Politics on suicide of student.

The real issue is the fact that before the Minister wrote to HRD minister the UNIVERSITY HAD ENQUIRED AND GIVEN CLEAN CHIT TO ROHITH and after the letter it punished him and others. Now which action is right is the bone of contention. Both Rahul and Kejriwal are not dumb or half wits, they are furthering their cause at every opportunity, a right which democracy gives them. If Congress was in power and BJP in opposition would the latter have remained quiet? Bias should not be a basis for judging.

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Arvind Kejriwal is indeed a half witted, dumb person who deserves no attention. Truth is that Rohith Vemula and the ASA (Ambedkar Students Association ) the group he was an activist for, indulged in anti-national activities and were protesting against the execution of Yakub Memon. He even had the audacity to call Swami Vivekanand as a half-witted person and a fake intellectual. I found this copy of the VC's letter to Smriti Irani which clearly reveals this. I think it is high time media was reprimanded for focusing on the issue on basis of caste system and trying to polarize the students.

Favoring person like yakub menon in any way is equal to treason.  He was sentensed by the court not by any political party. Univercities and collage are for study not for dirty politics.

In India politicians are more busy in poking their nose in every matter which is actually not at all their matter of concern. They must find out the truth first and then come to a conclusion. University campus is not a place for politics and so politicians should not be given any importance regarding it. If the VC was wrong then it should be judged by the court and not the politicians who start to ignite the matter in a more dangerous way. I am stating this in context to each and every political party.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

In India politicians are more busy in poking their nose in every matter which is actually not at all their matter of concern. They must find out the truth first and then come to a conclusion. University campus is not a place for politics and so politicians should not be given any importance regarding it. If the VC was wrong then it should be judged by the court and not the politicians who start to ignite the matter in a more dangerous way. I am stating this in context to each and every political party.

In India we respect and regards school and collages like temples. These are temple of education and platform for gloryfying politics.

anil wrote:

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

In India politicians are more busy in poking their nose in every matter which is actually not at all their matter of concern. They must find out the truth first and then come to a conclusion. University campus is not a place for politics and so politicians should not be given any importance regarding it. If the VC was wrong then it should be judged by the court and not the politicians who start to ignite the matter in a more dangerous way. I am stating this in context to each and every political party.

In India we respect and regards school and collages like temples. These are temple of education and platform for gloryfying politics.

 

Sorry Anil. Those days educational institutions were really treated as " Vidyalayas."Teachers were treated as Gurus in accordance with the adage, GuruDevo Bhavaha ". They used to impart knowledge  without any bias or prejudice. Now the present Gurus are corrupted. Of course, there are reasons for the present state of sad condition. Teachers are poorly paid. Wrong government policies and corrupt administrators are at the helm of the affairs together contributed to the deterioration of the educational institutions. Now educational institutions are the centers of politics. They are completely under the politicians.

 

anil wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Arvind Kejriwal is indeed a half witted, dumb person who deserves no attention. Truth is that Rohith Vemula and the ASA (Ambedkar Students Association ) the group he was an activist for, indulged in anti-national activities and were protesting against the execution of Yakub Memon. He even had the audacity to call Swami Vivekanand as a half-witted person and a fake intellectual. I found this copy of the VC's letter to Smriti Irani which clearly reveals this. I think it is high time media was reprimanded for focusing on the issue on basis of caste system and trying to polarize the students.

Favoring person like yakub menon in any way is equal to treason.  He was sentensed by the court not by any political party. Univercities and collage are for study not for dirty politics.

Like other politicians Mr. Arvind Kejriwal is also doing his vote bank politics. He went to Dadri, he went to Hyderabad and when questions asked about Malda West Bengal, he said he is the C.M. of Delhi and don't want to interfere in the matter of West Bengal government. But now the question is whether the Hyderabad is a part of Delhi?

In my view suicide by ONE student in a nation of 1.2 billion is not important. What is played up is the politics of caste which will ultimately sink India. Gandhi, Ambedkar, Vivekananda and many more ALL failed to eradicate caste.

The Chinese Institute of Strategic studies has forecast break up of India due to Caste and Muslim politics. Lets see what happens. The problem is however dire and I feel caste should be equated with aparthied and the UNO must intervene.

Before committing suicide, the Dalit research scholar Rohit Vemula had sent warning signals to the university authorities. In a letter, he described some possible modes of suicide and had asked the authorities to offer "euthansia" for him and other research scholars. He submitted this letter with a petition demanding that the administration of the university revoke their expulsion from hostels. But the administration rejected his demand and so he decided to kill himself.                                                                       

VC Appa Rao, already lifted the ban on the remaining . Scholars. But the Dalit Students, who were agitating continuing the strike, demanding,Rs.10 lakhs compensation and a job for the family member of Rohit.

The VC is a protege of Venkiah Naidu the politician, and surpassed 35 others. As a warden also he had tiff with Dalits. Dalits are discriminated from centuries. What happened to Eklavya when he had to offer his thumb to the cunning Dronacharya. It is shameful that even after seventy years cast is not leaving us. We are full of advice as to how Muslims should behave but conveniently look the other way at our own severe shortcomings. These weaknesses are responsible forour subjugation in the past.

Manoj Kumar Lamba wrote:

anil wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Arvind Kejriwal is indeed a half witted, dumb person who deserves no attention. Truth is that Rohith Vemula and the ASA (Ambedkar Students Association ) the group he was an activist for, indulged in anti-national activities and were protesting against the execution of Yakub Memon. He even had the audacity to call Swami Vivekanand as a half-witted person and a fake intellectual. I found this copy of the VC's letter to Smriti Irani which clearly reveals this. I think it is high time media was reprimanded for focusing on the issue on basis of caste system and trying to polarize the students.

Favoring person like yakub menon in any way is equal to treason.  He was sentensed by the court not by any political party. Univercities and collage are for study not for dirty politics.

Like other politicians Mr. Arvind Kejriwal is also doing his vote bank politics. He went to Dadri, he went to Hyderabad and when questions asked about Malda West Bengal, he said he is the C.M. of Delhi and don't want to interfere in the matter of West Bengal government. But now the question is whether the Hyderabad is a part of Delhi?

He is bluff master. he said in Punjab that if his party will come in power he will bane wine, but only MP of his party always remains drunken.

anil wrote:

Manoj Kumar Lamba wrote:

anil wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Arvind Kejriwal is indeed a half witted, dumb person who deserves no attention. Truth is that Rohith Vemula and the ASA (Ambedkar Students Association ) the group he was an activist for, indulged in anti-national activities and were protesting against the execution of Yakub Memon. He even had the audacity to call Swami Vivekanand as a half-witted person and a fake intellectual. I found this copy of the VC's letter to Smriti Irani which clearly reveals this. I think it is high time media was reprimanded for focusing on the issue on basis of caste system and trying to polarize the students.

Favoring person like yakub menon in any way is equal to treason.  He was sentensed by the court not by any political party. Univercities and collage are for study not for dirty politics.

Like other politicians Mr. Arvind Kejriwal is also doing his vote bank politics. He went to Dadri, he went to Hyderabad and when questions asked about Malda West Bengal, he said he is the C.M. of Delhi and don't want to interfere in the matter of West Bengal government. But now the question is whether the Hyderabad is a part of Delhi?

He is bluff master. he said in Punjab that if his party will come in power he will bane wine, but only MP of his party always remains drunken.

Not only Kejriwal, but all those Khaddar topi walas who made a bee line to shower sympathy on Rohit, are bent upon defaming the ruling party. Of course, these tricks are well understood by the people.

 

According to police investigation, there was no proof found that Mr. Rohit was a Dalit student. He got admission in university on general seat, and his mother father both are of OBC category. But the vote bank hungers made him a Dalit student and made the college issue as a National issue.

http://navbharattimes.indiatimes.com/state/other-states/hyderabad/probe-suggests-vemula-family-not-dalit-police/articleshow/50692298.cms

I am sure there are many such cases where people from general merit change their caste to one from the reserved category just to get all the benefits that go with i9t ! What a pahetic farce our nation has been reserved over the years by the total mis management of the caste factor by the previous governments and its leaders ! The entire nation will have to pay for their blunder !

The reservation based on caste system should be totally abolished. Even students having poor marks get admission in good institutes on the basis of reservation while some of those students having good marks and who can perform better will not admitted because of unreserved category.  It is better to give reservation on the basis of economical condition and not on the basis of caste or relegion.

There seems to be a lot of sympathy for vemulla which is not wrong for a young person lost his life, but can the blame be laid only on the university admin and the government. If you all read the following link, we can clearly see that it was his own faltering values and beliefs that led him astray. initially he was a person who followed and admired Swami Vivekanand, later on turned to abusing and criticising him in a poor show of decency and disrespect. can Vemulla's failure to stick to his own values be blamed on others? That alone shows his own lack of strength

http://www.indianexponent.com/2016/01/the-real-truth-of-rohith-vemula-suicide.html?m=1

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

There seems to be a lot of sympathy for vemulla which is not wrong for a young person lost his life, but can the blame be laid only on the university admin and the government. If you all read the following link, we can clearly see that it was his own faltering values and beliefs that led him astray. initially he was a person who followed and admired Swami Vivekanand, later on turned to abusing and criticising him in a poor show of decency and disrespect. can Vemulla's failure to stick to his own values be blamed on others? That alone shows his own lack of strength

 

http://www.indianexponent.com/2016/01/the-real-truth-of-rohith-vemula-suicide.html?m=1

I agree that suicide is an extreme step and this indicates extreme frustration and pessimism.  Nobody can be praised for such step in any circumstances.  But it is also necessary to consider the circumstances and individuals/ institutions that are guilty in the matter. There is no doubt that educational authorities are squarely to blame. We cannot find fault with the deceased scholar for change in his ideas. We all change our ideas from time to time. He first like Swamy Vivekanand but later changed his opinion. He was entitled to review his own views and cannot be faulted for this. 

 

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

There seems to be a lot of sympathy for vemulla which is not wrong for a young person lost his life, but can the blame be laid only on the university admin and the government. If you all read the following link, we can clearly see that it was his own faltering values and beliefs that led him astray. initially he was a person who followed and admired Swami Vivekanand, later on turned to abusing and criticising him in a poor show of decency and disrespect. can Vemulla's failure to stick to his own values be blamed on others? That alone shows his own lack of strength

 

http://www.indianexponent.com/2016/01/the-real-truth-of-rohith-vemula-suicide.html?m=1

I agree that suicide is an extreme step and this indicates extreme frustration and pessimism.  Nobody can be praised for such step in any circumstances.  But it is also necessary to consider the circumstances and individuals/ institutions that are guilty in the matter. There is no doubt that educational authorities are squarely to blame. We cannot find fault with the deceased scholar for change in his ideas. We all change our ideas from time to time. He first like Swamy Vivekanand but later changed his opinion. He was entitled to review his own views and cannot be faulted for this. 

 

It is clear that you have not read the link properly. A person is indeed entitled to change his views from time to time, no doubt about that. But a person who keeps faltering between different political theories in such a drastic manner is clearly a sign of disturbed and unstable mind.  Another big question that no one is asking answer for is, if he was there to study, why didn't he stick to his studies? Why get embroiled in dirty politics and anarchism sponsored by AAP?

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

There seems to be a lot of sympathy for vemulla which is not wrong for a young person lost his life, but can the blame be laid only on the university admin and the government. If you all read the following link, we can clearly see that it was his own faltering values and beliefs that led him astray. initially he was a person who followed and admired Swami Vivekanand, later on turned to abusing and criticising him in a poor show of decency and disrespect. can Vemulla's failure to stick to his own values be blamed on others? That alone shows his own lack of strength

 

http://www.indianexponent.com/2016/01/the-real-truth-of-rohith-vemula-suicide.html?m=1

I agree that suicide is an extreme step and this indicates extreme frustration and pessimism.  Nobody can be praised for such step in any circumstances.  But it is also necessary to consider the circumstances and individuals/ institutions that are guilty in the matter. There is no doubt that educational authorities are squarely to blame. We cannot find fault with the deceased scholar for change in his ideas. We all change our ideas from time to time. He first like Swamy Vivekanand but later changed his opinion. He was entitled to review his own views and cannot be faulted for this. 

 

It is clear that you have not read the link properly. A person is indeed entitled to change his views from time to time, no doubt about that. But a person who keeps faltering between different political theories in such a drastic manner is clearly a sign of disturbed and unstable mind.  Another big question that no one is asking answer for is, if he was there to study, why didn't he stick to his studies? Why get embroiled in dirty politics and anarchism sponsored by AAP?

 

That's exactly what I ask some of my own students who are still in Junior college and yet to have any mental maturity. The Political parties chase them and try every trick in the trade to shape them according to their needs and the impressionable minds simply fall for it , losing interest in studies and getting embroiled in criminal activities and goondaism , basically become henchmen for the local leader . The local MLA from the ruling party of our state is a highly corrupt character who thinks schools are his playing ground and the manner in which he uses up the amenities meant for students is disgusting and shameful, but who can question the fellow ? One of the students a girl had to leave college because of his misbehavior, he behaves as if he is an avatar of Mahatma Gandhi , with all that but I am hoping that people here now know better...If he gets elected again, then there is no hope for the state or for the people of this state ,,

usha manohar wrote:

I am sure there are many such cases where people from general merit change their caste to one from the reserved category just to get all the benefits that go with i9t ! What a pahetic farce our nation has been reserved over the years by the total mis management of the caste factor by the previous governments and its leaders ! The entire nation will have to pay for their blunder !

I am glad you have pointed this out. I wonder what the so called reformers like Vivekananda, Gandhi and ary samaj did all these years.