Great students make great teachers

Yes, because if the student work hard it will give the teacher more interest to make his student learn new things

. Teachers have a long lasting impact on the lives of their students. Students who fare well inspire the teachers too.

I could not agree more. Learning and teaching are two sides of same coin. This is imparting knowledge/ skill.  Only a good student can be good teacher. That is why good academic record is of paramount importance for one seeking teaching assignment.  A teacher must always update his knowledge implying that he must always remain a student. 

An ideal teacher learns first in order to impart knowledge to the students. An ideal student understands the intentions of his teacher. Such teachers and their ideologies are remembered forever. Such students who excel in studies inspire the teachers.

An ideal teacher is the idol of patience and knowledge. The true teacher is patient and knowledgeable enough to teach every student without any biasness. Therefore, good teachers are great.Yes, good teachers become greater in the case when they try to learn from their best students. However, personally I believe that a good teacher is cherished by a student and I think teacher should have a sense of care for students because due to this care, the children can share their issues with their teachers as they develop a sense of trust with them. Good teachers never break such trust.

Exactly. What you said is very true. A great teacher is one whom the student cherishes forever. When late Abdul Kalam was honored, he has attributed all his greatness to his teacher. Seeing his student's ability and worth, the teacher has become proud. This is how  great students make great teachers.

I would like to add that great student in my opinion is not he/she who has academically proved his/her worth. A great student can be a little less meritorious but has to be extremely humble, very inquisitive regarding knowledge, must have respect for the teachers and elders and must value time. It is not that a 95% holder is a great student in comparison to those who got less than 80% or so. Greatness is a huge term which does not only relate to intelligence and academic performance but it also includes the behavioural pattern of the student. A great student can attain the position of a great teacher only when he/she has a quest for knowledge and knows how to remain dedicated to the students.

Good students are created by Good teachers alone. May be the student possess some good qualities. But these are in a haphazard manner. It's the teacher who arranges all the inherent  sparks in to a Fire. Hence, A good product is made only when the raw material is good. Such good students remember their teachers all along.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

I would like to add that great student in my opinion is not he/she who has academically proved his/her worth. A great student can be a little less meritorious but has to be extremely humble, very inquisitive regarding knowledge, must have respect for the teachers and elders and must value time. It is not that a 95% holder is a great student in comparison to those who got less than 80% or so. Greatness is a huge term which does not only relate to intelligence and academic performance but it also includes the behavioural pattern of the student. A great student can attain the position of a great teacher only when he/she has a quest for knowledge and knows how to remain dedicated to the students.

In effect a person who is compassionate and has humane qualities ...I totally agree with that !

The words great, good are blanket terms which make it difficult to discuss this topic.  Great academically or in attitude?  There are many teachers who have won merits and awards but cannot come to the level of a student.

However, a person who has a passion for the profession makes an effective teacher. The desire to impart knowledge and all round development need to be at the core of a teachers heart. 

Without passion any profession become just a form of livelihood. 

If great people are made, It's due to the efforts of the Teachers. When Late Dr. Abdul Kalam was honored for his contributions in Space research, He said he owed his greatness to his teacher.So its implied that both the factors are needed. Teachers who make the great students. And great students who rose up to expectations of his teacher..

@usha manohar Absolutely, compassion is a must. A teacher may be very good at imparting knowledge but is not humane at all then as a teacher he/she fails. A simple example I want to cite here is when students go for inter-school competitions then there are some teachers who do not allow those participants an extra day or two to complete their work rather they speak abusively, mark their assignments as late submission and what not. This is highly unacceptable but you can do nothing because in school teachers are the authority. The students pay respect to those teachers who are considerate and I believe that they must be understanding. The students could not complete their work because they were on duty for their school only and that must be taken care of.  

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

@usha manohar Absolutely, compassion is a must. A teacher may be very good at imparting knowledge but is not humane at all then as a teacher he/she fails. A simple example I want to cite here is when students go for inter-school competitions then there are some teachers who do not allow those participants an extra day or two to complete their work rather they speak abusively, mark their assignments as late submission and what not. This is highly unacceptable but you can do nothing because in school teachers are the authority. The students pay respect to those teachers who are considerate and I believe that they must be understanding. The students could not complete their work because they were on duty for their school only and that must be taken care of.  

More than anything it shows the narrow vision of the teacher who is unable to perceive the advantage of taking part in debates and other competetions for both the student and the school.I faced this problem with my children and had to fight it out with the headmistress and the management commitee reps of their school..

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

@usha manohar Absolutely, compassion is a must. A teacher may be very good at imparting knowledge but is not humane at all then as a teacher he/she fails. A simple example I want to cite here is when students go for inter-school competitions then there are some teachers who do not allow those participants an extra day or two to complete their work rather they speak abusively, mark their assignments as late submission and what not. This is highly unacceptable but you can do nothing because in school teachers are the authority. The students pay respect to those teachers who are considerate and I believe that they must be understanding. The students could not complete their work because they were on duty for their school only and that must be taken care of.  

This behavior of teachers mirrors their ignorance and intolerance. They have biased and one sided views which they force on the tolerance. The example you cited on Sports is a standing example.

@sofs

Yes, you said it very rightly. Great academicians might not turn out to be a great teacher because of his/her lack of involvement in the teaching profession. Having knowledge is absolutely different from imparting knowledge. Those teachers are truly great teachers when they are able to explain the subject very convincingly but who fail to do so despite holding academic awards cannot be termed as great teachers. The students have to be extremely satisfied or else it's meaningless and along with it if students respect the teacher for his/her loving nature then nothing is greater than this.

Shampa Sadhya wrote:

@sofs

Yes, you said it very rightly. Great academicians might not turn out to be a great teacher because of his/her lack of involvement in the teaching profession. Having knowledge is absolutely different from imparting knowledge. Those teachers are truly great teachers when they are able to explain the subject very convincingly but who fail to do so despite holding academic awards cannot be termed as great teachers. The students have to be extremely satisfied or else it's meaningless and along with it if students respect the teacher for his/her loving nature then nothing is greater than this.

Basically any profession should be taken up because you feel that you can contribute positively and not simply to earn a living ! Shampa, you can use the quote button found underneath each comment like I have done , so that we get to read both the comment posted by other members and your response !

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

I could not agree more. Learning and teaching are two sides of same coin. This is imparting knowledge/ skill.  Only a good student can be good teacher. That is why good academic record is of paramount importance for one seeking teaching assignment.  A teacher must always update his knowledge implying that he must always remain a student. 

It is right that academic records is important for any assignment including teacher, but it is right that an average student can be a good teacher.

anil wrote:

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

I could not agree more. Learning and teaching are two sides of same coin. This is imparting knowledge/ skill.  Only a good student can be good teacher. That is why good academic record is of paramount importance for one seeking teaching assignment.  A teacher must always update his knowledge implying that he must always remain a student. 

It is right that academic records is important for any assignment including teacher, but it is right that an average student can be a good teacher.

A devoted teacher and an equally devoted student will do miracles resulting in an exemplary Teacher and an extraordinary student. It works well when both teachers and the students think on the same level of aiming at the respective assigned duties and work in the best of their abilities.