MNS chief has banned these 2 films. This is something that should have been done earlier. I wonder why Shahrukh Khan's films were not banned totally by Indians as he is a known supporter of Pak.
Please refer http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/mns-threatens-beat-filmmakers-work-pakistan-artistes/1/784252.html
Army has rightfully rejected the 5 crore donation. CM is trying to wriggle out but had aranged the meeting for this settlement. MNS has no standing yet BJP chose to yield because it wants to spite Shiv Sena. Why do BJP people think that they have to teach patriotism to Indians?
RAMBABU has no qualms and generates his own comments. Best is to not engage with hypothetical statements.
In this case what the Maharashtra CM has done was to dilute the issue which may or may not be right but there have been a number of instances when the opposition has openly gone on to appease minority community even when the mistake was from their side probably with the same intention..So there is no point in being judgmental and throw stones since all political parties are sitting within a glass house .
Shampa Sadhya wrote:Army welfare association has opposed to such type of donation because for them it's not donation but extortion. Secondly, the Maharashtra CM has denied the financial angle. I am dead against of including Pakistani artistes in this scenario but the movies which are in trouble did not rope in those artistes after Uri attack but it happened long back. So, we must act reasonably.
Hindus have always acted reaasonably. MOhammed of Ghor was allowed to escape by Prithviraj and he came back and killed him. He was being 'reasonable'. What a shame we cant even the MNS stick to a stand taken
The press is consistently against MNS and right wing parties since 1947. A simple act is portrayed as 'extortion'. In fact, people like Karan Johar must be asked to pay 50 crores so that sets an example and such a thing will not happen again. Regarding the 5 cr for relief fund I am checking and will come back. The fact is the fund has only 1.4 cr and this 5 cr should be welcome for the war widows. Has anybody asked them?
The point is how can an non Constitutional body dictate a settlement to a Constitutional body? There are enough non Constitutional bodies operating in sensitive states of India. Do they also have same rights? There is no question of left wing or right wing. Prithviraj's decision to allow Ghori to escape was his personal decision and Hinduism has nothing to do with it. If he belonged to another religion would he have acted differently? It was his personality making him take such decision. BJP released some terrorists in exchange for hostages. They have since made deadly attacks. Was it a Hindu decision?
MG Singh wrote:The press is consistently against MNS and right wing parties since 1947. A simple act is portrayed as 'extortion'. In fact, people like Karan Johar must be asked to pay 50 crores so that sets an example and such a thing will not happen again. Regarding the 5 cr for relief fund I am checking and will come back. The fact is the fund has only 1.4 cr and this 5 cr should be welcome for the war widows. Has anybody asked them?
Inforation and Broadcasting Minister Venkiaha Naidu termed as wrong, MNS demand of 5 Crore from Karan Johar for resolving the Controversy over his Movie Ae Dil Hai ....and said the Government is nothing to do.
In the India context even a ordinance Passed by the govt , right or wrong was not spared by its own party scion thereby insulting the elected PM so why point fingers at MNS
vijay wrote:A few minutes back a TV channel has exposed how MNS extracts money for staging protests and makes money to sustain itself. The die-hard MNS supporters in the forum will obviously not believe it.
I think none of us supported them for their goonism. It was the act to ban the movies that was appreciated as it was in sync with the sentiments of citizens at this time. But this extraction of money somehow has diluted the real intention and in fact has taken a different route from patriotism and is back to the extortion and goon style of MNS
The release of Movie ADHD is set for release after Karan Johar and other producers promised Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis that they will not work with Pakistani Artists in future. Any how i can say MNS succeeded in its mission that Pakistani Artists should not be allowed in the Movies made by Indian Producers.. I do not know if it is a publicity stunt or not.
rambabu wrote:The release of Movie ADHD is set for release after Karan Johar and other producers promised Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis that they will not work with Pakistani Artists in future. Any how i can say MNS succeeded in its mission that Pakistani Artists should not be allowed in the Movies made by Indian Producers.. I do not know if it is a publicity stunt or not.
It will make no difference that it is publicity or stunt, it is enough that this picture is released. It is also good that producers promised will not work with Pakistani artists. India have good artists.
anil wrote:rambabu wrote:The release of Movie ADHD is set for release after Karan Johar and other producers promised Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis that they will not work with Pakistani Artists in future. Any how i can say MNS succeeded in its mission that Pakistani Artists should not be allowed in the Movies made by Indian Producers.. I do not know if it is a publicity stunt or not.
It will make no difference that it is publicity or stunt, it is enough that this picture is released. It is also good that producers promised will not work with Pakistani artists. India have good artists.
Well the producer also promised to donate 5 Cr to the army welfare fund.... Whch did not happen... So it needs to be seen if they will keep their word on that.
@emge