Hello Friends,
Today it is Children's day.So we can have a discussion on the burning issue in India.
Here is the topic for this week's discussion,
How child labour can be eradicated ?
As usual all members who post at least three valid answers will get 50 points as bonus and winners will get Rs 50 and Rs 25 as cash prize.
All the best guys!!
20 Replies
I agree with what Gulshan has said, there are enough laws and legislations that make child labour illegal. Even then minor children form the major part of our nation's work force, especially in industries such as hotels (canteens, roadside dhabas, many medium sized hotels in cities etc), fireworks, tobacco industries etc. What has failed here is the will to put the legislation into action, probably the reason for failure is that many hotels are either owned by or blessed by powerful politicians and also have policemen as their patrons.
The reasons these children end up working is because their parents do not have any kind of certain employment which will guarantee them a certain amount of fixed income every month. For such parents, it also means the more the hands there are to work, the better the money earned and end up giving birth to at least 4-5 children, who lose their childhood and innocence at an early age.
So the bottom line is if child labour needs to be eradicated, there should be proper employment provided to the parents!
The reasons these children end up working is because their parents do not have any kind of certain employment which will guarantee them a certain amount of fixed income every month. For such parents, it also means the more the hands there are to work, the better the money earned and end up giving birth to at least 4-5 children, who lose their childhood and innocence at an early age.
So the bottom line is if child labour needs to be eradicated, there should be proper employment provided to the parents!
there are enough laws for many things in the constituation especially for child labor but where it is lacking is following the laws is lacking. if they follow perfectly then there will be no child labor at all.
But we cannot abolish child labor in a night. It needs lot of service and hard work then only we can
But we cannot abolish child labor in a night. It needs lot of service and hard work then only we can
The laws in force are not at all followed up.Now I think the best way to eradicate this curse is strict punishment.Poverty being one of the reason it may be given relief in genuine cases.
correct..strict punishment for the defaulters will be the key for the eradication of child labor.but relief should never be given.
if relief is ever given in any circumstances even the real culprits will find a way to prove that they are poor and poverty is the cause.
I agree with what Gulshan has said, there are enough laws and legislations that make child labour illegal. Even then minor children form the major part of our nation's work force, especially in industries such as hotels (canteens, roadside dhabas, many medium sized hotels in cities etc), fireworks, tobacco industries etc. What has failed here is the will to put the legislation into action, probably the reason for failure is that many hotels are either owned by or blessed by powerful politicians and also have policemen as their patrons.
The reasons these children end up working is because their parents do not have any kind of certain employment which will guarantee them a certain amount of fixed income every month. For such parents, it also means the more the hands there are to work, the better the money earned and end up giving birth to at least 4-5 children, who lose their childhood and innocence at an early age.
So the bottom line is if child labour needs to be eradicated, there should be proper employment provided to the parents!
there are enough employment schemes too.......providing proper employment to the parents does not guarantee the eradication of this menace.we should aim at giving the parents proper education.no educated parent will ever send his/her child to do forced labour. hence the problem prevailing in the country is the lack of education among parents.
making the uneducated parents realize the folly of sending their child to forced labour will go a long way in solving this problem.i would like to quote here that the state with highest literacy in India- kerala, has the least number of cases in child labour.those reported have been children from other states of India where literacy has been a joke.
more and more NGOs should take up the job of making the parents understand this problem.education can change the world...has changed the world ......and will change the world.....
I don't really think it is practical for children at school level to earn while they learn because the emphasis would then automatically be on how much money they can make and education will become secondary. It would be better if such vocational courses with a stipend for the parents in economically weaker sections is given.Such programmes are available but the question again is same...who will enforce this??? It is we the people, the like minded ones, who have to take the responsibility of educating people and spreading general awareness in our vicinity.
In addition to what I have stated, there is need to raise a mass campaign against child labor. The people in general should be motivated to boycott shops, repair shops, restaurants where children are employed. Needless to say that most of law is not implemented because of corruption and public indifference. Corruption may not be removed easily but it will be easier to create public opinion and mass campaign which will go a long way in prevention of child labor and promotion of education.
Gulshan ji it is not possible.It can be possible only when the children parents must change first.
They must think about the childrens future.Then there wont be any child labour.
Our government must have strict rules against childlabour.
1.It must be cruel of Having penalty in lakhs.
2.It must no cease.If it is done they will open another shop in another place.Then same problem repeat.
3.The media must take an active part on it.
4.People must cooperate to government and Media.It will make easy to eradicate child labour.
They must think about the childrens future.Then there wont be any child labour.
Our government must have strict rules against childlabour.
1.It must be cruel of Having penalty in lakhs.
2.It must no cease.If it is done they will open another shop in another place.Then same problem repeat.
3.The media must take an active part on it.
4.People must cooperate to government and Media.It will make easy to eradicate child labour.
Gulshan ji it is not possible.It can be possible only when the children parents must change first.
They must think about the childrens future.Then there wont be any child labour.
Our government must have strict rules against childlabour.
1.It must be cruel of Having penalty in lakhs.
2.It must no cease.If it is done they will open another shop in another place.Then same problem repeat.
3.The media must take an active part on it.
4.People must cooperate to government and Media.It will make easy to eradicate child labour.
Mass awareness campaign will change the mindset of parents as well as user of services of establishments where children are employed. The mass campaign is necessary to bring an awareness among all. This will also compel the Labor department to be more vigilant in enforcing law on employing children in factories, shops and establishments.
Gulshanji,
In response to your reply above I remember a movement by a local body three years ago.In a panchayath in Wayanad District of Kerala all the shop keepers were decided not to take children undr 18 as their salesmen.They exhibitted a board regarding this in front of every shop.I don't know the condition now.Still it was a good movement.
In response to your reply above I remember a movement by a local body three years ago.In a panchayath in Wayanad District of Kerala all the shop keepers were decided not to take children undr 18 as their salesmen.They exhibitted a board regarding this in front of every shop.I don't know the condition now.Still it was a good movement.
Deapak wrote:[quote]
there are enough employment schemes too.......providing proper employment to the parents does not guarantee the eradication of this menace.we should aim at giving the parents proper education.no educated parent will ever send his/her child to do forced labour. hence the problem prevailing in the country is the lack of education among parents.
making the uneducated parents realize the folly of sending their child to forced labour will go a long way in solving this problem.i would like to quote here that the state with highest literacy in India- kerala, has the least number of cases in child labour.those reported have been children from other states of India where literacy has been a joke.
more and more NGOs should take up the job of making the parents understand this problem.education can change the world...has changed the world ......and will change the world..... [/quote]
I agree to some extent, the same applies to literacy campaigns too, there are enough schemes and laws etc. etc. but there is no enforcement, as is the case with employment schemes. Also, if you think about it, its a vicious circle - no money no education, hence no education no money! And if at all the parents need to be persuaded to realize the importance of sending their children to school, they should be in such a condition that they do not have to worry about how and where they are going to get their next meal. There are many jobs and trades that do not demand literal education but training in a particular trade and skill such as carpentry, masonary etc. that can be provided to people below poverty line so that they have assurance of income that guarantees at least two square meals a day so that they afford the luxury of government-sponsored free education to their children.
there are enough employment schemes too.......providing proper employment to the parents does not guarantee the eradication of this menace.we should aim at giving the parents proper education.no educated parent will ever send his/her child to do forced labour. hence the problem prevailing in the country is the lack of education among parents.
making the uneducated parents realize the folly of sending their child to forced labour will go a long way in solving this problem.i would like to quote here that the state with highest literacy in India- kerala, has the least number of cases in child labour.those reported have been children from other states of India where literacy has been a joke.
more and more NGOs should take up the job of making the parents understand this problem.education can change the world...has changed the world ......and will change the world..... [/quote]
I agree to some extent, the same applies to literacy campaigns too, there are enough schemes and laws etc. etc. but there is no enforcement, as is the case with employment schemes. Also, if you think about it, its a vicious circle - no money no education, hence no education no money! And if at all the parents need to be persuaded to realize the importance of sending their children to school, they should be in such a condition that they do not have to worry about how and where they are going to get their next meal. There are many jobs and trades that do not demand literal education but training in a particular trade and skill such as carpentry, masonary etc. that can be provided to people below poverty line so that they have assurance of income that guarantees at least two square meals a day so that they afford the luxury of government-sponsored free education to their children.
[quote]sasikanth wrote:
Gulshan ji it is not possible.It can be possible only when the children parents must change first.
They must think about the childrens future.Then there wont be any child labour.
Our government must have strict rules against childlabour.
1.It must be cruel of Having penalty in lakhs.
2.It must no cease.If it is done they will open another shop in another place.Then same problem repeat.
3.The media must take an active part on it.
4.People must cooperate to government and Media.It will make easy to eradicate child labour.
Mass awareness campaign will change the mindset of parents as well as user of services of establishments where children are employed. The mass campaign is necessary to bring an awareness among all. This will also compel the Labor department to be more vigilant in enforcing law on employing children in factories, shops and establishments. [/quote]
Mass awareness campaign is what is needed but along with that willingness of people to change their mindsets, and it is people like us who are the major portion of market today. for eg. we all know and are aware that the major portion of fireworks industry in Sivakashi employs young children to work in their factories, but have we stopped buying and burning enormous numbers of firecrackers??? NO! In fact, the use of crackers has increased to much much more extent, loud crackers are burst to mark every celebration, be it the birth day of someone in the family, be it diwali or anything else. If we stopped buying them, there would be definitely some kind of change that would compel these factory owners to stop employing minor children.
Gulshan ji it is not possible.It can be possible only when the children parents must change first.
They must think about the childrens future.Then there wont be any child labour.
Our government must have strict rules against childlabour.
1.It must be cruel of Having penalty in lakhs.
2.It must no cease.If it is done they will open another shop in another place.Then same problem repeat.
3.The media must take an active part on it.
4.People must cooperate to government and Media.It will make easy to eradicate child labour.
Mass awareness campaign will change the mindset of parents as well as user of services of establishments where children are employed. The mass campaign is necessary to bring an awareness among all. This will also compel the Labor department to be more vigilant in enforcing law on employing children in factories, shops and establishments. [/quote]
Mass awareness campaign is what is needed but along with that willingness of people to change their mindsets, and it is people like us who are the major portion of market today. for eg. we all know and are aware that the major portion of fireworks industry in Sivakashi employs young children to work in their factories, but have we stopped buying and burning enormous numbers of firecrackers??? NO! In fact, the use of crackers has increased to much much more extent, loud crackers are burst to mark every celebration, be it the birth day of someone in the family, be it diwali or anything else. If we stopped buying them, there would be definitely some kind of change that would compel these factory owners to stop employing minor children.
There is beyond an iota of doubt that children are the backbone of a nation. In fact, they are the future of any nation and therefore much attention should be given to children in order to reap huge benefits in future. But bone chilling fact is that they are not given much importance and goes through hardships in the form of child labor at such a tender age as childhood. It is very sad to note that a proportion of children is having fun and excitement in their life while the other portion is burdened with hard labor, physical torture, extortion etc.
Apart from the points which I have mentioned in my first post regarding elimination of child labor I would now move a step further to sight some more key points to eradicate the same....
** Organized Activity against child labor-- Organized activities against child labor should be held by the organizations like Labor Parties, NGO's etc from time to time to make the offenders recognize that people of the world are conscious about the child labor issues and its high time they should give up this habit or else they might have to be ready to meet the outcomes. For example, the ILO is doing it once a year and other organizations should come at forefront to join the same.
** Pressure from Human Rights Groups-- Human Right Groups should come into action and give this issue much priority and importance than any other issues. Yes, they are the right person to raise this issue at the forefront so that it comes under the strict vigilance of others.
** Factory owners should follow child labor laws-- Factory owners should follow proper child labor laws and should not employ children to get their works done or to extort them. Before employing anyone they should maintain and follow proper rules and procedures and do not indulge in the violation of the same.
** Consumer education and Awareness-- This is one of the most vital weapon to get control over the menace. Much of the things are going on because it is not disclosed to the masses and things are under the carpet. I think media, internet and advertisement would definitely help to aware the people and the problem could well be brought under control.
** Birth rate control-- Overpopulation is also adding to the problem in one way or the other. Often larger families with five or six children are the victims of child labor. Through proper family planning such problem could be control and even parents would be able to give proper education to them...!
Apart from the points which I have mentioned in my first post regarding elimination of child labor I would now move a step further to sight some more key points to eradicate the same....
** Organized Activity against child labor-- Organized activities against child labor should be held by the organizations like Labor Parties, NGO's etc from time to time to make the offenders recognize that people of the world are conscious about the child labor issues and its high time they should give up this habit or else they might have to be ready to meet the outcomes. For example, the ILO is doing it once a year and other organizations should come at forefront to join the same.
** Pressure from Human Rights Groups-- Human Right Groups should come into action and give this issue much priority and importance than any other issues. Yes, they are the right person to raise this issue at the forefront so that it comes under the strict vigilance of others.
** Factory owners should follow child labor laws-- Factory owners should follow proper child labor laws and should not employ children to get their works done or to extort them. Before employing anyone they should maintain and follow proper rules and procedures and do not indulge in the violation of the same.
** Consumer education and Awareness-- This is one of the most vital weapon to get control over the menace. Much of the things are going on because it is not disclosed to the masses and things are under the carpet. I think media, internet and advertisement would definitely help to aware the people and the problem could well be brought under control.
** Birth rate control-- Overpopulation is also adding to the problem in one way or the other. Often larger families with five or six children are the victims of child labor. Through proper family planning such problem could be control and even parents would be able to give proper education to them...!
It seems to be a very easy topic but after reading so many responses, it actually seems to be more than what is seen.
Many of us see that valid steps have to be taken by the government like correctly mentioned in the arenas of education, self awareness and employment.
Although many steps have been taken, I believe its nearly impossible for this evil to be eradicated because of lack of the will to change.
There is truth in the fact that poverty plays a major role in child labor,but the fact that there is a class of people fanning the evil fire because of greed and adamance.
Ask any child who is working,he'll tell you he needs to support sibling and parents.In most cases the elders would demand money for their own expenditures.
Children would not want to go to school on their own, they have to be motivated.Parents of these children donot want to send them to school for the fact they want to earn through them and in my experience I feel they are very well aware of the government benefits that are available for their children.
I don't think they are unaware of the job opportunities either,unfortunately they donot want to go and earn and use their children instead.
I'm not disagreeing with anything said until now, but I feel that society needs a mind shift in enormously in order to eradicate Child labour.
Many of us see that valid steps have to be taken by the government like correctly mentioned in the arenas of education, self awareness and employment.
Although many steps have been taken, I believe its nearly impossible for this evil to be eradicated because of lack of the will to change.
There is truth in the fact that poverty plays a major role in child labor,but the fact that there is a class of people fanning the evil fire because of greed and adamance.
Ask any child who is working,he'll tell you he needs to support sibling and parents.In most cases the elders would demand money for their own expenditures.
Children would not want to go to school on their own, they have to be motivated.Parents of these children donot want to send them to school for the fact they want to earn through them and in my experience I feel they are very well aware of the government benefits that are available for their children.
I don't think they are unaware of the job opportunities either,unfortunately they donot want to go and earn and use their children instead.
I'm not disagreeing with anything said until now, but I feel that society needs a mind shift in enormously in order to eradicate Child labour.
It seems to be a very easy topic but after reading so many responses, it actually seems to be more than what is seen.
Many of us see that valid steps have to be taken by the government like correctly mentioned in the arenas of education, self awareness and employment.
Although many steps have been taken, I believe its nearly impossible for this evil to be eradicated because of lack of the will to change.
There is truth in the fact that poverty plays a major role in child labor,but the fact that there is a class of people fanning the evil fire because of greed and adamance.
Ask any child who is working,he'll tell you he needs to support sibling and parents.In most cases the elders would demand money for their own expenditures.
Children would not want to go to school on their own, they have to be motivated.Parents of these children donot want to send them to school for the fact they want to earn through them and in my experience I feel they are very well aware of the government benefits that are available for their children.
I don't think they are unaware of the job opportunities either,unfortunately they donot want to go and earn and use their children instead.
I'm not disagreeing with anything said until now, but I feel that society needs a mind shift in enormously in order to eradicate Child labour.
I agree that a change of mind is necessary. This can be done by building a very strong campaign against child employment. It is obvious that poor parents are lured by immediate income of child. They need to appreciate that a few years of education will enable their child to earn more and get a good status in society. This is also possible by a powerful campaign only. It is also true that children are to be motivated. some degree of compulsion is also necessary. There should be penalties and disincentives for motivating children to work. Political and social organizations can play a good role in this. The municipal counselors, MLA, MPs should ensure compliance of law against child labor in their constituencies.
First we have to think why they are looking for jobs?
They need money, so we have to fulfill their basic financial needs like money for food, cloths and other simple things. Once they fulfill all the basic needs they automatically go to school and the children never think to get into job.
They need money, so we have to fulfill their basic financial needs like money for food, cloths and other simple things. Once they fulfill all the basic needs they automatically go to school and the children never think to get into job.
Topic Author
A
Abid Areacode
@Abid Areacode
Topic Stats
Created
Monday, 14 November 2011 10:30
Last Updated
Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies
0
Views
8K
Likes
0