Direct FDI in retail sector

I think it is decided and may be the rule is 70% of the product, wallmart has to buy from india. So, i think that farmer will get more amount from wallmart when they will buy from farmers.
Also, there are less cold storage in india,as a result lots vegetables and grains are spoiled and farmer have to take the loss. So wallmart will make new storage houses and this will be helpful to farmers.

There are various things under FDI in retail. I hope to get good answers from experts here.

:(Wall Mart is buying from farmers, what you like to say about gap Rs3---------
Rs100.

I think it is decided and may be the rule is 70% of the product, wallmart has to buy from india. So, i think that farmer will get more amount from wallmart when they will buy from farmers.
Also, there are less cold storage in india,as a result lots vegetables and grains are spoiled and farmer have to take the loss. So wallmart will make new storage houses and this will be helpful to farmers.

There are various things under FDI in retail. I hope to get good answers from experts here.

:(Wall Mart is buying from farmers, what you like to say about gap Rs3---------
Rs100.

I think it is decided and may be the rule is 70% of the product, wallmart has to buy from india. So, i think that farmer will get more amount from wallmart when they will buy from farmers.
Also, there are less cold storage in india,as a result lots vegetables and grains are spoiled and farmer have to take the loss. So wallmart will make new storage houses and this will be helpful to farmers.

There are various things under FDI in retail. I hope to get good answers from experts here.

I don't think this gap is correct. Otherwsie, farmer won't sell them. I don't agree.
See, sometime farmers grow so much amount of vegetables, that they don't have space to store them and vegetables are rotten. So, now farmer could sell those vegetables to wallmart.
Anil, i think statistic not correct.

Farmers would know their value while a corporate war would begin to acquire food items directly. They should get a better price now.

Congress won in voting on this issue. But what is realty of FDI in retail sector. It is news in paper that farmers are getting only Rs 3 for one kg of baby corn to whom wall mart is selling at 100Rs per kg. Who will earn in future with FDI in retail sector and who will be looser?

These are just rumors and simply cannot be believed because the figures are exaggerated ten fold and it is still not a reality. So, we have to see what would happen when it is a reality ...by the way our own government is not doing any better job in paying farmers when they buy goods from them at co operative stores, so let us hope that Walmart does a better job of paying the farmers..

There is some news coming about Lobing in FDI which is done by Walmart. I am not able to understand what is the meaning of lobing. Can anyone explain this?

There is some news coming about Lobing in FDI which is done by Walmart. I am not able to understand what is the meaning of lobing. Can anyone explain this?

I think its lobbying. Lobbying means using personal links and using unofficial ways to get what they want. Its a general practice in India and abroad.

There is some news coming about Lobing in FDI which is done by Walmart. I am not able to understand what is the meaning of lobing. Can anyone explain this?

I think its lobbying. Lobbying means using personal links and using unofficial ways to get what they want. Its a general practice in India and abroad.

But i heard that lobbying is not there in india. In America, Walmart is using since 4 years and a raw estimate declared is 125 Crores is used by Walmart in india as a Lobbying.

I think nothing is beneficial to general public. Now in many malls nothing is cheap rather than of market. It i costly than normal market.
So It is not garranted that it will be beneficial.

I think nothing is beneficial to general public. Now in many malls nothing is cheap rather than of market. It i costly than normal market.
So It is not garranted that it will be beneficial.

As usha mam said, we will know it is beneficial or not, when Wallmart will open their stores.

I think nothing is beneficial to general public. Now in many malls nothing is cheap rather than of market. It i costly than normal market.
So It is not garranted that it will be beneficial.

As usha mam said, we will know it is beneficial or not, when Wallmart will open their stores.

It will be more costly as we have seen in Big Bazar or Junction mall.

I think nothing is beneficial to general public. Now in many malls nothing is cheap rather than of market. It i costly than normal market.
So It is not garranted that it will be beneficial.

As usha mam said, we will know it is beneficial or not, when Wallmart will open their stores.

That's right. In India Our laws and acts will change their hues and colours when they come to the stage of implementation.

Now many middle men are eating the cream and due to FDI the big investors will eat it. Where we are, we will be there.

Now many middle men are eating the cream and due to FDI the big investors will eat it. Where we are, we will be there.

didn't got you Ram.

I want to say that now many agents are between farmer and consumer.If Big investors enters then they will take the total profit. What will be our benefit?

Congress won in voting on this issue. But what is realty of FDI in retail sector. It is news in paper that farmers are getting only Rs 3 for one kg of baby corn to whom wall mart is selling at 100Rs per kg. Who will earn in future with FDI in retail sector and who will be looser?

I hope Direct FDI in retail Sector is inevitable at present. But We should think about the areas where it can be applied and where it shouldn't be.

I want to say that now many agents are between farmer and consumer.If Big investors enters then they will take the total profit. What will be our benefit?

No, i think farmers would be able to sell directly to wallmart. No, role of agents now.

Some farmers will be benefited and they will get exact value of crops. They may get some loan from that investors.

I think nothing is beneficial to general public. Now in many malls nothing is cheap rather than of market. It i costly than normal market.
So It is not garranted that it will be beneficial.

As usha mam said, we will know it is beneficial or not, when Wallmart will open their stores.

That's right. In India Our laws and acts will change their hues and colours when they come to the stage of implementation.

Very true ! There is many a slip between the cup and the lip....We may have to wait for a few years after it is implemented to see the difference it makes to our economy...however, let us hope for the best and pray that the politicians and law makers have not completely sold themselves out...

B) This statics is based on a news in news papers. Farmers grow baby corn after agreement with wall mart. Agreement is Rs8 per kg, but after grading and transportation farmers is getting this amount only.

:(Wall Mart is buying from farmers, what you like to say about gap Rs3---------
Rs100.

I think it is decided and may be the rule is 70% of the product, wallmart has to buy from india. So, i think that farmer will get more amount from wallmart when they will buy from farmers.
Also, there are less cold storage in india,as a result lots vegetables and grains are spoiled and farmer have to take the loss. So wallmart will make new storage houses and this will be helpful to farmers.

There are various things under FDI in retail. I hope to get good answers from experts here.

I don't think this gap is correct. Otherwsie, farmer won't sell them. I don't agree.
See, sometime farmers grow so much amount of vegetables, that they don't have space to store them and vegetables are rotten. So, now farmer could sell those vegetables to wallmart.
Anil, i think statistic not correct.