Hindi chauvanism will be counter productive

The government should learn a lesson from the blows and jolts earlier governments tasted by trying to force Hindi language

I many times feel that the language of that group should be adopted which is the least spoken in India and made the official language. Then everyone will have equal advantage or disadvantage and all will learn it. Any takers both ways?

This will be a big joke on the Hindi chauvanists. I suggest that Khasi (Meghalaya) be made national language. :laugh: :laugh:

But my more serious suggestion is that English should get more prominent role as this is common to all Indians and is well used by them. Also Roman script should be adoptd for Hindi. Hindi in Roman script will be understood more than Hindi in Devnagri script. Many use Roman script for Hindi also in Facebook.

Ultimately that language is going to flourish in which one is able to earn a living. That is why Sanskrit, Urdu and Persian have almost declined or vanished from use in India. English is becoming a global language and its spread has finished many native languages in many countries. Unfortunate but true. Writing Hindi in Roman script is already taking place in social networks. Matter of time before it becomes widespread. Many a times all the movies running seem to be English but actually are Hindi movies with English titles!!.

I agree. I seriously feel that language is nothing but a medium. The thrust should be on peace, prosperity, equity, justice and progress. Language is secondary. I need water to quench my thirst. Whether you call this water, neer, jol or AAB matters little.

Here I am tempted to tell a story. A young man went to college and learnt Persian with proficiency. Once he fell seriously sick. He could not even speak well. He was bed ridden. One day, he breathed his last. Somebody asked as to what were his last words. The parents said- He was just uttering AAB- AAB. The visitor said- Then he died of thirst. He was asking for water continously but you did not give him. Parents repented why they sent their son to learn Persian. They lamented- Persian has killed our son. Uttering AAB- AAB died our child.
.

The government should learn a lesson from the blows and jolts earlier governments tasted by trying to force Hindi language

I many times feel that the language of that group should be adopted which is the least spoken in India and made the official language. Then everyone will have equal advantage or disadvantage and all will learn it. Any takers both ways?

This will be a big joke on the Hindi chauvanists. I suggest that Khasi (Meghalaya) be made national language. :laugh: :laugh:

But my more serious suggestion is that English should get more prominent role as this is common to all Indians and is well used by them. Also Roman script should be adoptd for Hindi. Hindi in Roman script will be understood more than Hindi in Devnagri script. Many use Roman script for Hindi also in Facebook.

Ultimately that language is going to flourish in which one is able to earn a living. That is why Sanskrit, Urdu and Persian have almost declined or vanished from use in India. English is becoming a global language and its spread has finished many native languages in many countries. Unfortunate but true. Writing Hindi in Roman script is already taking place in social networks. Matter of time before it becomes widespread. Many a times all the movies running seem to be English but actually are Hindi movies with English titles!!.

I agree. I seriously feel that language is nothing but a medium. The thrust should be on peace, prosperity, equity, justice and progress. Language is secondary. I need water to quench my thirst. Whether you call this water, neer, jol or AAB matters little.

Here I am tempted to tell a story. A young man went to college and learnt Persian with proficiency. Once he fell seriously sick. He could not even speak well. He was bed ridden. One day, he breathed his last. Somebody asked as to what were his last words. The parents said- He was just uttering AAB- AAB. The visitor said- Then he died of thirst. He was asking for water continously but you did not give him. Parents repented why they sent their son to learn Persian. They lamented- Persian has killed our son. Uttering AAB- AAB died our child.
.

The three language formula is a very good concept. It takes care of a language of commerce and higher studies, teaches the national language and also the state language in most cases the mother tongue. Some of us who are out of our state know one more language ie 4 languages. It is uplifting. Hindi states can receive official letters in Hindi, others in English. What is the problem. You are right language is a medium but many times it is used for domination also by vested interests.

I do not see anything wrong in using Hindi as medium of communication, it is unique to India and father of nation supported this.

I do not see anything wrong in using Hindi as medium of communication, it is unique to India and father of nation supported this.

Father of nation supported many other things which are not followed. No one is saying Hindi should not be the official language. Only it should not be forced on any state or region.

I do not see anything wrong in using Hindi as medium of communication, it is unique to India and father of nation supported this.

Father of nation supported many other things which are not followed. No one is saying Hindi should not be the official language. Only it should not be forced on any state or region.

The BJP should turn its attention to immediate burning problems like Hijacked Indians in Mosul, Iraq, Economic instability due to turbulence in Iraq etc. Language issue can wait. Let it not waste its time on imposition of language and become unpopular in its starting point.

The BJP should turn its attention to immediate burning problems like Hijacked Indians in Mosul, Iraq, Economic instability due to turbulence in Iraq etc. Language issue can wait. Let it not waste its time on imposition of language and become unpopular in its starting point.

Absolutely ! This can wait and may be not even important since things have been going on without any hassle for so long but other issues that you mentioned are far more important and also internal problems with regard to economy and infra structure which are far more essential to be tackled and dealt with...

The BJP should turn its attention to immediate burning problems like Hijacked Indians in Mosul, Iraq, Economic instability due to turbulence in Iraq etc. Language issue can wait. Let it not waste its time on imposition of language and become unpopular in its starting point.

Absolutely ! This can wait and may be not even important since things have been going on without any hassle for so long but other issues that you mentioned are far more important and also internal problems with regard to economy and infra structure which are far more essential to be tackled and dealt with...

BJP should not bite more than it can swallow.. Especially in the beginning of its governance. People will think about the current problems. These issues are to addressed first.

The BJP should turn its attention to immediate burning problems like Hijacked Indians in Mosul, Iraq, Economic instability due to turbulence in Iraq etc. Language issue can wait. Let it not waste its time on imposition of language and become unpopular in its starting point.

Absolutely ! This can wait and may be not even important since things have been going on without any hassle for so long but other issues that you mentioned are far more important and also internal problems with regard to economy and infra structure which are far more essential to be tackled and dealt with...

BJP should not bite more than it can swallow.. Especially in the beginning of its governance. People will think about the current problems. These issues are to addressed first.

But it is easier to indulge in mattrs like Article 370, common civil code, temple issues. Controlling rising prices and employment solution are hard nuts to crack. It is the time we should realize that they have come to power by raising emotive matters.

To elucidate- Modi could have simply stated at Varanasi- : Freeing rivers from pollution will be our priority'. But this simple statement cannot give votes. So he said- FIRST I BELIEVED THAT I HAVE COME TO VARANASI. ON SECOND THOUGHTS, I FELT THAT BJP HAS SENT ME HERE. BUT NOW I AM CLEAR THAT MAA GANGA HAS CALLED ME HERE'
In fact, he was parodying a hymn- "chalo bulawa aaya haai maata ne bulaaya hai jor se bolo jai maata ki'.

Any way, such tactics are fascist. Hindi chauvanism is also indication of fascism.

Do you think that Hindi is mix of Tamil, Urdu, Gujarati etc. BJP leader thinks so. So, by encouraging Hindi, you are also encouraging Tamil. How strange logic? Are they not getting funnier.


http://www.firstpost.com/politics/everyone-chill-bjp-says-hindi-is-mix-of-tamil-gujarati-bengali-1580695.html

Do you think that Hindi is mix of Tamil, Urdu, Gujarati etc. BJP leader thinks so. So, by encouraging Hindi, you are also encouraging Tamil. How strange logic? Are they not getting funnier.


http://www.firstpost.com/politics/everyone-chill-bjp-says-hindi-is-mix-of-tamil-gujarati-bengali-1580695.html

I call them Jokers. I was laughing aloud after hearing these jokers saying, Hindi is a mix of Tamil,, Urdu ,Gujrati etc. Poor linguists die of suffocation.

Do you think that Hindi is mix of Tamil, Urdu, Gujarati etc. BJP leader thinks so. So, by encouraging Hindi, you are also encouraging Tamil. How strange logic? Are they not getting funnier.


http://www.firstpost.com/politics/everyone-chill-bjp-says-hindi-is-mix-of-tamil-gujarati-bengali-1580695.html

I call them Jokers. I was laughing aloud after hearing these jokers saying, Hindi is a mix of Tamil,, Urdu ,Gujrati etc. Poor linguists die of suffocation.

Hindi is the mother tongue of 25% Indians. It is understood by around 50% of the population. These areas per last census findings. So imposing Hindi will be resisted. It will spread in course of time. It is not an issue at all. Government should spend its energy on coming with innovative ways to control price rise, inflation, creating jobs etc. Divisive issues should not be their agenda.

Do you think that Hindi is mix of Tamil, Urdu, Gujarati etc. BJP leader thinks so. So, by encouraging Hindi, you are also encouraging Tamil. How strange logic? Are they not getting funnier.


http://www.firstpost.com/politics/everyone-chill-bjp-says-hindi-is-mix-of-tamil-gujarati-bengali-1580695.html

I call them Jokers. I was laughing aloud after hearing these jokers saying, Hindi is a mix of Tamil,, Urdu ,Gujrati etc. Poor linguists die of suffocation.

Hindi is the mother tongue of 25% Indians. It is understood by around 50% of the population. These areas per last census findings. So imposing Hindi will be resisted. It will spread in course of time. It is not an issue at all. Government should spend its energy on coming with innovative ways to control price rise, inflation, creating jobs etc. Divisive issues should not be their agenda.

That's what exactly I said in my earlier responses. Language is irrelevant and doesn't need any attention at this stage.

Do you think that Hindi is mix of Tamil, Urdu, Gujarati etc. BJP leader thinks so. So, by encouraging Hindi, you are also encouraging Tamil. How strange logic? Are they not getting funnier.


http://www.firstpost.com/politics/everyone-chill-bjp-says-hindi-is-mix-of-tamil-gujarati-bengali-1580695.html

I call them Jokers. I was laughing aloud after hearing these jokers saying, Hindi is a mix of Tamil,, Urdu ,Gujrati etc. Poor linguists die of suffocation.

Hindi is the mother tongue of 25% Indians. It is understood by around 50% of the population. These areas per last census findings. So imposing Hindi will be resisted. It will spread in course of time. It is not an issue at all. Government should spend its energy on coming with innovative ways to control price rise, inflation, creating jobs etc. Divisive issues should not be their agenda.

That's what exactly I said in my earlier responses. Language is irrelevant and doesn't need any attention at this stage.

But you are repeatedly saying it is not important at this stage. Is it important at all.