Hindi v/s English

2.1K Views
0 Replies
1 min read
We all know English is worldwide known language and is growing its roots. In India some people think that there is a competition between their own language Hindi and English, and due to increasing value of English the value of Hindi is going down day by day. The Hindi lovers want that their language should be used everywhere in India, but we cannot ignore the importance of English. I think both Hindi and English are necessary languages in India.

20 Replies

it should be shame for India that their own language is treated as foreign language in their own country, and a foreign language is given priority and easily understood. we should proud of our own language and culture instead of ignoring it.


You need be pragmatic and not be beligerant about so called own lnguage and culture. In fact, English has enriched itself by adopting words from different languages. The words like Pucca, safari. Purdah have been borrowed from other languages. Then what is wrong if Hindi adopts foreign words that are popular. The terms like Gas, cylinder, University etc are well understood and these must be incorporated in Hindi.

Incidentally, I feel that English technical terms should be accepted in all Indian languages for the sake of simplicity and uniformity. Why do you wish to use 'sakshya' for evidence. Why in chemistry you want to translate 'latent heat' as Gupta Ushma.


Or 'Lohpatgamini' for -----


I think both Hindi and English usage of terms used here will enhance our Hindi knowledge and also will not add to any confusion if an alternative in English is provided. If possible schools and colleges and universities should take it up.


All words that are popularly used by Hindi speaking people should be treated as Hindi words. Thus University, school, park, musuem, cinema, station are Hindi words. The technical terms as used in English should be adoptd in all Indian languages. This will ensure uniformity and same technical term will be be used and understood throughout India.


In fact many of our words have found their way into the English language - Bunglow, Janta,Bandicoot , Jute etc etc. So they have been influenced as much as we have been ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_of_Indian_origin
Parents and schools should also give equal importance to the regional languages so that their children is equally proficient in their mother tongue. It is very irritating to see some young teenagers who can't even complete a sentence in their mother tongue. We should not ignore the importance and richness of our regional languages.
it should be shame for India that their own language is treated as foreign language in their own country, and a foreign language is given priority and easily understood. we should proud of our own language and culture instead of ignoring it.


You need be pragmatic and not be beligerant about so called own lnguage and culture. In fact, English has enriched itself by adopting words from different languages. The words like Pucca, safari. Purdah have been borrowed from other languages. Then what is wrong if Hindi adopts foreign words that are popular. The terms like Gas, cylinder, University etc are well understood and these must be incorporated in Hindi.

Incidentally, I feel that English technical terms should be accepted in all Indian languages for the sake of simplicity and uniformity. Why do you wish to use 'sakshya' for evidence. Why in chemistry you want to translate 'latent heat' as Gupta Ushma.


Or 'Lohpatgamini' for -----


I think both Hindi and English usage of terms used here will enhance our Hindi knowledge and also will not add to any confusion if an alternative in English is provided. If possible schools and colleges and universities should take it up.


All words that are popularly used by Hindi speaking people should be treated as Hindi words. Thus University, school, park, musuem, cinema, station are Hindi words. The technical terms as used in English should be adoptd in all Indian languages. This will ensure uniformity and same technical term will be be used and understood throughout India.


In fact many of our words have found their way into the English language - Bunglow, Janta,Bandicoot , Jute etc etc. So they have been influenced as much as we have been ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_of_Indian_origin


Juggernaut, nirvana, Suttee are some more words joined the English language.
As like Hindi, English keeps importance in our country. We all know that Indian languages is changes as state changes. Person from one state is unable to understand all other state languages in proper manner. This create separation. English decreases this separation and bring people of all state under one roof.
In fact Hindi and English should not be pitted against each other. Both these languages are required for the smooth functioning of our society. At the same time Indian vernacular languages should not be dropped off completely, we belong to a multi-lingual society/ country and this is what makes us unique, so instead of fighting over languages, or making one language superior to another we should give importance to both Hindi and English and also encourage using our mother tongue for the newer generation.
I'm a firm believer in the formula THE. Telugu, ( my Mother tongue)Hindi and English.I never faced any problems in implementing my Formula.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Funny it may sound..but the first phrase I learned when I was in Hyderabad..was 'Telugu raadu'..because apparently, people thought I was one among them...but when I came to speak their language..I failed :) :)
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


I agree that knowledge of many languages is beneficial but this is not always feasible. Everyone is not capable of learning many languages. Mostly, knowlege of Hindi and English suffices. It is natural that everyone is conversant with the language of his own region. I am in Brij region. In agra- Mathura area, Brij Bhasha- a variant of Hindi is spoken. I can follow this when others speak but myself cannot speak in Brij Bhasha. Famous poet Soordas wrote in this language.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.


True to the core...learning a language always comes in handy and useful..but only hurdle is to continue using a language over time or else we lose touch and may even forget esp true in case of foreign languages such as German, Russian and so on.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.


True to the core...learning a language always comes in handy and useful..but only hurdle is to continue using a language over time or else we lose touch and may even forget esp true in case of foreign languages such as German, Russian and so on.


That is why you should concentrate only on the language you need to communicate in the region you live apart from Hindi and english that are more widely used. Instead of learning so many languages it is better to learn some skill or topic that is useful and interesting.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.


True to the core...learning a language always comes in handy and useful..but only hurdle is to continue using a language over time or else we lose touch and may even forget esp true in case of foreign languages such as German, Russian and so on.


That is why you should concentrate only on the language you need to communicate in the region you live apart from Hindi and english that are more widely used. Instead of learning so many languages it is better to learn some skill or topic that is useful and interesting.


I beg to differ with you Sir. Learning is a continuous process and learning anything new, even a new language has been proved quite healthy for our brains.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.


True to the core...learning a language always comes in handy and useful..but only hurdle is to continue using a language over time or else we lose touch and may even forget esp true in case of foreign languages such as German, Russian and so on.


That is why you should concentrate only on the language you need to communicate in the region you live apart from Hindi and english that are more widely used. Instead of learning so many languages it is better to learn some skill or topic that is useful and interesting.


I beg to differ with you Sir. Learning is a continuous process and learning anything new, even a new language has been proved quite healthy for our brains.


In my case learning new languages other than my mother tongue, Hindi and English, never proved futile. Rather they widened my knowledge base.
to walk with time we should learn all languages which are used in our day to day life. we should focus in learning our regional language to communicate with locals, Hindi to communicate in India and English to communicate with foreigners.


Well communicating in English is not just limited to foreigners...we do communicate in English with fellow Indian. However, yes even i try to learn ..the language in which ever place i go...I had to learn Bengali (my mother tongue), English,Hindi, and Oriya in school, picked up a little bit of Telugu..while in Hyderabad..and now I understand Marathi. Learning language is fun and also gives you an opportunity to communicate with the local people better.


Learning more languages is a plus point. It not only makes the communication easy in new places, but builds relationships. Just say, "Soukyama Thambi" in Tamilnadu. And see how the person goes out of the way and renders all the help you need.


Absolutely ! I too feel that it is good have at least working knowledge of as many languages as you can. I am able to speak fluently English, Hindi,Kannada, Tulu, Tamil and a little Telugu , German and Malyalam as well and it really has helped when I travel and visit other places ...


Wow..Usha it is amazing that you know so many languages...also when one knows more than one or two languages/dialects it becomes so easy to interact with people. I always wanted to and still keen on learning Spanish, which is closest to English..but it didn't quite happen.


It reminds me of an old incident when I was employed in a steel Major constructed with the collaboration Of Russians. To communicate with them i learned Russian throug "Teach yourself series ". And my Russian friends used to polish my accent and pronunciation. And over a period i could raise my standard of Russian knowledge.
Language learning will never go waste.


True to the core...learning a language always comes in handy and useful..but only hurdle is to continue using a language over time or else we lose touch and may even forget esp true in case of foreign languages such as German, Russian and so on.


That is why you should concentrate only on the language you need to communicate in the region you live apart from Hindi and english that are more widely used. Instead of learning so many languages it is better to learn some skill or topic that is useful and interesting.


I beg to differ with you Sir. Learning is a continuous process and learning anything new, even a new language has been proved quite healthy for our brains.


Language is only a medium of expression and not more than that. so it suffices to know English, Hindi and local language. For example, if you live in Andhra, English, Hindi and Telugu will suffice. Somebody keen to learn many languages can do so but others can do well with fewer. Persoally I know only English and Hindi and this is okay with me. I don't need to learn any other language for communication at Agra.
Language is not only medium of communication, it creates employment opportunities also. Translators are in high demand.

Topic Author

Topic Stats

Created Tuesday, 22 July 2014 04:04
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.1K
Likes 0

Share This Topic