Should Pakistanis be sent back???

2.9K Views
0 Replies
1 min read

After the surgical attacks by the army... There have been few people who insist that India completely cut off its pakistani ties and send back all its people...including actors businessman etc.... Recently Karan Johar n mahesh Bhatt have opposed ths view.

So whats your take on it? Should we sent back all pakistani people...should we be resuming the bilateral dialogue???

14 Replies

rambabu wrote:

Unless Pakistan stops Cease fire violations there is no scope for talks with Pakistan.. Now it's too late for Talks. Even in the Ongoing BRICKS meet Pakistan sponsored Terrorism  was regarded as the Common scourge not only for the Countries Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, but to the entire world.

Pakistan has never stopped ceasefire violations. Its always aggressive at the LOC. So i think in time, this situation will calm down and both countries will again be forced into bilateral talks. Which has the situation in many previous instances as well

Divya wrote:
rambabu wrote:

Unless Pakistan stops Cease fire violations there is no scope for talks with Pakistan.. Now it's too late for Talks. Even in the Ongoing BRICKS meet Pakistan sponsored Terrorism  was regarded as the Common scourge not only for the Countries Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, but to the entire world.

Pakistan has never stopped ceasefire violations. Its always aggressive at the LOC. So i think in time, this situation will calm down and both countries will again be forced into bilateral talks. Which has the situation in many previous instances as well

I don't think so. Pakistan cannot believed. There should be a congenial atmosphere for bilateral talks. Of course, earlier situations are different. We believed Pakistan. And what happened, you are seeing.  After seeing the way in which continuous ceasefire violations are taking place, it is strange you are still hopeful.

rambabu wrote:
Divya wrote:
rambabu wrote:

Unless Pakistan stops Cease fire violations there is no scope for talks with Pakistan.. Now it's too late for Talks. Even in the Ongoing BRICKS meet Pakistan sponsored Terrorism  was regarded as the Common scourge not only for the Countries Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa, but to the entire world.

Pakistan has never stopped ceasefire violations. Its always aggressive at the LOC. So i think in time, this situation will calm down and both countries will again be forced into bilateral talks. Which has the situation in many previous instances as well

I don't think so. Pakistan cannot believed. There should be a congenial atmosphere for bilateral talks. Of course, earlier situations are different. We believed Pakistan. And what happened, you are seeing.  After seeing the way in which continuous ceasefire violations are taking place, it is strange you are still hopeful.

Lets wait and see. And I am not hoping for the talks. As i said both the countries will be forced into talks, willingly or unwillingly.

With due respect to art and artists from Pakistan, I have to say that National Interest is above all. In this time every one staying in India has to stay together and condemn terrorism. Indians who are staying abroad and earning their livelihood there have to abide by the law of that country and condemn any terrorist attack on that country.  These Pak artists came openly to condemn terrorism in other countries in past. Infact one of them made a musical album after one such attack in Pakistan. Why this hypocrisy now when the attack was on India?? If they can not condemn the attack on the country where they live for their livelihood, it is morally and ethically right to ask them to leave.

Arunima Singh wrote:

With due respect to art and artists from Pakistan, I have to say that National Interest is above all. In this time every one staying in India has to stay together and condemn terrorism. Indians who are staying abroad and earning their livelihood there have to abide by the law of that country and condemn any terrorist attack on that country.  These Pak artists came openly to condemn terrorism in other countries in past. Infact one of them made a musical album after one such attack in Pakistan. Why this hypocrisy now when the attack was on India?? If they can not condemn the attack on the country where they live for their livelihood, it is morally and ethically right to ask them to leave.

Not condemning terrorist attack by Pakistani artists is perfidy. They must be push back and not allowed to work here in future, but movies which are complete must be released.

 

Arunima Singh wrote:

With due respect to art and artists from Pakistan, I have to say that National Interest is above all. In this time every one staying in India has to stay together and condemn terrorism. Indians who are staying abroad and earning their livelihood there have to abide by the law of that country and condemn any terrorist attack on that country.  These Pak artists came openly to condemn terrorism in other countries in past. Infact one of them made a musical album after one such attack in Pakistan. Why this hypocrisy now when the attack was on India?? If they can not condemn the attack on the country where they live for their livelihood, it is morally and ethically right to ask them to leave.

It;s a pity. Pakistani Actors in Bollywood Fawad Khan,Mahira Khan and Ali Zafar denounced Paris Terror attacks but not Uri attacks. This silence of these actors on Uri attacks says clearly that these Pakistani Actors are loyal to their own actors. But not loyal to that country, which gave them a livelihood. Such traitors and Ungrateful Actors should not be allowed to live in India. I commend MNS.

 

commending MNS well known for lawlessness is ridiculous. Pakistani actors are just artists and in India for a limited purpose. They cannot be expected to criticize their country for Pakistan for favor of allowing them role in Indian movies. It is for govt. to allow or disallow or grant/ reject VISA. MNS or anyone else has no such right. If they indulge in activities like banning films or actors, they are just law breakers and criminals and nothing else.

After the recent development, Pakistan banning all Indian channels, I doubt if anyone still feels that we should entertain anything Pakistani on our soil. 

Amid Indo - Pak tension. Pakistan's Media Regulatory Authority decided to enforce a complete ban on Indian TV and Radio contents. This shows Pakistan's frustration after Surgical Strikes by India.  After this incident no Pakistani should be allowed to stay in India. Pakistan is India's number One enemy.

rambabu wrote:

Amid Indo - Pak tension. Pakistan's Media Regulatory Authority decided to enforce a complete ban on Indian TV and Radio contents. This shows Pakistan's frustration after Surgical Strikes by India.  After this incident no Pakistani should be allowed to stay in India. Pakistan is India's number One enemy.

i think showcases the military rule in pakistan against the democracy in india. 

Definitely.. Pakistan doesn't want that democracy in India to survive. Because, Modi's Government carried successfully Surgical Strikes successfully in PoK. Such Surgical Strikes would not have been possible by Pakistan, a Military ruled Country. Still the shameless Pakistan violating ceasefire lines. Actually, Pakistan is afraid of some more Surgical Strikes by India any moment.

It is so funny that Indo-= Pak and Indo Chinese trade is as usual. There is no ban on export or import of goods with these countries but only Bollywood movies/ foreign actors are targeted.  

The reason behind targeting Pakistani actors is, Pakistan is targeting India to  destabilize the Government. Despite the entire world  in one voice identified it as a Terrorist exporting Country, it is indulging in Ceasefire violations. Pakistani artists do not  have any right  to act in the Movies made in India.

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

India has not snapped diplomatic relation with Pakistan.  Who knows when some Indian leader will go to Pakistan to take tea with Pak counterparts. So there is no need for us to create any sort of hysteria. 

I agree, Indian policy towards Pakistan is inconsistent.

 

Topic Author

D

Divya

@DivyaRakesh

Topic Stats

Created Monday, 03 October 2016 16:45
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.9K
Likes 2

Category

Discussions

433 Topics

Share This Topic