Hi All,
I am back with another round of Group Discussion Contest. The topic for this round is
"What changes needed in our education system to create future leaders?"
We have a lot of high profile colleges in India which are listed in top colleges in the world, however we are far behind many countries. We have huge number of students graduating every year, but are not able to be part of many innovations which we are seeing every day coming from other countries. What changes do you propose in our education system to change this scenario.
To know more about this contest Click Here
We are giving 50 points for all the members who post atleast 3 valid replies on Group Discussion topic. Replies should be in a constructive manner either oppose of supporting the topic.
Wish you all the best and be creative, informative and be sportive in taking feedback.
20 Replies
Lohit...
Its true that quality of education is good in very few colleges only... Like IIT , IIM etc.
But other colleges are also not bad.But they are not coming to the top in providing quality education compared to the present situation of education system.
Still in our system, we force students to by heart what which have been found decades before and we are testing their memory power only.
Like western system, we should give students basic knowledge and then allow him to experience it and give encouragement to find something by himself rather than just by hearting what it is in text..
Our system should come to that standard...
Also you had agreed to santosh saying that there is no need for hindi medium as we need english more.. But one thing is there.. hindi or whatever be our mother tongue.. Don't avoid it..
We should give importance to our mother tongue also...
Its true that quality of education is good in very few colleges only... Like IIT , IIM etc.
But other colleges are also not bad.But they are not coming to the top in providing quality education compared to the present situation of education system.
Still in our system, we force students to by heart what which have been found decades before and we are testing their memory power only.
Like western system, we should give students basic knowledge and then allow him to experience it and give encouragement to find something by himself rather than just by hearting what it is in text..
Our system should come to that standard...
Also you had agreed to santosh saying that there is no need for hindi medium as we need english more.. But one thing is there.. hindi or whatever be our mother tongue.. Don't avoid it..
We should give importance to our mother tongue also...
Abid,
Yes.. SSA is the developed form of DPEP and SSA has overcome the draw backs of DPEP.
Mock parliament is now a days conducted in school level also.. Mock parliament is a good practise to develop talents and leadership qualities in students..
Caste system is good to uplift lower caste. But the thing is that most of the lower caste people are rich now and they are misusing the reservations.. So i think reservation criteria should be revised..
Continous evaluation is better than just testing his memory power..
And i agree with you that we should not avoid our own mother tongue and system..
Yes.. SSA is the developed form of DPEP and SSA has overcome the draw backs of DPEP.
Mock parliament is now a days conducted in school level also.. Mock parliament is a good practise to develop talents and leadership qualities in students..
Caste system is good to uplift lower caste. But the thing is that most of the lower caste people are rich now and they are misusing the reservations.. So i think reservation criteria should be revised..
Continous evaluation is better than just testing his memory power..
And i agree with you that we should not avoid our own mother tongue and system..
Abid..
Yes we have to value our own culture.. values and tradition..
Reservation was started for upliftment of the backward.. But as corruption is increased in reservation system.. As I said.. revision of criteria is required..
We had discussed about the need of reservation in one of our first GD's..
Yes we have to value our own culture.. values and tradition..
Reservation was started for upliftment of the backward.. But as corruption is increased in reservation system.. As I said.. revision of criteria is required..
We had discussed about the need of reservation in one of our first GD's..
Michael...
Reservation is needed to upliftment of backward and we don't need to remove it completely..
But i agree with you that rather than decreasing, it had increased the gap between society to some extend..
Anyway.. its time for a revision in reservation criteria..
I think 50% reservation is not at all required..
And i agree to you that its essential to know three languages as you said.. All has its own need..
English.. Gives us a global exposure..
Hindi.. Proud to be an Indian..
Mother tongue.. We can't forget our mother...
Reservation is needed to upliftment of backward and we don't need to remove it completely..
But i agree with you that rather than decreasing, it had increased the gap between society to some extend..
Anyway.. its time for a revision in reservation criteria..
I think 50% reservation is not at all required..
And i agree to you that its essential to know three languages as you said.. All has its own need..
English.. Gives us a global exposure..
Hindi.. Proud to be an Indian..
Mother tongue.. We can't forget our mother...
Jobin wrote:
[quote]
Seminars, projects etc are good. But don't make it a burden to students or just don't make it so simple that students will just copy something. It should be helpful to improve the knowledge and talents of students...
[/quote]
Jobin,
The seminars and projects of SSA are not at all a burden to students.I think you had mistaken it like the projects and seminars conducted by higher education students.Students really enjoy them and acquire practical knowledge through them.
In our days we have magazines only in colleges.Now we can see magazines even in primary schools with the whole efforts of students only.
Campus films were heard in degree level colleges only.Now upper primary students prepare documentary films.
All these are the effect of SSA.It really develops a student in all areas through his own query and findings.
[quote]
Seminars, projects etc are good. But don't make it a burden to students or just don't make it so simple that students will just copy something. It should be helpful to improve the knowledge and talents of students...
[/quote]
Jobin,
The seminars and projects of SSA are not at all a burden to students.I think you had mistaken it like the projects and seminars conducted by higher education students.Students really enjoy them and acquire practical knowledge through them.
In our days we have magazines only in colleges.Now we can see magazines even in primary schools with the whole efforts of students only.
Campus films were heard in degree level colleges only.Now upper primary students prepare documentary films.
All these are the effect of SSA.It really develops a student in all areas through his own query and findings.
Politics is already a branch of study in our education.As some of here fears it hadn't become a sensitive issue till now.But ruling and opposing parties had made some issues in some states not in study of politics,but in history and like that.
But in my opinion this study is good for nothing.It is just like any subject.By studying it one cannot be a good leader.To develop good managers and businessman we have business schools.Like that to develop good leaders we should have political schools.
But in my opinion this study is good for nothing.It is just like any subject.By studying it one cannot be a good leader.To develop good managers and businessman we have business schools.Like that to develop good leaders we should have political schools.
Abid,
When projects are given.. students should also get good time to prepare a goo one by themselves. But what we are seeing many times is that its not happening in the busy schedule..
Magazines, campus films ets are a good sign of progress and quality of students.. Its a nice move...
When projects are given.. students should also get good time to prepare a goo one by themselves. But what we are seeing many times is that its not happening in the busy schedule..
Magazines, campus films ets are a good sign of progress and quality of students.. Its a nice move...
In higher level of education we are still text book oriented.First it should be changed to practical oriented one.
Secondly the present education system does not cater the needs of youth.So it should be totally changed to give due importance to the youth in all respect since they are the future responsible citizens
The over emphasise on exams and the narrow mindedness of current system should be demolished and importance to knowledge should be given.
Then only new young energetic leaders will emerge from the youth.
Secondly the present education system does not cater the needs of youth.So it should be totally changed to give due importance to the youth in all respect since they are the future responsible citizens
The over emphasise on exams and the narrow mindedness of current system should be demolished and importance to knowledge should be given.
Then only new young energetic leaders will emerge from the youth.
Yes its true that we should make our education less oriented towards text books ..
What we require is the practical knowledge..
I'm not agreeying to you completely that present education system is not concentrating on youth more.. Present education system has programs concentrated on youth like sex education, law education etc.
And i agree to you that we are giving over concentration on exams and marks rather than practical knowledge..
What we require is the practical knowledge..
I'm not agreeying to you completely that present education system is not concentrating on youth more.. Present education system has programs concentrated on youth like sex education, law education etc.
And i agree to you that we are giving over concentration on exams and marks rather than practical knowledge..
[quote]Seminars, projects etc are good. But don't make it a burden to students or just don't make it so simple that students will just copy something. It should be helpful to improve the knowledge and talents of students..[/quote]
@Jobin,
Its not true that students dont get time to prepare for seminars and projects.It was a case when the SSA system was introduced, but later many changes were made.
You said that students may copy and wont be sincere in their work.But you must understand that seminars and projects are no just homeworks.Once they prepare a seminar or project, they have to present it in the class and there will be discussion on it.So the person who prepared it has to be fully ready and thorough with the topic.A good knowledge in topic is required here.Otherwise they will loose marks when they are not able to answer correctly to the question asked by the members in other groups.There would be a debate on the topic and it will really help to improve the talents and smartness of the student.The answer given for the questions will help the teachers to judge the student and put marks.Thats continues evaluation and its a perfect form of practical approach to a topic.
@Jobin,
Its not true that students dont get time to prepare for seminars and projects.It was a case when the SSA system was introduced, but later many changes were made.
You said that students may copy and wont be sincere in their work.But you must understand that seminars and projects are no just homeworks.Once they prepare a seminar or project, they have to present it in the class and there will be discussion on it.So the person who prepared it has to be fully ready and thorough with the topic.A good knowledge in topic is required here.Otherwise they will loose marks when they are not able to answer correctly to the question asked by the members in other groups.There would be a debate on the topic and it will really help to improve the talents and smartness of the student.The answer given for the questions will help the teachers to judge the student and put marks.Thats continues evaluation and its a perfect form of practical approach to a topic.
Making politics a part of curriculum
@Cool boy
You are right.Politics must be made a part of curriculum.To make a good leader, not just the study of history is enough.Students must also have the practical knowledge on what happening around them.I think in this regard, mock parliament is an answer to an extent.
@ Jobin
Controversy come when you name a particular party and its ideology.As you know there are two basic ideology of politics RIGHT and LEFT.One feature is that; Right believe in individual development and thus leading to the development of society.LEFT believe that only with the development in society individual development will take place.So why cant we use other names and teach the students this very basic ideology.Now thats a very basic concept in politics.So political education in possible in that way without controversies.
Political school
@abid
Political school is great concept,but the problem is that its not at all practical.There must be law which tells that only people with a degree from such school can contest in election.Very nice to say this, but think of the vote it will get in the parliament.It will be a historic bill because for the first time a zero vote will be made!!
@Cool boy
You are right.Politics must be made a part of curriculum.To make a good leader, not just the study of history is enough.Students must also have the practical knowledge on what happening around them.I think in this regard, mock parliament is an answer to an extent.
@ Jobin
Controversy come when you name a particular party and its ideology.As you know there are two basic ideology of politics RIGHT and LEFT.One feature is that; Right believe in individual development and thus leading to the development of society.LEFT believe that only with the development in society individual development will take place.So why cant we use other names and teach the students this very basic ideology.Now thats a very basic concept in politics.So political education in possible in that way without controversies.
Political school
@abid
Political school is great concept,but the problem is that its not at all practical.There must be law which tells that only people with a degree from such school can contest in election.Very nice to say this, but think of the vote it will get in the parliament.It will be a historic bill because for the first time a zero vote will be made!!
hi,
I like to emphasis on the role of teachers.In my opinion, along with any change in educational system, teachers also must be well educated on taking classes.Of course there are courses conducted for teachers, but we have to see how much successful it is.
We know that a student learn from teacher not just the curriculum, but many other qualities.After family, school and teachers are the main factors which mould the personality of a student.So if we can specifically train our teachers in imparting moral values and quality to students, we can surely hope to get great leaders in the future.If properly planned and executed,not only leaders, a whole society of responsible and committed citizens can be made in this manner.
I believe the entire success of education is in the hands of good teachers.
I like to emphasis on the role of teachers.In my opinion, along with any change in educational system, teachers also must be well educated on taking classes.Of course there are courses conducted for teachers, but we have to see how much successful it is.
We know that a student learn from teacher not just the curriculum, but many other qualities.After family, school and teachers are the main factors which mould the personality of a student.So if we can specifically train our teachers in imparting moral values and quality to students, we can surely hope to get great leaders in the future.If properly planned and executed,not only leaders, a whole society of responsible and committed citizens can be made in this manner.
I believe the entire success of education is in the hands of good teachers.
@MC you are right there should be special training sessions for teachers to know about politics and the knowledge which should they give to students. I would like to suggest that if some types of newspapers are issued which contained more on politics and distributed to students in schools it would spread a good knowledge of politics.
Political schools are good but think about, mostly when we are in school we don't really understand the complexities of things....
When we were kids, some of us might have wanted to become a doctor,a pilot etc...just become it sounded as good profession to us, because it had made an impression on our young minds..
So in order to attract the youth's attraction we have to change the present face of politics...
Everyday we hear in the news about some politician doing some immoral deeds..
that will not leave a good impression....
"Politics" and its importance should be explained to young minds right at the root level..
It should not have to be " taught", it has to be explained or else it will become like any other subject which we forget after our exams are over...
And a certain level, private schools and colleges should be introduced for those who have interest in it and want to pursue it..
When we were kids, some of us might have wanted to become a doctor,a pilot etc...just become it sounded as good profession to us, because it had made an impression on our young minds..
So in order to attract the youth's attraction we have to change the present face of politics...
Everyday we hear in the news about some politician doing some immoral deeds..
that will not leave a good impression....
"Politics" and its importance should be explained to young minds right at the root level..
It should not have to be " taught", it has to be explained or else it will become like any other subject which we forget after our exams are over...
And a certain level, private schools and colleges should be introduced for those who have interest in it and want to pursue it..
Thanks for your opinion on "Political School".As MC said teachers are the social engineers.They can mould the future citizen of our country.They can elicit the ideas of children.
Actually Teacher is a friend and guide of the student.Most of the problems of a student is solved by his teacher.Hence always one will have affection towards a teacher after his parents.
Actually Teacher is a friend and guide of the student.Most of the problems of a student is solved by his teacher.Hence always one will have affection towards a teacher after his parents.
@cool boy
Your idea is good.Today children are not at all interested in reading political news.All they want is sports and page 3 gossips,most of the students.So by distributing such paper and keeping discussion on it will help in creating awareness on politics in young students.But one problem is that, we can't select any newspaper for this purpose.There are papers which are biased.So i think if possible, at least the front page of every newspaper or political news in paper must be discussed for about 15minutes or more, as the first thing in morning.So that children have an overall idea about the news and newspaper and they will be able to read between lines in case of some biased newspaper.
@Michael
Your are right.You won't hear any student telling that his ambition is to become a politician!.There must be a charm in politics and for that,as you said,the entire face of politics has to change.
What you said about teaching politics is correct.We should make it a part of the education as extra curricular activity.If politics is taught and there is an exam for that, i also believe it wont do much good.Instead, it must be something students love and want to actively participate, just like a game.There can be debates and discussions and it should be interesting learning.That will make the young minds to think about politics and to go for politics.Also since there is no degree needed to become a politician obviously there is no need for an exam.All that is needed is to impart that national commitment and interest in politics, which will help to create good leaders in future.
Your idea is good.Today children are not at all interested in reading political news.All they want is sports and page 3 gossips,most of the students.So by distributing such paper and keeping discussion on it will help in creating awareness on politics in young students.But one problem is that, we can't select any newspaper for this purpose.There are papers which are biased.So i think if possible, at least the front page of every newspaper or political news in paper must be discussed for about 15minutes or more, as the first thing in morning.So that children have an overall idea about the news and newspaper and they will be able to read between lines in case of some biased newspaper.
@Michael
Your are right.You won't hear any student telling that his ambition is to become a politician!.There must be a charm in politics and for that,as you said,the entire face of politics has to change.
What you said about teaching politics is correct.We should make it a part of the education as extra curricular activity.If politics is taught and there is an exam for that, i also believe it wont do much good.Instead, it must be something students love and want to actively participate, just like a game.There can be debates and discussions and it should be interesting learning.That will make the young minds to think about politics and to go for politics.Also since there is no degree needed to become a politician obviously there is no need for an exam.All that is needed is to impart that national commitment and interest in politics, which will help to create good leaders in future.
In my opinion to create good leaders education should have some qualities.They are listed below.
1) Education should be one which help to attain the goal of a student.
2) It should develop self confidence in students
3) It should be suitable for the tastes of students.
4) The personal differences should be considered
5) Education should develop social and co-operative mind
6) It should develop critical analysing abilities in students.
If all these are observed surely the outcome will be good leaders.I think none of them are impracticable.
1) Education should be one which help to attain the goal of a student.
2) It should develop self confidence in students
3) It should be suitable for the tastes of students.
4) The personal differences should be considered
5) Education should develop social and co-operative mind
6) It should develop critical analysing abilities in students.
If all these are observed surely the outcome will be good leaders.I think none of them are impracticable.
Topic Author
M
Maverick
@maverick
Topic Stats
Created
Tuesday, 29 December 2009 10:16
Last Updated
Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies
0
Views
21.3K
Likes
0