All are born equal. It is the environment in which one grows which shapes his intellect levels as that determines his/her levels of exposure to the contents of the world outside. The home and school and teachers also play a very important role in one's intelligence level attainment. Exceptions in both directions also occur. An intelligent person usually is well read the converse may not necessarily be true. Experience acts like a chisel sharpening the intellect.
vijay wrote:All are born equal. It is the environment in which one grows which shapes his intellect levels as that determines his/her levels of exposure to the contents of the world outside. The home and school and teachers also play a very important role in one's intelligence level attainment. Exceptions in both directions also occur. An intelligent person usually is well read the converse may not necessarily be true. Experience acts like a chisel sharpening the intellect.
I am tempted to narrate some stories. There is a Sanskrit language story of a boy who learnt astrology. He weant to king's court with his father. The king tried to test his knolwdge. He asked what was in his hand. The boy found out astrologocally that the king had something round shaped with some hole. He quickly told. The king joyously asked- Correct. Now tell what is exactly this. The boy said- ginding machine. He could not even understand that the grinding machine was too big to hide in hands. The king had a ring in his palm. This shows that knowledgeable person may not be intelligent.
another story. a very learned man crossed a river in a boat. He asked the boatman if he knew Sanskrit. The boatman replied- No. Then 25% of your life is wasted- said the man. Nest he asked if he knew mathematics. The boatman did not knbow. He was illiterate. As illuck would have it, a fierce storm and heavy rain disbalanced the boat. The boatman asked- Do you know swimming? No- said the learned man. Boatman said- Your whole life is waste.
Everyone has knowlege. But all knowledge is not useful everywhere. Where swimming is needed, maths, Sanskrit, Vedas are of no use.
You are intelligent if tyou can use your knowledge correctly. You are intelligent if your knowledge is practical.
Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:vijay wrote:All are born equal. It is the environment in which one grows which shapes his intellect levels as that determines his/her levels of exposure to the contents of the world outside. The home and school and teachers also play a very important role in one's intelligence level attainment. Exceptions in both directions also occur. An intelligent person usually is well read the converse may not necessarily be true. Experience acts like a chisel sharpening the intellect.
I am tempted to narrate some stories. There is a Sanskrit language story of a boy who learnt astrology. He weant to king's court with his father. The king tried to test his knolwdge. He asked what was in his hand. The boy found out astrologocally that the king had something round shaped with some hole. He quickly told. The king joyously asked- Correct. Now tell what is exactly this. The boy said- ginding machine. He could not even understand that the grinding machine was too big to hide in hands. The king had a ring in his palm. This shows that knowledgeable person may not be intelligent.
another story. a very learned man crossed a river in a boat. He asked the boatman if he knew Sanskrit. The boatman replied- No. Then 25% of your life is wasted- said the man. Nest he asked if he knew mathematics. The boatman did not knbow. He was illiterate. As illuck would have it, a fierce storm and heavy rain disbalanced the boat. The boatman asked- Do you know swimming? No- said the learned man. Boatman said- Your whole life is waste.
Everyone has knowlege. But all knowledge is not useful everywhere. Where swimming is needed, maths, Sanskrit, Vedas are of no use.
You are intelligent if tyou can use your knowledge correctly. You are intelligent if your knowledge is practical.
Both the examples say in no uncertain terms that knowledge without application to real life situation is an exercise in futility.
I totally agree that environment plays an essential part in shaping ones intelligent.A child born in a middle class home with an average intelligence if given the right exposure would be able to fine tune its intellectual skills , which probably will not be possible if there is no such exposure.
Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:vijay wrote:All are born equal. It is the environment in which one grows which shapes his intellect levels as that determines his/her levels of exposure to the contents of the world outside. The home and school and teachers also play a very important role in one's intelligence level attainment. Exceptions in both directions also occur. An intelligent person usually is well read the converse may not necessarily be true. Experience acts like a chisel sharpening the intellect.
I am tempted to narrate some stories. There is a Sanskrit language story of a boy who learnt astrology. He weant to king's court with his father. The king tried to test his knolwdge. He asked what was in his hand. The boy found out astrologocally that the king had something round shaped with some hole. He quickly told. The king joyously asked- Correct. Now tell what is exactly this. The boy said- ginding machine. He could not even understand that the grinding machine was too big to hide in hands. The king had a ring in his palm. This shows that knowledgeable person may not be intelligent.
another story. a very learned man crossed a river in a boat. He asked the boatman if he knew Sanskrit. The boatman replied- No. Then 25% of your life is wasted- said the man. Nest he asked if he knew mathematics. The boatman did not knbow. He was illiterate. As illuck would have it, a fierce storm and heavy rain disbalanced the boat. The boatman asked- Do you know swimming? No- said the learned man. Boatman said- Your whole life is waste.
Everyone has knowlege. But all knowledge is not useful everywhere. Where swimming is needed, maths, Sanskrit, Vedas are of no use.
You are intelligent if tyou can use your knowledge correctly. You are intelligent if your knowledge is practical.
All of us people are a sum total of our experiences and knowledge gained through books , education and life. And we all have beliefs and prejudices and an intelligent mind would analyse before believing in anything, also evaluate and use knowledge to their advantage. It is also true that you are constantly learning and changing ideas , unless one is extremely rigid ! An intelligent person is not wary of being exposed to new ideas and gaining new knowledge irrespective of it being bad or good because he or she is able to discern the useful from the dross !
@Usha.
Admitting and recognizing the vital importance of environment which does provide stimuli in the growth and development of intelligence,how can we
hold that all we are born intelligent ignoring its non-sustainanability in the light of new discoveries in the field of science? When even in a family varying degrees of intelligence or its absence exist among its members,no such sweeping generalizations should be made. About reading and intelligence I have this real life story to add.Once the daughter of a serving judge developed a love affair and eloped with her lover much to the intense dislike and embarrassment of the judge who,being distraught with anger was planning all kinds of legal and not-so-legal actions to undo it.Then it fell to the lot of his semi-literate peon to advise his erudite master that all his madly planned action would fetch more disgrace and embarrassment for him and there the master relented!
All intelligent persons are not similar just as all duffers are not similar. It is these environment and one's reactions to it that shapes the nature of a person.There is a particular threshold above which one is supposed to be in possession of intelligence. Reading broadens intelligence as it equips one with knowledge which helps in decision making. Intelligence helps in grasping issues faster. How a person reacts is generally decided by his nature and the type of attitudes he has towards issues. Intelligence has nothing to do with it. We often see many of our intelligent leaders reacting in a regressive manner to issues of religion.
@Chinmoy
I may be wrong but from what I have seen many very well read intelligent people become irrational when it comes to emotional issues like their loved ones and family, they simply go berserk . The peon was probably more rational in hos thinking because he had no emotions attached to the issue. I guess even the most intelligent and well read people have their Achilles heel !
I agree Chinmoy, one has to have inherited genes and the right environment to bring up a genius . That's how we see some dullards in the same family.When you look at the great contributors in any field, the offspring in many cases fail to live come up to their level. I guess there is imbalance somewhere either in their genes or their environment
chinmoymukherjee wrote:@Usha I regard the biological source as the primary one and environment to be the facilitating source of intelligence which,to my mind,could be the only rational explanation for varying degrees of intelligence and stupidity both.Otherwise we would be having thousands of Vivekanandas nd Tagores in our midst!!
True and this is what Behavioral genetics is all about. Firstly, not all traits are inherited equally otherwise there would not be any variation .Secondly, environment affects the genes to bring about further differences. Differences therefore are seen among individuals in terms of intelligence, behavior, looks and various abilities such as art , craft, music etc.
There is saying in Sanskrit. Pandita Putra Sunthaha. Means a sholar's son need not be a scholar always. All traits of a parent generally need not be inherited by the children. In this respect, environment in and around the house and changing times play a key role in shaping a person.
@Usha That was the larger and exact point I was driving at and you have got it so well by summing it up aptly!
Thanks a lot Chinmoy..
Broadly speaking while well read people are intelligent or even brilliant, not all of them may be street smart or possess common sense.This is something we come across often with regard to scholars and scientists who fail to understand the value of inter personal relationships and other such issues. We have a family friend the name I would not like to disclose ,suffice to say he is a well known personality hailing from our part.He is brilliant, can speak on every subject possible but when it is a question of maintaining his relationships he is a total failure- bad vibes with siblings, two failed marriages, and two failed relationships,no rapport with his children ! Makes one think whether too much of intelligence take its toll on a person ?
@kiran8