CBI is unconstitutional- Guwahati High Court verdict

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I find this amazing ! It has too many far reaching implications and we can see how the unscruplous take adavantage .Sajjan Kumar Singh accused in 1984 riots is already planning to take the issue upto court since CBI was the one that was involved in the investigation, and this is only the beginning...

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

But CBI is working in all states. Every state has special CBI courts. Yes it is crisis.

If CBI is unconstitutional then no other organisations are constitutional in Guwahati. :silly: :P

What I can gather from this decision is that the law we have in this country is too complicated for even courts to understand and decide what is constitutional. I fail to understand if this is so complicated case for courts, how would an ordinary understand his rights. The need is to make laws simple, clear, transparent for every one to understand without having any bylaws even if they have to write the law-books all over again. Half of the pending cases will go immediately.

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

Its a different issue. The issue is how CBI could act, investigate arrest annexe the properties if its an unconstitutional body since 1963? What about those who are in prisons on the charges of CBI?

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

Its a different issue. The issue is how CBI could act, investigate arrest annexe the properties if its an unconstitutional body since 1963? What about those who are in prisons on the charges of CBI?

CBI has never been constitutional body, as the power derives can only be known from its formation and the honorable court judgment can be seen like this but still apex court ruling is awaited on this.

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

Its a different issue. The issue is how CBI could act, investigate arrest annexe the properties if its an unconstitutional body since 1963? What about those who are in prisons on the charges of CBI?

CBI has never been constitutional body, as the power derives can only be known from its formation and the honorable court judgment can be seen like this but still apex court ruling is awaited on this.

What you are saying is about the present situation. What about those who are in the jails and whose property is annexed by the CBI like Telecom scam for which erstwhile minister was arrested ?

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

Its a different issue. The issue is how CBI could act, investigate arrest annexe the properties if its an unconstitutional body since 1963? What about those who are in prisons on the charges of CBI?

CBI has never been constitutional body, as the power derives can only be known from its formation and the honorable court judgment can be seen like this but still apex court ruling is awaited on this.

What you are saying is about the present situation. What about those who are in the jails and whose property is annexed by the CBI like Telecom scam for which erstwhile minister was arrested ?

This is not fault of CBI then but it goes to supreme court. It was their duty to point it out earlier whether the CBI had the right to act or not.

The Gauhati High Court had ruled that CBI is unconstitutional body. This decision has far reaching impl;ications.

http://www.ndtv.com/article/india/cbi-unconstitutional-can-t-investigate-crimes-says-gauhati-high-court-443204

I read this news.CBI is central government agency. In this way any courts ruled that this and this agency which is establish by central government is unconstituational. Like CAG, CLB and more.

C.B.I. was formed according to Delhi Police act. The act was not signed by President and not even seen by him. again law and order is state subject and so C.B.I cannot be treated as police organization and allowed to arrest people and prosecute them. But so far nobody challenged C.B.I.- not even Supreme court. With Gauhati High Court decision, a new crisis has surfaced.

If act is not signed by honorable President of India, then it is not an act, it will be called as draft bill, it is interesting how government of the day preset its side at honorable Supreme Court of India, as its spokesperson said they would be appealing against this case. :evil: :evil:

Its a different issue. The issue is how CBI could act, investigate arrest annexe the properties if its an unconstitutional body since 1963? What about those who are in prisons on the charges of CBI?

CBI has never been constitutional body, as the power derives can only be known from its formation and the honorable court judgment can be seen like this but still apex court ruling is awaited on this.

What you are saying is about the present situation. What about those who are in the jails and whose property is annexed by the CBI like Telecom scam for which erstwhile minister was arrested ?

This is not fault of CBI then but it goes to supreme court. It was their duty to point it out earlier whether the CBI had the right to act or not.

That's the most pitiable part of it. It was only after challenging the validity of a charge sheet of CBI by an employee who was charge sheeted this fact has come out

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

The central govt. is making an appeal against Gauhati High Court decision. Let us hope that the crisis will be solved.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Centre-to-move-SC-against-Gauhati-high-court-order-on-CBI-today/articleshow/25458731.cms

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

The central govt. is making an appeal against Gauhati High Court decision. Let us hope that the crisis will be solved.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Centre-to-move-SC-against-Gauhati-high-court-order-on-CBI-today/articleshow/25458731.cms

Yes, Central government already appealed for a stay according to morning news.

It may be a technical point which was blown up at this point of time. We need an institution like Central Bureau of Investigation in the country, whatever be the name. If the President is yet to sign on it, let it be done now. Some people want to create chaos and embarrass the present government on the pretext of the Guwahati Court intervention.

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

The central govt. is making an appeal against Gauhati High Court decision. Let us hope that the crisis will be solved.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Centre-to-move-SC-against-Gauhati-high-court-order-on-CBI-today/articleshow/25458731.cms

Government can create these institutions, these are not illegal but it does not have constitutionnsanction attached with it.

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

The central govt. is making an appeal against Gauhati High Court decision. Let us hope that the crisis will be solved.

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Centre-to-move-SC-against-Gauhati-high-court-order-on-CBI-today/articleshow/25458731.cms

Government can create these institutions, these are not illegal but it does not have constitutionnsanction attached with it.

Institutions without constitutional sanctions cannot exercise powers which ultimately leads to unnecessary and unwanted burden on the taxpayer.

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

Yes I have heard many organisations work for the country but they are illegal. They do the top secret high profile jobs.

Gauhati High Court said on Wednesday that the CBI cannot be treated as a police force; it can only conduct "inquiries".

So with such unconstitutional organizations working in this nation and the governments using them as the tools to intimidate and bully its political rivals since 1963 ?
What a Nation we are living in !!!
And the wonder of wonders is our Apex court is validating the CBI and banking on the agency to ensure justice..

A classic case of ‘Andher Nagri Chaupat Raja’

The fact was brought to light by an ordinary citizen and an employee of Mahanagar Telephone Nigam brings shocking facts about the validity of our ‘Constitutional experts’.
Now it has to be seen how many such unconstitutional organizations are functioning in this country.

Yes I have heard many organisations work for the country but they are illegal. They do the top secret high profile jobs.

I am sure you have top intelligence agencies of our country in your mind, is that so?