Which one is best- Indian classical or western music?

True, I love to hear all kind of music, but I like slower one especially Gazels most.

Ghazals are slow and most of them are sad that's why i listen to them only when i am sad and alone. :)

I even love Ghazals a lot. esp of Jagjit Singh and Ghulam Ali.

Even i like these but there is some special mood required to hear them. :)

True, I love to hear all kind of music, but I like slower one especially Gazels most.

Ghazals are slow and most of them are sad that's why i listen to them only when i am sad and alone. :)

I even love Ghazals a lot. esp of Jagjit Singh and Ghulam Ali.

Yes gulam Ali is as good, especially while he twists in the end.

I like Jagjit Singh more than Ghulam Ali. :)

Which one is best- Indian classical or western music?

We can never compare Indian with western....both have their own peculiarities. I know nothing about western music....yet Mozart and Beethovan were really great.
About my favorites.....I love Indian music....yet I hate fast numbers which increase the bp

I think every music has some period,where these songs are appreciated. In 70s and 80,even in 90s classical music was favorite and now as we are progressing,we are going towards western.

I would say both are good. I still love various Classical songs and some songs are always in my Music Library.
Young generation loves Western,me too.

But I think 80's was the weakest era of Bollywood music, except some R.D.Burman tunes. But it was the golden era of both Malayalam and Tamil songs, no doubt. Ilayaraja, Ravi, Raveendran etc....reigned this era at South

Both are good but personal interest varies from man to man.

Both are good but personal interest varies from man to man.

You love only Rabindra sangeeth :P :P

[quote]RAM PROSAD ACHARYYA wrote:
Both are good but personal interest varies from man to man.

You love only Rabindra sangeeth[/quote]
Do you hear Rabindra sangeet?
I like some classical also and sufi songs and Ghajal.

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

I think, you have a little knowledge about classical music. Have you studied in your childhood days?
Can you give me a link of one such composition?

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

I think, you have a little knowledge about classical music. Have you studied in your childhood days?
Can you give me a link of one such composition?

{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 7204]}

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

I think, you have a little knowledge about classical music. Have you studied in your childhood days?
Can you give me a link of one such composition?

{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 7204]}

I will check it after one week..please do provide me with a link....

I know nothing about Raga.....but I always felt close resemblence of two songs, though their tunes were entirely different...sung by vani Jayaram and Madhuri.....
Bole re pappi harar from guddi and Innenikku ....sandhyakal chaalicha of Guruvayoor Kesavan. Years later I found....both songs were based on a single raga....don't ask me which one

There are some Hindi film compositions of Manny Dey which are based on raaga.

There are some Hindi film compositions of Manny Dey which are based on raaga.

Mannay dey is a singer, not composer

There are some Hindi film compositions of Manny Dey which are based on raaga.

Mannay dey is a singer, not composer

He is a singer and a famous composer as well - especially in Bengali. He was the assistant music director to S.D.Burman!

There are some Hindi film compositions of Manny Dey which are based on raaga.

Mannay dey is a singer, not composer

He is a singer and a famous composer as well - especially in Bengali. He was the assistant music director to S.D.Burman!

Really???? It's a new piece of knowledge......Can you name a few Hindi compositions of mannay Dey?
the most famous romantic number.....an evergreen hit....was sung by Manna Dey for Salil Chaudary(Chemmeen)

I think when You are alone Classical Is Good But when you Are in a Crowd Western Suit That Situation..............

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

I think, you have a little knowledge about classical music. Have you studied in your childhood days?
Can you give me a link of one such composition?

{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 7204]}

I will check it after one week..please do provide me with a link....

I know nothing about Raga.....but I always felt close resemblence of two songs, though their tunes were entirely different...sung by vani Jayaram and Madhuri.....
Bole re pappi harar from guddi and Innenikku ....sandhyakal chaalicha of Guruvayoor Kesavan. Years later I found....both songs were based on a single raga....don't ask me which one

As long as Hindi film music composers made brilliant use of Hindustani Classical music we got great melodious immortal master pieces.Vani Jayram's song was one of those apt instances. There were composers who had equal mastery over both Indian as well as Western classical music like R.D.Burman,Salil Chowdury and others!

Has anyone heard Pandit V.J. Jogh's violin recital in raag 'Shyamkalyan'? I challenge no soul would be ever be bored!! A magical music experience!

I think, you have a little knowledge about classical music. Have you studied in your childhood days?
Can you give me a link of one such composition?

{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 7204]}

I will check it after one week..please do provide me with a link....

I know nothing about Raga.....but I always felt close resemblence of two songs, though their tunes were entirely different...sung by vani Jayaram and Madhuri.....
Bole re pappi harar from guddi and Innenikku ....sandhyakal chaalicha of Guruvayoor Kesavan. Years later I found....both songs were based on a single raga....don't ask me which one

As long as Hindi film music composers made brilliant use of Hindustani Classical music we got great melodious immortal master pieces.Vani Jayram's song was one of those apt instances. There were composers who had equal mastery over both Indian as well as Western classical music like R.D.Burman,Salil Chowdury and others!

Except Hindusthani and Carnatic, what else classical music is there in our country? :whistle:
I think there are 72 ragas and it is common for both. Am I right? :whistle: :unsure:

I do not know more about raga's but I know sa re ga ma pa is same in all type of music.