What happens if minister is underqualified

When agenda is the priority then talent does not matter. 

As long as the minister executes his aasigned jobs in tune with the needs of the ministry, qualification or no qualification, doesn't matter.

rambabu wrote:

As long as the minister executes his aasigned jobs in tune with the needs of the ministry, qualification or no qualification, doesn't matter.

 

The issue mentioned in post relates to bad consequences of appointing under qualified minister. 

But who will decide whether the minister is wrong? Some comments say the scientist in the first place is not qualified to be posted on that particular post.

I could not read the article since it is in hindi and I am not very fluent with it. However, this appointing under-qualified ministers has been happening since Independence so no great issues there...However, personally speaking I feel that Politicians shd have a minimum educational qualification to take up any responsible post ! We have had a near illiterate in Rabri Devi run a state with the blessings of Ally Congress at the center, so, anything goes in this country of ours, so why point fingers at Smriti Irani now ? opinions differ as this link for another article on the same subject proves....Even Tagore never finished school!!!!

http://www.livemint.com/Opinion/PwVQxqfEWjPw8C2gzl1uHL/Smriti-Irani-as-HRD-minister-Why-not.html

You forgot to make your link live :)

Even Bill gates under whom many highly qualified persons  are working was a school dropout. Low qualification will not be hindrance as long as the ability part lies intact.

usha manohar wrote:

I could not read the article since it is in hindi and I am not very fluent with it. However, this appointing under-qualified ministers has been happening since Independence so no great issues there...However, personally speaking I feel that Politicians shd have a minimum educational qualification to take up any responsible post ! We have had a near illiterate in Rabri Devi run a state with the blessings of Ally Congress at the center, so, anything goes in this country of ours, so why point fingers at Smriti Irani now ? opinions differ as this link for another article on the same subject proves....Even Tagore never finished school!!!!

http://www.livemint.com/Opinion/PwVQxqfEWjPw8C2gzl1uHL/Smriti-Irani-as-HRD-minister-Why-not.html

You forgot to make your link live :)

 

This country will never take a single step ahead. The sole purpose of discussion of politicians is criticism and leg pulling of ruling party. What all we discuss is how to dethrone the ruling party.

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

RAMAKRISHNAN. A wrote:

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

Education qualification not alone but overall experience- duration and quality, aptitude all these matter. Here problem remains because the concerned minister is not qualified in any sense- academic or non academic, experience or aptitude.  

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

RAMAKRISHNAN. A wrote:

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

Education qualification not alone but overall experience- duration and quality, aptitude all these matter. Here problem remains because the concerned minister is not qualified in any sense- academic or non academic, experience or aptitude.

 

Then what for such ministers are there? For the perks ? 

 

rambabu wrote:

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

RAMAKRISHNAN. A wrote:

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

Education qualification not alone but overall experience- duration and quality, aptitude all these matter. Here problem remains because the concerned minister is not qualified in any sense- academic or non academic, experience or aptitude.

 

Then what for such ministers are there? For the perks ? 

There is a proverb-  dulhan (minster  vohi jo piya (PM)  man bhaye.  Hope this needs no elucidation.  

 

 

 

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

RAMAKRISHNAN. A wrote:

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

Education qualification not alone but overall experience- duration and quality, aptitude all these matter. Here problem remains because the concerned minister is not qualified in any sense- academic or non academic, experience or aptitude.

 

Then what for such ministers are there? For the perks ? 

There is a proverb-  dulhan (minster  vohi jo piya (PM)  man bhaye.  Hope this needs no elucidation.  

Ahaha. So Piya Man lutaana Sabse Mukhya kaam hai. Qualification or no qualification . Wah Miyan.... Wah..

 

 

 

 

The qualification of ministers and the roles they really play has always been quite questionable in India for some time now. Come to think of it, even highly educated ministers could not do much in their roles, what could be the reason for that? eg. Manmohan Singh a highly accomplished economist but famous for being silent and inert at all times.

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

The qualification of ministers and the roles they really play has always been quite questionable in India for some time now. Come to think of it, even highly educated ministers could not do much in their roles, what could be the reason for that? eg. Manmohan Singh a highly accomplished economist but famous for being silent and inert at all times.

 

Exactly ! In fact now Congress wants to project Rahul Gandhi who is a university drop out like Smriti Irani the PM candidate !!!! They were ready to hand over power to Sonia Gandhi whose educational qualifications are shrouded in mystery 

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

rambabu wrote:

Gulshan Kumar Ajmani wrote:

RAMAKRISHNAN. A wrote:

Educational qualifications like graduation or post-graduation need not be the criteria for determining the ministerial competence. They should be intelligent, honest and should perform their duties sincerely, with a heart full of commitment to the people who elected them.

Education qualification not alone but overall experience- duration and quality, aptitude all these matter. Here problem remains because the concerned minister is not qualified in any sense- academic or non academic, experience or aptitude.

 

Then what for such ministers are there? For the perks ? 

There is a proverb-  dulhan (minster  vohi jo piya (PM)  man bhaye.  Hope this needs no elucidation.  

 

I agree with you sir, but in case of Congress Piya Manmohan (read PM) even that was not possible. It was all in remote hands so everything went topsy-turvy, right from top to bottom.

 

 

 

 

usha manohar wrote:

Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:

The qualification of ministers and the roles they really play has always been quite questionable in India for some time now. Come to think of it, even highly educated ministers could not do much in their roles, what could be the reason for that? eg. Manmohan Singh a highly accomplished economist but famous for being silent and inert at all times.

 

Exactly ! In fact now Congress wants to project Rahul Gandhi who is a university drop out like Smriti Irani the PM candidate !!!! They were ready to hand over power to Sonia Gandhi whose educational qualifications are shrouded in mystery 

 

It should be the experience and vision that needs to be counted for in India, asking for ministers who are well educated, well cultured and equally versed in politics is asking for too much. Also even if such a person did exist, he is given a rather insignificant role where he cannot do much, like the former President Mr. APJ Abdul Kalam or rendered a hapless puppet like ex-PM Manmohan Singh!