20 Replies

Indian culture should be taught in schools also, but before that a common definition should be arrived at

Religion and culture are different. Culture is more affected by region rather than religion. Religion also affects culture to some extent but mainly it is region that affects culture and language. It is futile to talk of Hindu or Muslim culture.  Bengali Hindu and Bengali Muslim have more in common than a Rajasthani Muslim and Bengali Muslim. 

One thing which is pushing back our people from our own culture is the attraction towards western culture. Parents think that it is beneficial to put our kids in English medium school, their names should look modern. Children also think following western culture looks stylish and modern. Even in villages people get attracted towards western culture, no one in today's generation wants to follow Indian culture because people think that if they not follow western culture they will remain behind. 

It's not right to think that if one follows Indian culture they will remain behind.  If the parents talk in their mother tongue with their children in the Home, children will certainly know the value of their Mother tongue. It all depends on the Home atmosphere and the parents.

 

rambabu wrote:

It's not right to think that if one follows Indian culture they will remain behind.  If the parents talk in their mother tongue with their children in the Home, children will certainly know the value of their Mother tongue. It all depends on the Home atmosphere and the parents.

 

Parents should talk in mother tongue at home, but most of parents are working and they think that talking to their kids in English will improve their communication skills in English. Today in almost all jobs in India English is required, so parents think to improve English skills of their kids. 

 

Manoj Kumar Lamba wrote:
rambabu wrote:

It's not right to think that if one follows Indian culture they will remain behind.  If the parents talk in their mother tongue with their children in the Home, children will certainly know the value of their Mother tongue. It all depends on the Home atmosphere and the parents.

 

Parents should talk in mother tongue at home, but most of parents are working and they think that talking to their kids in English will improve their communication skills in English. Today in almost all jobs in India English is required, so parents think to improve English skills of their kids. 

Communicating in Mother Tongue, children will be benefited . , it helps in learning many languages including English. This was pointed out in in my previous posts.

 

 

That is why we must first define what exactly is meant by Indian culture .For many it is religion which is not true. People are attracted to English because it ensures a job and bread and butter. One can also learn mother tongue.

When I said Mother tongue, it is the Mother tongue of the individual. It has got nothing to do with religion. Even a tribal will be having his Mother tongue and there are stories in their Mother tongue. He will tell these tales to his children

Learning English is the need of the hour but that does not mean that those who study or studied in English medium schools are all against Indian culture or are not aware about Indian culture. Even English medium girls schools and colleges directly or indirectly expect their students to wear saree on farewell day or foundation day and so on. This is how we learn to give importance to our Indian costume. Now, when the trend setters go for western style then how can we expect the younger generation to follow the Indian style. So, it will be wrong to raise finger towards English medium schools. Indian culture has to be practised at home, school as well as the big guns must also promote it or else the youngsters will not follow the Indian culture be it the age old traditions, literature, music and many more.

I studied in English medium schools in another state.But my parents always used to speak with me in Telugu. This enabled me to learn later Hindi and  Urdu. After my college education, when I'm employed in a Steel plant that was built with the collaboration of Russia, I learned Russian language. All this was possible because my  parents used to communicate with me in my Mother tongue right from childhood. My daughter who settled in the USA talks in Telugu with her children. It's not all, she made her children learn Kuchipudi, the traditional dance form of Andhra. Its all about parenting.

 

Many languages can be learned even if one does not know one's mother tongue. The two have no corelation.  Not knowing mother tongue does not dilute one's love for their culture. Yes knowing mother tongue is good but can not be used as a brownie scoring point over someone who does not know it. 

If one has the ability to learn many other languages without knowing the Mother tongue, it's a blessing.

 

We have to speak with our children in our mother-tongue. They should learn to read and write in their own language. Mother-tongue is a fundamental part of our cultural identity. It is also good to teach our children the languages of other states. This is the best way to learn about the cultures of that states. But today's children cannot go forward  without English. Therefore, we should train our children at home also to talk in English, but not always. English is the only language to communicate with the people of other countries. 

We have to speak with our children in our mother-tongue. They should learn to read and write in their own language. Mother-tongue is a fundamental part of our cultural identity. It is also good to teach our children the languages of other states. This is the best way to learn about the cultures of that states. But today's children cannot go forward  without English. Therefore, we should train our children at home also to talk in English, but not always. English is the only language to communicate with the people of other countries. 

English is the Lingua franka. In today's world to learn English is essential. But it doesn't mean one ignores his Mother tongue

 

Yes, we should respect our mother-tongue like our mothers. There are some parents around us who do not like to talk in mother-tongue. Therefore, their children cannot talk in their regional languages. They always talk in English and compel their children to talk only this foreign language. The attitude of such parents are talk in English is the best way to keep their status in the society.  

Talking about culture should not be restricted to mother tongue. Culture is a wide spectrum from language to clothing, to living style, to eating habit, to literature, to music, to communication pattern and what not. So, let's talk about various aspects of Indian culture and not just about mother tongue. I am in favour of learning mother tongue but sometimes due to various causes one fails to adopt one's mother tongue but knows Hindi or any other regional language quite well then I think it greatly signifies his/her awareness about Indian culture. Knowledge of mother tongue cannot be the yardstick of Indian culture. 

If one cannot talk in his Mother tongue. it's ok. But, later on  when they grow up,children will know about their Mother tongue from their parents. If parents too do not know what their Mother tongue is, then rises the problem.

 

Not knowing mother tongue is no longer a problem. There are many third generation persons who do not know it and are doing fine.

Topic Author

R

rambabu

@rambabu

Topic Stats

Created Monday, 28 December 2015 02:03
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.2K
Likes 1

Share This Topic