Congrats to all the member who won DFAA. Have lots of fun. Sasikanth you have done so well. Keep it up.

Ronark,

What you pointed is a loophole only.He may not have cared it.As GD moderator I participate in GDs .I can compete with the participants.But as I decide the winner can I declare myself as winner?

Thank you gulshan ji you have cleared doubts of us.Moderator is also elligible for DFAA

A moderator is eligible for DFAA. But it is doubtful whether a moderator can give award to himself. Ronark takes decision in DFAA. I doubt whether he can give award to himself. I think that previously, no moderator gave award to himself/ herself.

You kept again us in doubt who will clear our doubt. :) :) :( :(

You kept again us in doubt who will clear our doubt. :) :) :( :(

Nobody may give any award to himself. This is logical. But actual position can be explained only by maverick.

[quote]Why can't a moderator be a member and win DFAA. If a moderator is active then i think he should get DFAA.
I want to clear this from maverick. He would better to answer this.
And when i had send the result to maverick,he didn't told me about this,so i think he is also agree that Moderator can be a winner.

Lets see what maverick has to see on this. [/quote]

Ronark, it does not make sense if you are a moderator of the topic and declare yourself a winner. There is no doubt that in spite of being a moderator, you can actively participate in the discussions, but if you declare yourself a winner then it would be a biased opinion. Also it is a general rule that a judge should never declare himself a winner, he would not remain a judge then. For you to win, you have other threads in GD, Top Voter etc. etc. along with revenue sharing. I share responsibility with Abid for the GD thread and it was made clear that when I initiate the GD, then Abid can compete and win but I can only participate, I am not eligible for winning; and vice versa when Abid initiates the GD.

good idea. Now everybody will participate in the forum daily .

[quote]Why can't a moderator be a member and win DFAA. If a moderator is active then i think he should get DFAA.
I want to clear this from maverick. He would better to answer this.
And when i had send the result to maverick,he didn't told me about this,so i think he is also agree that Moderator can be a winner.

Lets see what maverick has to see on this.

Ronark, it does not make sense if you are a moderator of the topic and declare yourself a winner. There is no doubt that in spite of being a moderator, you can actively participate in the discussions, but if you declare yourself a winner then it would be a biased opinion. Also it is a general rule that a judge should never declare himself a winner, he would not remain a judge then. For you to win, you have other threads in GD, Top Voter etc. etc. along with revenue sharing. I share responsibility with Abid for the GD thread and it was made clear that when I initiate the GD, then Abid can compete and win but I can only participate, I am not eligible for winning; and vice versa when Abid initiates the GD.[/quote]
I really don't understand why i can't be winner. Ok. If this is the rule all want to follow,I don't want to be the judge of DFAA. Not fair.
In this site,most of the time i use to work in forums and if i am not allowed to win here,i don't want to be the judge of DFAA.

Maverick sir,please comment on this,your decision will be final.

In any game or context judge can not be player either you can get judge benefit or winner benefit it depends upon you what you want to select.

like in cricket Umpire and player are different.

[quote]Why can't a moderator be a member and win DFAA. If a moderator is active then i think he should get DFAA.
I want to clear this from maverick. He would better to answer this.
And when i had send the result to maverick,he didn't told me about this,so i think he is also agree that Moderator can be a winner.

Lets see what maverick has to see on this.

Ronark, it does not make sense if you are a moderator of the topic and declare yourself a winner. There is no doubt that in spite of being a moderator, you can actively participate in the discussions, but if you declare yourself a winner then it would be a biased opinion. Also it is a general rule that a judge should never declare himself a winner, he would not remain a judge then. For you to win, you have other threads in GD, Top Voter etc. etc. along with revenue sharing. I share responsibility with Abid for the GD thread and it was made clear that when I initiate the GD, then Abid can compete and win but I can only participate, I am not eligible for winning; and vice versa when Abid initiates the GD.

I really don't understand why i can't be winner. Ok. If this is the rule all want to follow,I don't want to be the judge of DFAA. Not fair.
In this site,most of the time i use to work in forums and if i am not allowed to win here,i don't want to be the judge of DFAA.

Maverick sir,please comment on this,your decision will be final.[/quote]

Ronark,
I was continuously participating in GDs and when I became its moderator I have to pull from competition , but share my ideas.You will get moderator bonus for this works.