Right age to start schoolinng

2.9K Views
0 Replies
2 min read

I belong to the school of the thought that formal schooling should start at the age of 7. I abide by Rudolf Steiner and have done that for my two children. For me preschool year should start at the age of 5. In my school  parents come for inquiry of admission for children as young as an year and half. And once the child settles down, there is a constant demand to increase their timings of stay in the school. This might be beneficial for parents especially when they are both working. But is it really beneficial for the child?? I have witnessed a mad rush to push children at an inappropriate age for learning and making them "smart ". But on the contrary, I find children lacking life skills which you need more than academics to be really smart.

I hold an opinion that child needs the warmth of a kin and nurturing environment of a home more than school in the initial years of life. This is very crucial for the holistic emotional as well as cognitive skills. Skills taught at school can be built once the child has reached a certain emotional maturity and cognitive strength in his first environment of learning.

Feel free to agree or disagree. 

16 Replies

Today most of the don't want to live in joint families, and in most cases both are working couple. The kid is left at home with made or servant. Now while staying at home with servants or mad the kid will not learn anything good, because the mad or servant will not bother to teach right thing to kid. So it is better for such parents to send their kids to play schools at the age of 2 or above years, atleast the kid will learn something from teachers and other students.

The Student to Teacher ratio in Play Schools is usually less when compared to normal schools. It means, Kids in a Play School, get more attention and care. Additionally, education in Play Schools is much more fun and interactive than in normal Schools

Ideally, the right age to start schooling is age 7 because it is at that age the muscles of a child's wrist are properly developed to wield a pencil and use it in a right manner. Until then, the child absorbs and learns things, languages, ways of communication etc. from his or her surroundings, siblings, family, parents etc. Nowadays, people send their kids to school as soon as they turn 2 or a few months after because they are in a hurry to get back to their own works and/or because the grandparents are not available to look after them. It is true that a child learns quickly when he or she is kids of her own age, but sending the child off to school at such a young age also creates problems. Chief of which is the child either becomes too shy and introvert because of the separation anxiety or they turn this anxiety in aggression. Normal mental development is hindered. Although children quickly recover and get on with it, some part of their mental makeup never recovers. At least, it is my observation.

@ Kalyani. I fully agree with you. The right age for schooling is 7 and that is what is followed in major countries of Europe and many other countries. Waldrof schools and schools following Krishnamurthy's philosophy still do that. Even our old Gurukul system did that. The body and mind is ready for learning after the internal organs have well developed and that the development of internal organ is manifested by change of teeth. Now a days children lose their tooth much before 7 owing to the pressure that the young brain suffers. The energy that Nature stores for the development of internal organs is deviated and directed to the development of intellect ( with over stimulation). Sending them early to school has become a norm and it is beneficial for the parents. The benefits that we see in children are actually  short termed and not good in long terms and that has been proved by psychologists.

The formal schooling begins at between 5 and a half and six years very much like here in almost all the European countries except Finland. They also have play schools where fun activities and skill development takes place for children above three years . Normally these play schools run just for two hours and twice a week to prepare children , more a weaning process..

usha manohar wrote:

The formal schooling begins at between 5 and a half and six years very much like here in almost all the European countries except Finland. They also have play schools where fun activities and skill development takes place for children above three years . Normally these play schools run just for two hours and twice a week to prepare children , more a weaning process..

True Usha, but the kind of play schools that are established now are more business like and commercial. I have seen it when I sent my son to a play school. True that there are many fun activities, games etc. involved but in the later term of the school, the children are made to start writing standing, lines, sleeping lines etc. draw circles, made to colour various forms within lines and made to learn a number of nursery rhymes and stuff which I feel is not fair for a 3 year old. The kids quickly learn those things by heart but can we call that real learning which is achieved through constant hammering and sometimes even punishments?

Kalyani, many of the play schools now follow the Montessori system of education which is interactive technology with NAEYC guidelines that lays stress on visual learning.. children have the ability to do their best during the first four years after birth which is a proven fact .. if the schools adopt the right methods a child benefits greatly during those most formative years!

usha manohar wrote:

Kalyani, many of the play schools now follow the Montessori system of education which is interactive technology with NAEYC guidelines that lays stress on visual learning.. children have the ability to do their best during the first four years after birth which is a proven fact .. if the schools adopt the right methods a child benefits greatly during those most formative years!

I agree with you Usha, a child's learning development is at its best until 5 years of age, but the kind of education and learning that playschools provide is not really in keeping with the guidelines. The education at that age should be focused on language, social development and cognitive learning skills but here they are made to write which is quite difficult as the required muscles are still undeveloped and focus is on learning only specific poems and rhymes rather than on language as a whole.

If we look at the life span of humans and compare it to other animals, we find that humans have the longest childhood. According to most of the school of thoughts of Psychologists it is 0 to 21 years, when one becomes adult. Many would say it is 18 years. But that makes it one fourth of the total life span. Nature never does anything without any use. This long childhood has a message that learning need not be rushed. First 7 years are called formative years because the seed of emotions and intellect is sown by nature and needs a nurturing environment. It is also formative years because the rhythms of body - strengthening of internal organ system, sleep-wake rhythm, food habit  and bowel rhythms have to establish , a preparation for learning ahead in life.

That is not true Kalyani, children have the ability to pick up language skills at two simultaneously learning 2or 3 languages at the same time. It happened with my own children because they had to learn tulu, kannada and English while hey were toddlers ..also the more their brain cells are used the less wastage because a new born has trillions of cells which gets repleted to a few millions by the time they are adults mainly because of dis use during early years  .. more importantly a child knows it's limits and will not exert more than it can . Also , children spend just 2 or 3 hours,at play schools which is just right for social interaction and some early learning process. Most of their cognitive skills and values get taught at home . So home atmosphere is far more important .

 

 

Play Schools, are highly focused  to provide Value based education in a friendly atmosphere. In the initial days, children often exhibit various fussy and demanding attitudes.  The role of a Play School is to train kids to face the Outside world

When do you really face the outside world ?? At 21 or 18?? Do you need to invest so long to prepare for your adulthood?? So childhood is all about preparing for adulthood?? To face outside world?? Childhood according to me is to live like a child, face the issues of childhood and handle it. Not to prepare for adulthood issues??

All good habits, including the preparation of the child  to face the world should  start in the formative years. It's only ,then the Child's habits become strong even after the Child  grows up.

Good habits have to be a part of every stage of life- Good habits in childhood are to help you with happy and healthy childhood. Children unlike us live in present, in the moment. Adults live in future and past.

Its all about Wise Parenting. Good or Bad Habits will be formed in the Formative years. Formative years are Foundation for Good or bad Habits. Its the responsibility of the Parents to inject Good habits from the very beginning.

At age of 3, children try to imitate their elders because this is the right age where start learning different things that comes to them. At this age if we admit them in the school, it will be helpful for them to learn new things, try to perform new activities also they try to do things on their own.. because they are bit crazy to perform every activity that belongs to them so after completion their 3 years they should go to school.

Topic Author

A

Arunima Singh

@Arunima kunwar

Topic Stats

Created Wednesday, 19 October 2016 09:23
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.9K
Likes 3

Share This Topic