Was "Gumnami Baba" the Subash Chandra Bose.?

It might be but it all shrouded in mystery. As far as me to be believed, Netaji born in Orissa at Cuttack, the oldest capital of Odisha, and his ancestors are from Puri town my birth place, and we all beleived he returned here as some baba and everyday he visits Lord Jagannath during morning alati at four am and then he returned as my grand father used to believe and most people of Puri seems to believe but I cannot guarantee the veracity of these facts.

There are such rumors about Netaji ever since he disappeared believed to have died in a plane accident. Most of this talk has been ruled out because, if he is Bose, what is stopping him to come out into the open ?

 

mohan manohar wrote:It might be but it all shrouded in mystery. As far as me to be believed, Netaji born in Orissa at Cuttack, the oldest capital of Odisha, and his ancestors are from Puri town my birth place, and we all beleived he returned here as some baba and everyday he visits Lord Jagannath during morning alati at four am and then he returned as my grand father used to believe and most people of Puri seems to believe but I cannot guarantee the veracity of these facts.

Some facts were similar to Netaji, such as date of birth of both are same, that 23rd of Jan. But no one is sure that he was Subhash Chandra Bose. Only people believe that it would happen that the saint was real Netaji.

No chance. Even if he is alive what may be the reason to hide himself ? If he comes out people will be happy. It is the handiwork pf rumor mongers.

 

I belive so at the cost of being disputed for my saying so. As far I am concerned I have seen him in a documentry in 1971 made during Nehruji last darshan in 1964.

Undoubtedly will be disputed. Because the subject itself is dead. More than that the subject has become stale.

 

There are variouis reasons why subhash Chand Bose could not openly appear in India. He was an ally of the vanquished axis group of Germany, Italy and Japan. India had got independence in a contitutional way and so was duty bound to hand over Bose to allied powers as he was most probably a war criminal. So it is possible that if alive, he would be living in disguise. So the possibility of Gumnami Baba or shaulmari Ashram Basba or someone beiong subhash Chand Bose cannot be ruled out. But at this stage the matter is not relevant. The entie matter will remain a mystery for ever. 

As Bose went without trace, it has given rise to many legends about his existence. If I understood Bose correctly, if he had survived the crash and managed to reach India. he was man enough to come out in open and was not a coward to remain hidden for fear of being arrested and handed over to allied power. Would people have allowed it?.Which allied country did he invade and what support he provided to axis countries.But yes who will bell the cat.

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

There are variouis reasons why subhash Chand Bose could not openly appear in India. He was an ally of the vanquished axis group of Germany, Italy and Japan. India had got independence in a contitutional way and so was duty bound to hand over Bose to allied powers as he was most probably a war criminal. So it is possible that if alive, he would be living in disguise. So the possibility of Gumnami Baba or shaulmari Ashram Basba or someone beiong subhash Chand Bose cannot be ruled out. But at this stage the matter is not relevant. The entie matter will remain a mystery for ever. 

 

Exactly. At this stage this matter is irrelevant. It is better to accept this matter as a mystery forever.

 

A saint "Gumnami Baba" lived in Faizabad in U.P. Some people believe that he was "Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose". And some deny. No one knows about the reality.

http://www.jankipul.com/2015/04/blog-post_17.html

http://navbharattimes.indiatimes.com/state/uttar-pradesh/ayodhya/faizabad/gumnami-baba-memorial-to-come-up-in-faizabad-soon/articleshow/48064745.cms

http://www.bbc.com/hindi/india/2013/02/130213_netaji_gumnami_faizabad_partone_ns

 

It is indeed something to ponder about although it is too late now to do anything about it...It also gives rise to many other thoughts as to why Bose remained annonnymous in his own country !!!!

I don't see any reason why Netaji should should remain in exile even after independence. This makes me believe that he really died in the air accident which was the talk during many years ago. Anyhow as Gulshanji said this is a matter irrelevant to the present.

 

It is not so irrelevant because by keeping the issue alive certain leaders of the past are sullied by vested interests, from time to time.

rambabu wrote:

I don't see any reason why Netaji should should remain in exile even after independence. This makes me believe that he really died in the air accident which was the talk during many years ago. Anyhow as Gulshanji said this is a matter irrelevant to the present.

 

If you feel so, I lock this thread for further discussion.