Should Yoga be imposed?

On the contrary the Schools or the board should impose rules where the kids practice yoga on a daily basis. This will not only spread awareness but it will be inculcate a healthy practice among the children along while enjoying its various benefits and learn yoga in a beneficial manner.

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

This is probably one activity that will help the students reap health benefits in the long run...However, it is for 9th and 10th students that it is part of the curriculum whereas for others it is for twice or thrice a week ..However, traffic congestion is not an excuse because normally traffic increases after 7 or 8 AM, so starting early to school is actually beneficial to both the student and others who travel later , will see a reduced traffic because of this ..

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/compulsory-yoga-for-cbse-students-of-classes-xi-xii-government/

I agree yoga should not be imposed on children. Instead school can create some extra curricular activity that includes yoga, so that it creates interest in children. Also in this way children will get educated about its benefits.. If someone is really interested will attend the class.

The Yoga Day is being celebrated today in my son's school and in many other schools in Pune, but they are going to do so during regular school hours and are not required to be present early or stay back late.

I personally feel that Yoga is much more better and beneficial than the standard PT exercises being taught compulsorily in the schools. Anything that increases flexibility, concentration and physical as well as mental agility should be welcomed with open minds. Why is there such a loud cry against Yoga being taught in schools?

This is the habit of some people, if some one wants to do good for other, they immediately start opposing it. Same thing has happened in this case also, some started relating yoga to religion, some says it is imposed on us. Yoga is not limited to a single person or country, it is for all and thanks to our P.M. that he is spreading awareness about the benefits of Yoga to the world.

Manoj Kumar Lamba wrote:

This is the habit of some people, if some one wants to do good for other, they immediately start opposing it. Same thing has happened in this case also, some started relating yoga to religion, some says it is imposed on us. Yoga is not limited to a single person or country, it is for all and thanks to our P.M. that he is spreading awareness about the benefits of Yoga to the world.

That is exactly the reason why many groups are opposing Yoga, because it is being promoted by Narendra Modi! I admit that because of certain shlokas and chanting Om during some Asanas and Pranayama, it is associated with Hindu religion, but not everyone is required to say those shlokas, just doing the asanas for their benefit is good enough.

The impression that Yoga is associated with Slokas and Mantras is totally baseless. Even the Asanas are so simple that a child of 6 years in my neighborhood learnt six type of Asanas within a span of 3 months.

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

Yoga has nothing to do with religion. Modi said,Yoga is not a religious practice, but a science for better mental health. UN Secretary General Ban Ki moon said, Yoga is must for harmony, Country's largest border guarding force BSF will soon send a 1900 personnel-strong contingent to advanced training in Yoga exercises and skills by Ramdev at his facility in Haradwar.

 

rambabu wrote:

The impression that Yoga is associated with Slokas and Mantras is totally baseless. Even the Asanas are so simple that a child of 6 years in my neighborhood learnt six type of Asanas within a span of 3 months.

Really?? Baseless? Probably you do not know then that Surya Namaskar is performed while chanting names of the Sun then! And Aumkar is used with some times of Pranayama and meditation, both of which happen to be an integral part of Yoga.

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

Yoga has nothing to do with religion. Modi said,Yoga is not a religious practice, but a science for better mental health. UN Secretary General Ban Ki moon said, Yoga is must for harmony, Country's largest border guarding force BSF will soon send a 1900 personnel-strong contingent to advanced training in Yoga exercises and skills by Ramdev at his facility in Haradwar.

Only and only problem with yoga, that it is associated with Hindu and Hidutav, just like Ayurveda. 

 

 

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

Yoga has nothing to do with religion. Modi said,Yoga is not a religious practice, but a science for better mental health. UN Secretary General Ban Ki moon said, Yoga is must for harmony, Country's largest border guarding force BSF will soon send a 1900 personnel-strong contingent to advanced training in Yoga exercises and skills by Ramdev at his facility in Haradwar.

Only and only problem with yoga, that it is associated with Hindu and Hidutav, just like Ayurveda. 

Why should its association with Hindu and Hinduism be termed as a "problem"?

 

 

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

Yoga has nothing to do with religion. Modi said,Yoga is not a religious practice, but a science for better mental health. UN Secretary General Ban Ki moon said, Yoga is must for harmony, Country's largest border guarding force BSF will soon send a 1900 personnel-strong contingent to advanced training in Yoga exercises and skills by Ramdev at his facility in Haradwar.

Only and only problem with yoga, that it is associated with Hindu and Hidutav, just like Ayurveda. 

Why should its association with Hindu and Hinduism be termed as a "problem"?

How can one relate health related activities or nature to religion, Yoga is as doing some exercises,  and ayurveda is treating diseases by natural products. So religion has nothing to do with yoga or ayurveda.

 

 

Manoj Kumar Lamba wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Not only Yoga, nothing should be imposed or forced. But, awareness on Yoga or its benefits should be spread be it for Private schools or Government Schools.

Yes it is optional.Some  people are habitual of opposing all things. For some peoples it is program of political party. Yoga is for better health of all humans. Today I read that Muslims are also supporting Yoga. They said that we can speak Allaha in place of OM. I think noting wrong in it.

Yoga has nothing to do with religion. Modi said,Yoga is not a religious practice, but a science for better mental health. UN Secretary General Ban Ki moon said, Yoga is must for harmony, Country's largest border guarding force BSF will soon send a 1900 personnel-strong contingent to advanced training in Yoga exercises and skills by Ramdev at his facility in Haradwar.

Only and only problem with yoga, that it is associated with Hindu and Hidutav, just like Ayurveda. 

Why should its association with Hindu and Hinduism be termed as a "problem"?

How can one relate health related activities or nature to religion, Yoga is as doing some exercises,  and ayurveda is treating diseases by natural products. So religion has nothing to do with yoga or ayurveda.

You are right but we can do when some person is seeing only saffron in each thing. It is saying that Sawan Ke Andey Ko Hra Hi Hra Dikhta Hai. At present BJP is rulling party so some person can only see saffron.

 

 

 

Those who link Yoga with Hinduism is Unaware of the fact that presently, Yoga is being highly favored by innumerable number of Christians, Muslims and almost all the religions of the World. I fail to understand, why a therapeutic method is being linked with a religion. Sounds ridiculous.

It is much ado about nothing, Who has done so this time.  The Yoga day came and went away routinely and peacefully.

Yes, Yoga Day has come and went peacefully. And those who link Yoga with religion struggling hard to prove it otherwise. The fact is Yoga remains in  it's position undisturbed and unperturbed.

Exactly so what is the issue? World wide yoga has been done since many years all over the world, without any fuss. It is not that it was discovered only when UN declared a Yoga Day.

Even Well before the declaration of Yoga Day by the UN, Many NGOS were observing Yoga Day in India and abroad. Especially in USA by the NRIs.