Could ancient Nepali and Pakistan culture be Indian!

2.1K Views
0 Replies
1 min read
:( :( what is Indian culture. Is this not Nepali and Pakistani. In fact, our country derived its name form 'Indus valley' that is in Pakistan. More in the link:

http://in.news.yahoo.com/it-all-started-in-jambudvipa--or-did-it--071629335.html

17 Replies

You have left out Bangladesh sir, They have as much claim on Indus valley as India and Nepal or Tibet or China. I should have added Afghanistan also in the list.
You have left out Bangladesh sir, They have as much claim on Indus valley as India and Nepal or Tibet or China. I should have added Afghanistan also in the list.


It is not about their claim. It is about our claim. Is the ancient culture of those countries Indian?
You have left out Bangladesh sir, They have as much claim on Indus valley as India and Nepal or Tibet or China. I should have added Afghanistan also in the list.


It is not about their claim. It is about our claim. Is the ancient culture of those countries Indian?


If they were part of greater India (Pakistan, Bangladesh etc) our claim has more weightage.
:( :( what is Indian culture. Is this not Nepali and Pakistani. In fact, our country derived its name form 'Indus valley' that is in Pakistan. More in the link:

http://in.news.yahoo.com/it-all-started-in-jambudvipa--or-did-it--071629335.html


In fact even in Indonesia and Thailand we see a lot of our cultue and heritage right down to names like ram,sita,pratima etc...They have ballets of ramayan although the country is predominantly buddhist which has again gone from here ..
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.


You are points are to the point but you missed that Nepal is no more a Hindu state any more. They have declared Nepal as secular state for some time now.
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.


You are points are to the point but you missed that Nepal is no more a Hindu state any more. They have declared Nepal as secular state for some time now.

Ohh, I indeed missed that. When did they declare that? I didn't have any idea about that.
:( :( what is Indian culture. Is this not Nepali and Pakistani. In fact, our country derived its name form 'Indus valley' that is in Pakistan. More in the link:

http://in.news.yahoo.com/it-all-started-in-jambudvipa--or-did-it--071629335.html


Our country derived its name India from Indus. OK. Prior to that, India was a nameless country ? What about Bharat , which existed much much earlier than India? Strangely, the author of the article did not deal with it.
:( :( what is Indian culture. Is this not Nepali and Pakistani. In fact, our country derived its name form 'Indus valley' that is in Pakistan. More in the link:

http://in.news.yahoo.com/it-all-started-in-jambudvipa--or-did-it--071629335.html


First thing India is English world. old name is Bharat or Hidustan. Second thing before 1947 no country with name of Pakistan was not on the map of World. Before partician Pakistan, India and Bangla Desh was one country. Nepal was never part of India, Bharat or Hindustan, though culture of bother country alike.
You have left out Bangladesh sir, They have as much claim on Indus valley as India and Nepal or Tibet or China. I should have added Afghanistan also in the list.


It is not about their claim. It is about our claim. Is the ancient culture of those countries Indian?


If they were part of greater India (Pakistan, Bangladesh etc) our claim has more weightage.


No Sunil, Afghanistan was never part of India, though Maharaj Ranjeet Singh won Afghanistan and Raja Vikirama Aditya also ruled on Afghanistan.
I think what goes by the name of Indian culture is a product of influences of cultures of numerous lands over a span of a few thousand years and it is not necessary to name any particular one. Given to the syncretic nature of Indian culture it would be more apt to call it a 'Melting Pot' of cultures!!
You have left out Bangladesh sir, They have as much claim on Indus valley as India and Nepal or Tibet or China. I should have added Afghanistan also in the list.


It is not about their claim. It is about our claim. Is the ancient culture of those countries Indian?


If they were part of greater India (Pakistan, Bangladesh etc) our claim has more weightage.


No Sunil, Afghanistan was never part of India, though Maharaj Ranjeet Singh won Afghanistan and Raja Vikirama Aditya also ruled on Afghanistan.


Neither were Tibet or China, that is why I have not added these countries in India directly but they can have claims on Indus valley.
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.


You are points are to the point but you missed that Nepal is no more a Hindu state any more. They have declared Nepal as secular state for some time now.

Ohh, I indeed missed that. When did they declare that? I didn't have any idea about that.
Maurisus is the only declared Hindu state, Nepal becomes secular after communist ruled there.
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.


You are points are to the point but you missed that Nepal is no more a Hindu state any more. They have declared Nepal as secular state for some time now.

Ohh, I indeed missed that. When did they declare that? I didn't have any idea about that.
Maurisus is the only declared Hindu state, Nepal becomes secular after communist ruled there.

Now this is new to me again - Mauritius is a Hindu state? So it means before Nepal went secular, there were two official Hindu states in the world???
There are many countries, though they are not declared as Hindu states, where Hinduism is widely practiced with a considerable number of Hindus. They are Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Mauritius, Fiji, Suriname, Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, the United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States.
Pakistan is the deprived child of India and Nepal is officially the Hindu state. I am sure there are a lot of similarities between all these three nations. That is why they share a lot of similar culture. And yes, Indus belongs to all of us. After all, it is a natural source of water.


Nepal ceased to be a Hindu state after ouster of monarchy there.
There are many countries, though they are not declared as Hindu states, where Hinduism is widely practiced with a considerable number of Hindus. They are Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Mauritius, Fiji, Suriname, Guyana, Trinidad and Tobago, the United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States.


I am surprised to see inclusion of few names and also not finding names of a few other countries where number of Hindus live happier life than countries mentioned above where they have no rights, not even basic civilian rights. Talking about practicing Hinduism will be too much in couple of places mentioned above.

Topic Author

Topic Stats

Created Saturday, 21 September 2013 05:38
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 2.1K
Likes 0

Share This Topic