Gujjars agitate for reservation

Rajasthan High Court has turned down the plea of reservation for Gujjars.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/HC-turns-down-Gujjars-plea-for-quota-in-govt-jobs/articleshow/7144024.cms

I think Rajasthan court has done good work atlast... :) Thanks for sharing the information.

Earlier they agitated for having a separate state.Now for reservation.

why no community is asking to lift the reservations ? It is been a drag on the intellectuals since the independance. Less qualified and low capable guys are getting govt jobs every where and there attitude after getting the job is very disappointing. Even if an employee gets more than 30000 per month his/her kids get lumpsgrants from the schools...?

Shalu Joseph wrote:
[quote]why no community is asking to lift the reservations ? It is been a drag on the intellectuals since the independance. Less qualified and low capable guys are getting govt jobs every where and there attitude after getting the job is very disappointing. Even if an employee gets more than 30000 per month his/her kids get lumps grants from the schools...?[/quote]

Each community fights for reservation for itself rather than demanding end to this. The only communities that may not demand reservation are Brahmans and Vaishya or bania. The Brahamans have already centuries old reservation in religious rituals and temples whereas the vaishya/ bania have reservation in Business and industry with lot of inherited money and business establishment. Hence, nobody will call for ending reservations.

The community based thinking in India is one of reasons for the poverty in india. If you want have reservation let us give it on the basis of pure poverty. If some one admits that they are poor and needs some special aids from the govt. let the authorities check the conditions and give or reject. It should be based ones financial conditions and not on cast!

Shalu Joseph wrote:
[quote]The community based thinking in India is one of reasons for the poverty in india. If you want have reservation let us give it on the basis of pure poverty. If some one admits that they are poor and needs some special aids from the govt. let the authorities check the conditions and give or reject. It should be based ones financial conditions and not on cast![/quote]

I agree. But the help should in shape of scholarship and subsidies. There should be help for training and education and not in services and legislature.

In my place these guys are getting 5 acres of free land and still they agitating for more.. They should be brought in to the mainstream by properly training and getting educated

gulshan kumar ajmani wrote:
[quote]Shalu Joseph wrote:
[quote]why no community is asking to lift the reservations ? It is been a drag on the intellectuals since the independance. Less qualified and low capable guys are getting govt jobs every where and there attitude after getting the job is very disappointing. Even if an employee gets more than 30000 per month his/her kids get lumps grants from the schools...?[/quote]

Each community fights for reservation for itself rather than demanding end to this. The only communities that may not demand reservation are Brahmans and Vaishya or bania. The Brahamans have already centuries old reservation in religious rituals and temples whereas the vaishya/ bania have reservation in Business and industry with lot of inherited money and business establishment. Hence, nobody will call for ending reservations.[/quote]


Well gulshan no one has problem in performing their rituals or profession acquired from their ancestors...Even a farmer or milkman gets good income with their ancestors profession..but education is the vital aspect which is making everbody to opt for reservation ...So even brahims and vaishaya who want education and jobs in goverment organization are facing diffficulties to get with talent...as you said their professions can give them oppurtunity earn more..I also want to say a Sudra or SC/ST can also get good revenue from their ancestors business..

I am totally against the reservation issues and I totally agree with what Shalu says.

Dear Friend,

This is the Black mailing against the Government.
Regard's
Bharat.

If a person belonging to a particular caste goes for a work which has never been traditionally performed by his/fer forefathers nobody can stop him/her which Gulshan wrote otherwise.Moreover I go with Shalu as far as merit is concerned. Efficient disposal of works requires merit and quota should not find any place where selections are to be done for efficiency. The forefathers of the constitution put in place these reservations because it was needed at that time and for some more time. Moreover as Gulshan indicated these deficiencies require other methods of eradication like training,education for which separate plans must be formulated.

Hundreds of passengers were stranded Tuesday as movement of trains between Mathura in Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan's Bharatpur was disrupted by Gujjars

These agitators don't even care for the nuisance they cause to the public. :( :(

Even i am against this reservation and people selected on caste basis...All govt. jobs are given to a particular caste and that is what i hate the most....Deserving candidates are ruled out....

Remedy is not in snatching away the berth of a right,meritorious and deserving candidate, it lies in turning a less meritorious, less skilled cadidate into an efficient,competent and deserving one.

The Gujjar agitation has disrupted train and bus services. There appears hope for an early settlement of dispute.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/gujjars-government-closer-to-resolution-75991