Native place of Arya's

What you sad is right. Aryans are believed to have been come from many parts of the world. Some settled in India. But there is no definite conclusion. here is an interestig article

http://www.hinduwebsite.com/hinduism/concepts/aryan.asp

Aryan race comes from Iran and Europe. Remember how Hitler wanted to purify the Population because he himself being an Aryan, he felt others were inferior. Power struggle has always been there either because of race.color or land dispute .

There is a divergence of opinions, regarding original Home of Aryans. Max mueller is of the opinion, the Honme land of Aryans is Central Asia. Swami Dayanand Saraswati says Aryans came from Tibet.Some scholars even deny the theory of Aryan Invasion and subsequent expansion in the Indian Subcontinent.

It is a myth created by English in 17th & 18th centuries to show Indians down. When they came here they saw  flourishing kingdoms and history running to antiquity. So they created the myth that original inhabitants were not so brilliant and outsiders from Central Europe etc came and thus wanted credit for civilization developing in India. Unfortunately whenever their is a theory downgrading Indians there are always significant number of Indians who start parroting these theories. Has it ever occurred to anyone as to why India has always received everything from abroad and never the reverse. It is time history was corrected on this Aryan theory account. Therefore when no Aryans came where is the question of their origin.

In my previous thread, I said, the Theory of Invasion of Aryans it self being denied by Indian Historians. Yes, it's true that History has to be rewritten. High time History written by Colonial British should be set aside.

But not replaced by right wing or left wing historians,

Actually when British, Spanish or Portuguese reached to any new place they thought they had 'Discovered' a new world and own it. Vasco-Da Gama Discovered India, Columbus America and Canada and the list goes on. The most interesting part is that the originals were named

Indians

Red Indian

West Indians  etc. As if there was no culture existed before the learned ones arrived in a particular country. Aryans is sane theory discovered by the learned ones and more so to divide Indians.  

Agreed.. Histories written by different countries, who came to India are mere distortions. We, the natives believed these Distortions. On the whole,, it lead to divisions and sub divisions in the native Indians.

It is a pity that today also this bogus Aryan theory is finding support in India as a tool of superiority.

suni51 wrote:

Actually when British, Spanish or Portuguese reached to any new place they thought they had 'Discovered' a new world and own it. Vasco-Da Gama Discovered India, Columbus America and Canada and the list goes on. The most interesting part is that the originals were named

Indians

Red Indian

West Indians  etc. As if there was no culture existed before the learned ones arrived in a particular country. Aryans is sane theory discovered by the learned ones and more so to divide Indians.  

Nehuru is wrote in his book Discovery of India that Arya came from abrod, it means it is not right. 

rambabu wrote:

What you sad is right. Aryans are believed to have been come from many parts of the world. Some settled in India. But there is no definite conclusion. here is an interestig article

http://www.hinduwebsite.com/hinduism/concepts/aryan.asp

Very interesting article. But author of this article didn't mention period when Arya came to India. Arya Putra words is used in Mahabharat.

 

vijay wrote:

It is a myth created by English in 17th & 18th centuries to show Indians down. When they came here they saw  flourishing kingdoms and history running to antiquity. So they created the myth that original inhabitants were not so brilliant and outsiders from Central Europe etc came and thus wanted credit for civilization developing in India. Unfortunately whenever their is a theory downgrading Indians there are always significant number of Indians who start parroting these theories. Has it ever occurred to anyone as to why India has always received everything from abroad and never the reverse. It is time history was corrected on this Aryan theory account. Therefore when no Aryans came where is the question of their origin.

You mean Arya are Indians?

Sanskrit Language and German language which is spoken in Germany, Austria and  Switzerland have many similarities, which goes to show that there was some kind of interaction centuries ago. Aryan race is a reality and History cannot be rewritten simply because it is written by foreigners...

usha manohar wrote:

Sanskrit Language and German language which is spoken in Germany, Austria and  Switzerland have many similarities, which goes to show that there was some kind of interaction centuries ago. Aryan race is a reality and History cannot be rewritten simply because it is written by foreigners...

It is well known fact that Sanskrit is mother of all other languages.

anil wrote:

rambabu wrote:

What you sad is right. Aryans are believed to have been come from many parts of the world. Some settled in India. But there is no definite conclusion. here is an interestig article

http://www.hinduwebsite.com/hinduism/concepts/aryan.asp

Very interesting article. But author of this article didn't mention period when Arya came to India. Arya Putra words is used in Mahabharat.

Read carefully the article. It's right the Author did not give the time  when the Aryans came to India . Because, there is no definite time about the Arrival of Aryans. Even the Aryan invasion has been dismissed by some eminent Historians.

 

 

anil wrote:

usha manohar wrote:

Sanskrit Language and German language which is spoken in Germany, Austria and  Switzerland have many similarities, which goes to show that there was some kind of interaction centuries ago. Aryan race is a reality and History cannot be rewritten simply because it is written by foreigners...

It is well known fact that Sanskrit is mother of all other languages.

 

Sanskrit is probably the mother of all Indian languages , not world over since there are so many dialects spoken across the world..

Aryans was a term of respect in ancient India used for nobles and rulers. Thus it could be an Indian term. Also the Europeans when they started colonising Asia and Africa found well developed civilizations existing. So they developed the theory that in ancient times there was migration of Europeans into India and Iran and so on to claim that they also had a hand in our development then. Alexander invaded India in 323 BC, Mahabharata is more than 6000 years old and well developed languages were in vogue, so where does the Aryan from outside theory fit in. I was reading yesterday a bizarre theory that West Europeans interacted with upper castes and East Europeans with lower caste in India in ancient times. Ridiculous. India is what it was today even in ancient times. How ancient no one knows.  

Quite a good information  related to India. The facts about ancient India and its rich culture are unquestionable. Any how, about the origin of Aryans and their home still remains as a big question. That's why the home of Aryans could not be ascertained definitively.

Because there were no Aryans from outside, so where is the question of their home. Also why Asians like Indians could not have gone to Europe, why it is always other way round?

That's true. Many famed Historians and Indian Historians contested the issue Aryan Invasion. The web link that was given earlier to Anil clearly says Aryan invasion was a myth.