every month. And in last that person get pension from this money which got cut from starting to last.

Now about Private sector pension plan. In these time private sector also giving pension. And there are a lot of plans which you can get regarding pension. pension in private sector is more than government sector and you will get from just your starting of retirement. In government jobs you have to give money to Corrupted person to get your pension.


About tension point, i think more tension in government sector, Prices are rising high and high, private jobs provides you financially free service not government job. Less salary in government jobs make you to take loans and loans which will give you more tension.

And hard work is the part of your life. you are a lazy person you don't wanna do hard work so go for government jobs and be corrupted. We are dedicated persons who wanna put our efforts in our success.[/quote]

Thank so much sir saying lazy person,not hard working person and not putting efforts in my life.Thanks for this wishes sir God bless you for your future.Sir i have lot of words to describe this posts answer but i don't think its right to explain my feeling to you.Thanks[/quote]

Thanks Mr. Jasmeet singh, in my mind government job employees are lazy, because all day they sir in their office and do talkies. No dear explain in you can about this post. i will sure answer your post.
Amit Warkari wrote:
[quote]Hi All,
I think both have their pros & cons..

But,
At the end I think, Govt Jobs are more better..
Reasons:
1>Security of Job,
2>Work pressure not that high,
3>Extra benefits like accommodation, PF, Pension etc
4>Its more reputed.
5>Easy to get Loan...[/quote]


Amit warkari i am not agree with your points. Government jobs make you part of corruption and when you are in corrupted employees then you are not secure.

Work pressure in not high, its depends upon your position, whats the work pressure. And work pressure is not high ok but when salary is less and growth is less, then prices rising pressure will make you more in trouble.

Private jobs also gives accomodation, PF and pension facility these days. Which is much better than government job facilites.


Who told you government job is more reputed. Reputation depends upon person's efforts and its good work. Not through position. A bad politician has a big position, but in normal people eyes he has a reputation of like a corrupted dog.

Ha Ha Ha, easy to get loan. You mean private jobs employees not get loan easily. Dear first thing, private job employees ahve so much salary, so they don't need to take so much loan, and if they wanna they can easily get loan, because they have good salary and bank firstly see what is the salary return of that employee.
jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]Private jobs in my view is good for students to start work as a part time in call centers and MNC to get some experience how to work under the bosses.Like now more younger generation is doing part time jobs in call centers and insurance company which is helping them to get job placement after their studies.
IN this view i feel private sector is better for students to work part time with studies to earn experience.[/quote]

Jasmeet singh some amount of your words are right, but this is the good point of private jobs that you can earn according to your given time int his sector. Government jobs not provide these services. And If in market government job is 1, then in private sector jobs are 1000. According to population of India which is helping more for removing unemployeement. Just go to employement office which provides the service in government area. And check the documents how many persons got the job. A poor person can't give money in lakhs to a corrupted officer in government sector. But with his efforts he can get success in private sector.
jasmeet singh wrote:
[quote]Like your are saying that govt sector is working with old mind and functions as compare to private sector because govt sector which has been established has not to show much where as private sector has to work hard then they will be able to establish them self in the market

AT the time of recessions most of the private sectors were cosed due to that lot of people get unemployed as at this point of view govt sector is better.[/quote]

Dear Jasmeet singh in recession time India not get so much effects. And first thing companies only removes those employees which are not working properly. A employee which is giving benefit to private company why company will fired him.
Santosh Kumar Singh wrote:
[quote]This time I am doing private job. I feel that Private job is not good as Govt. Job.

In Private Job

There are lot of work pressure
Time limit to complete work
Boss some times misuse u and divert your work also.
You can not feel freedom anytime.[/quote]


Santosh sir, in private sector form one or some more time we have to put better efforts. So after this we can get easily good position. Remember in private job you can be boss in your department in just 3 or 4 years. But in government job, its not sure you will be boss or not.
Lohit its not so easy to get good position in Private sector there are lot of hard work and effort needed to get good position.
But in Govt job if you are not boss then it is ok you will enjoy with your position.

But in private sector job is one type of tarching of our life.

I think doing part time internet work is better than private job.
The main difference between govt and private is the profit motive. As the private business is for profit, employees are also treated like raw materials and other inputs. Naturally, the employer wants to get the most out of the employee. On the other hand, government is for managing national affairs. The politicians as well as government servants (bureaucrats as generally called) have an important role in national management. It is obvious that an I.A.S. officer and Military officer has higher social status than a private sector employee irrespective of money income. If you wish a prestigious career with security and have robust health with sports hobby, military service is best. I.A.S and other civil services give you a very promising and active role in national affairs. On the other hand, one who is more interested in money only, wants quick rise and is highly talented, private service especially in multinational may be okay.
I agree with what Gulshankumar ajmani told above.To get a commanding job like commissionar or district collector we have only the choice of Government job.HOw will you get it privately? You may get higher salaried job than this.But the reputation of that job will not be obtained.So if you look from any side government job is the best one.
Santosh Now days Government jobs has also lot of pressure.My father is a bank manager but he has to fill all his target I have seen he is now going to his big clients( account holder) to sell LIC policies because his bank has a tied up with LIc and branch manager has to fill that target.
CAn you imagine that situation.

Now pressure is every where thats why Government job employees are also taking VRS
Santosh Kumar Singh wrote:
[quote]Lohit its not so easy to get good position in Private sector there are lot of hard work and effort needed to get good position.
But in Govt job if you are not boss then it is ok you will enjoy with your position.

But in private sector job is one type of tarching of our life.

I think doing part time internet work is better than private job.[/quote]

Santosh sir from these lines i think you wanna say you don't like to do hard work. Yes this can be possible, if you don't wanna do hard work then go for government job.
Lohit seth wrote:
[quote]
you are saying about pension in government jobs. you know from where a government employee get his pension. From starting of his job to last year of his job, government cut some amount of money from his salary of every month. And in last that person get pension from this money which got cut from starting to last.


About tension point, i think more tension in government sector, Prices are rising high and high, private jobs provides you financially free service not government job. Less salary in government jobs make you to take loans and loans which will give you more tension.

[/quote]

You are absolutely wrong.The pension plan you told above is not the existing one in central or government jobs.I had heard contributory pension.There employee will deposit an amount and company will deposit the same and on retirement you will be paid from it.No employee in my state Kerala (State and central employees)undergoes the salary cutting for pension.Where does it exist?

Regarding tension, private job is more tensile.It is not predictable the mood of our boss if we makes mistake repeatedly.Even we may not be able to take a leave to relax from that state.But in Govt job your boss will be a friend of you.You can work quietly clearing your doubts.

You told about price hikes.You know there is one allowance called dearness allowance declared by government in every six months after reviewing the price index.Yesterday centre had decided to give 8% of basic pay as DA.With this the total DA will rise to 35%.Will any private sector do this?

Topic Author

M

Maverick

@maverick

Topic Stats

Created Monday, 15 March 2010 09:25
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 53K
Likes 0

Share This Topic