When was CBI autonomous

by Gulshan Kumar Ajmani in General Discussions

3.48k 21.9k 176.9k

12 years ago

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

G. K. Ajmani Tax consultant
http://gkajmani-mystraythoughts.blogspot.com/

Like it on Facebook, Tweet it or share this topic on other bookmarking websites.

rambabu

1.49k 32k 218.8k

12 years ago

#338070

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

The declaration of CBI chief Ranjit Sinha in this regard says it all. CBI is under government control

Thank you said by: Gulshan Kumar Ajmani

Suny Ag

253 20k 141.2k

12 years ago

#338077

It never was but neither was it responsible to PMO. At the most law ministry could suggest it on few issues, that was all.

I love this free image hosting site for sharing my work

https://o0.nz/

usha manohar

704 19.5k 126.1k

12 years ago

#338093

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

I agree it is bizzare to hope that CBI is autonomous, the question is, so what power does it have ? It will function as the ruling government dictates, so why have it in the first place? any odd organisation will do ?

Pay no mind to those who talk behind your back, it simply means that you are two steps ahead !!!

Suny Ag

253 20k 141.2k

12 years ago

#338095

CBI is only a eyewash to divert attention for the time being and at the same time blackmail parties which do not support government's viewpoint.

I love this free image hosting site for sharing my work

https://o0.nz/

rambabu

1.49k 32k 218.8k

12 years ago

#338108

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

I agree it is bizzare to hope that CBI is autonomous, the question is, so what power does it have ? It will function as the ruling government dictates, so why have it in the first place? any odd organisation will do ?

So, the opposition is right. All along their allegations against CBI were dismissed by the ruling party.

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani

3.48k 21.9k 176.9k

12 years ago

#338124

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

I agree it is bizzare to hope that CBI is autonomous, the question is, so what power does it have ? It will function as the ruling government dictates, so why have it in the first place? any odd organisation will do ?

So, the opposition is right. All along their allegations against CBI were dismissed by the ruling party.

CBI was never an autonomous body. This fact is known to all. This does not mean that the organization does not function. Autonomy cannot be a solution. Just try making every organization autonomous and see the fun. Then government will have no responsibility. To make government responsible, you need to put the organization under government control.

G. K. Ajmani Tax consultant
http://gkajmani-mystraythoughts.blogspot.com/

anil

220 6.73k 39.2k

12 years ago

#338168

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

They admit it now but every one know than it is under government. Indeed no one political party wants that CBI will be a autonomous. All wants to use it for their benefits.

chinmoymukherjee

934 14.7k 122.3k

12 years ago

#338170

I think the Supreme Court has bared it all with all its Constitutional expertise and nobody needs to arrogate to himself or herself to be knowing the Constitutional provisions better than the Apex court which has been very emphatic in stressing the need to free this body from the clutches of political bosses. In a case where the government is a party to case it is highly unethical on the part of anyone remotely associated with the government to have a sneak peek into the report proposed to be submitted to the Court!

rambabu

1.49k 32k 218.8k

12 years ago

#338174

We only need to see the organizational pattern to find out autonomous or departmental status of CBI. Many claim that CBI is autonomous. some say that CBI is govt run. Now an affidavit is filed in supreme court that CBI is under government control.

CBI is not a constitutional post and is definitely organized as a govt department. It is so bizarre to certain people looking for autonomy in this organization.

http://in.news.yahoo.com/cbi-not-an-independent-body--cbi-chief-151704494.html

I agree it is bizzare to hope that CBI is autonomous, the question is, so what power does it have ? It will function as the ruling government dictates, so why have it in the first place? any odd organisation will do ?

So, the opposition is right. All along their allegations against CBI were dismissed by the ruling party.

CBI was never an autonomous body. This fact is known to all. This does not mean that the organization does not function. Autonomy cannot be a solution. Just try making every organization autonomous and see the fun. Then government will have no responsibility. To make government responsible, you need to put the organization under government control.

True, Autonomy is not the solution, but effective implementation of the respective provisions in the act is.

Thank you said by: Gulshan Kumar Ajmani

You do not have permissions to reply to this topic.

Title	Category	Replies
What are the impacts of modern technology on family communication?	Discussions	0
Women should get to wear whatever they want!	General Discussions	0
Understanding What Education Is?	Discussions	0
Whose birthdate is a lucky ?	General Discussions	0
importance of skill	Topics of Interest	0

Forum Categories

Trending Topics