Suggestion to show amount on forum post and reply as per quality of post?

Could you give specific examples to make more clear.

Like you respond with one line so there is no quality but if you have respond with more 100 words and its generating traffic on google then boddunan put some amount on that post and that amount will be display when you open this post.

You said that you wanted to suggest regarding whether the member, while responding should check the post's quality or not. If  i'm right, please define a " Quality Post". with some examples. This helps in taking the discussion forward.

Quality posts means its not copied from any other websites and good keywords used in his post, Good English words and no grammar mistake. If you search on google with that post topic then it should come in first page on searching.

This site is a not pay-per-post site so I doubt if this suggestion has any validity unless the entire pay structure is changed.

Its just my suggestion to promote for traffic and to earn something investment required. I do not think there will be lot of quality contents in a day . There may be 4 to 5 quality post per day and if its 5 rs then total will be 25 Rs investment per day.

Santosh Kumar Singh wrote:

Its just my suggestion to promote for traffic and to earn something investment required. I do not think there will be lot of quality contents in a day . There may be 4 to 5 quality post per day and if its 5 rs then total will be 25 Rs investment per day.

 

 Again the basic question, who will determine quality??? and what is quality?

Determining quality is work of Editor and there are lot of way to check it on online tools like character count, content searching on google ,english grammer checker etc

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Santosh Kumar Singh wrote:

Its just my suggestion to promote for traffic and to earn something investment required. I do not think there will be lot of quality contents in a day . There may be 4 to 5 quality post per day and if its 5 rs then total will be 25 Rs investment per day.

 

 Again the basic question, who will determine quality??? and what is quality?

 

True, quantity alone cannot take the place of quality...

Quality checking is not difficult task if Editor allow then I am providing suggestion for quality also. There should be vote system on each reply for some days higher vote content get selected for good quality section.

If the forum post  is original, with the member's own opinion, a post fetches 5 points. If its otherwise, points are deducted. This system is already present in the site. Regarding voting system, you can bring it to the notice of the Administrator. But, I feel the present system is OK.

Present system is ok but system demands change to contribute more on forum and other section. Same thing will feel bore to members in future. 

Of course any positive change is always welcome , and if it makes the forum posts more interesting and more 'Knowledgeable' all the more better . As of now there is absolutely no moderation done , am not sure what the reason is and there are hardly any rules in place except the ones that are directly related to points..

Re introducing especially Revenue sharing and other money making features is more than enough. I remember, how there was a spirit of competitiveness  all over the site conspicuously visible in those days. Discussion forums used to be real platform for exchange of views.

I write on a fair amount of sites and this is not anywhere, and that includes some top writing sites in the world. Quality is confined to posts and articles. It will not work to have such a system on discussions. Sometimes even a one line reply can have a lot of meaning. remember Mark twain who said " damn well would have written a shorter post but didn't have time" Also look at the writings of  O Henry. 

I am not in its favor. it is not necessary that all reply needs 100 or more words. Here all members are not English scholars. We always try to write in manner that reader understand what we want to say. I suggest earlier that comments should be make compulsory to earn point from viewing article. It is not enough to open article page, one must be read it and write some words.

The whole idea of discussion site is to exchange knowledge and information by the members in their own  capacity. However, certain  basic etiquette need to be followed because it is a community.

usha manohar wrote:

The whole idea of discussion site is to exchange knowledge and information by the members in their own  capacity. However, certain  basic etiquette need to be followed because it is a community.

Site have its rules and regulation for it. I think most of members following these.

 

 

 

 

I wrote:

usha manohar wrote:

The whole idea of discussion site is to exchange knowledge and information by the members in their own  capacity. However, certain  basic etiquette need to be followed because it is a community.

Site have its rules and regulation for it. I think most of members following these.

 

 

 

 

 

I feel that  a discussion  site does not run on rules and regulations alone... etiquette is different to rules n regulations 

i think this is very good idea and this site should obey this as it increase the member interest for writing more good comments in the forum.