Why is Barfi nominated for Oscars???

People who send this movie for Oscar would know the reason better.

I feel that the story is different. All have done well in the movie. It deserves Oscar.

Many times many film were nominated in Oscar but every time failed ,But I think lagan ,Black could win Oscar.

Many times many film were nominated in Oscar but every time failed ,But I think lagan ,Black could win Oscar.

Black was the best film and had the potential for winning an Oscar award but it could not. I don't think Barfi would do anything there. :blink:

But Barfi is nominated in foreign language section ,let see what happens ,we can hope atleast as the movie is good.

But Barfi is nominated in foreign language section ,let see what happens ,we can hope atleast as the movie is good.

Lets see what happens but to win Oscar from Barfi would be expecting too much. :blink:

Now we are getting many good movies from bollywood lke latest release English vinglish.

Now we are getting many good movies from bollywood lke latest release English vinglish.

I have not seen Barfi or English vinglish but that's OK every week some good films are released. :)

I remember Black in which Rani and AB acted well i have seen this film 10 times. :)

Now we are getting many good movies from bollywood lke latest release English vinglish.

I have not seen Barfi or English vinglish but that's OK every week some good films are released. :)

I remember Black in which Rani and AB acted well i have seen this film 10 times. :)

yes Black, Tare jameen Par ,lagan, Three idiots are so good that i also can see many times.

The speciality of this film barfi is, heroine Illeyana a south Indian telugu actress has played a role.

The speciality of this film barfi is, heroine Illeyana a south Indian telugu actress has played a role.

I did not know it. But those who have seen this film say that its a nice movie. :)

@ Ram even i have seen tare zameen par and 3 idiots many times I am a big fan of Aamir Khan and never miss his movies. :)

Already 2-3 threads started for Barfi.....even one for its Oscar nomination.
Can you go through previous pages
this is one among them
http://www.boddunan.com/forum/movies-entertainment/237206-barfi-entered-in-oscar.html?limitstart=0

Just as you can submit multiple articles on same topic from different angles, post/ threads on on same topic can also be creatyed.

then Ok.
We shall add some humorous posts using our imaginations :cheer:

I have seen those threads but my intention in starting this one is from a very different angle, as you can see I have started this under Humor and Jokes and the purpose is to invite similar jokes or discussion on husband-wife relationship!! Not talking about the movie really!!

Kalyani, when a thread is started under humor to get some humorous responses you get very serious debate and when a serious discussion gets started elsewhere the S factor ( brigade) takes over and you have gossip for pages together, what a topsy turve place this is LOL....

Lol is that why Barfi was selected. :laugh: But I would love to marry a mute boy as cute as Ranbir. :silly:

then marry our dearest forum.....he stays with you always.......though he talks a lot, he is mute. We can't hear his voice... :laugh: :laugh:

Where is the face ?? :laugh: With so many girlfriends the forum has you are certainly giving me a bad option. :P :silly:

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: who told it?. :laugh:

But the fact is certainly different what we see in film. :laugh:

I haven't seen that movie yet. Then how can i give my opinion :silly:
Anyhow, I put forward a proposal to asha.....Itna acha ladka nahi milega ;)

Lol is that why Barfi was selected. :laugh: But I would love to marry a mute boy as cute as Ranbir. :silly:

then marry our dearest forum.....he stays with you always.......though he talks a lot, he is mute. We can't hear his voice... :laugh: :laugh:

Where is the face ?? :laugh: With so many girlfriends the forum has you are certainly giving me a bad option. :P :silly:

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: who told it?. :laugh:

But the fact is certainly different what we see in film. :laugh:

I haven't seen that movie yet. Then how can i give my opinion :silly:
Anyhow, I put forward a proposal to asha.....Itna acha ladka nahi milega ;)

Itna acha ladka nahi milega
Dipika and Katrine tumko nehi chorega.
Hogaya na sayeri. :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo:

Lol is that why Barfi was selected. :laugh: But I would love to marry a mute boy as cute as Ranbir. :silly:

then marry our dearest forum.....he stays with you always.......though he talks a lot, he is mute. We can't hear his voice... :laugh: :laugh:

Where is the face ?? :laugh: With so many girlfriends the forum has you are certainly giving me a bad option. :P :silly:

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: who told it?. :laugh:

But the fact is certainly different what we see in film. :laugh:

I haven't seen that movie yet. Then how can i give my opinion :silly:
Anyhow, I put forward a proposal to asha.....Itna acha ladka nahi milega ;)

Itna acha ladka nahi milega
Dipika and Katrine tumko nehi chorega.
Hogaya na sayeri. :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo:

why deepika and Katrina only, our genelia desuza is also unmarried ;)

Lol is that why Barfi was selected. :laugh: But I would love to marry a mute boy as cute as Ranbir. :silly:

then marry our dearest forum.....he stays with you always.......though he talks a lot, he is mute. We can't hear his voice... :laugh: :laugh:

Where is the face ?? :laugh: With so many girlfriends the forum has you are certainly giving me a bad option. :P :silly:

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: who told it?. :laugh:

But the fact is certainly different what we see in film. :laugh:

I haven't seen that movie yet. Then how can i give my opinion :silly:
Anyhow, I put forward a proposal to asha.....Itna acha ladka nahi milega ;)

Itna acha ladka nahi milega
Dipika and Katrine tumko nehi chorega.
Hogaya na sayeri. :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo: :woohoo:

why deepika and Katrina only, our genelia desuza is also unmarried ;)

I think Genilia is married to Ritesh Deshmukh. :ohmy:

I am saying about our Genelia who loves Boddunan a lot. She is still unmarried. Guess who

I am saying about our Genelia who loves Boddunan a lot. She is still unmarried. Guess who

I think this is Sarala you are talking about? hehehe.... :laugh:

I am saying about our Genelia who loves Boddunan a lot. She is still unmarried. Guess who

I think this is Sarala you are talking about? hehehe.... :laugh:

Yes of course....so not only Asha, sarala also in the row ;)

Going by this link, it looks as if the producer director borrowed rather generously from every source possible and put together the scenes...

http://tanqeed.com/forum/barfi-scenes-inspiredcopied-from-the-notebook-charlie-chaplin-and-other-movies/

and some very sound reasons why it is a bad oscar choice..

http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/three-reasons-why-barfi-is-a-bad-oscar-choice-466245.html

Read on....
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Because its the real story of every couple...... A mad wife, a mute husband and a beautiful ex-girlfriend!! :laugh: :laugh:

Got this from the net...Congress and Barfi have a lot in common :laugh:

"A deaf and mute person whose life revolves around a mentally challenged woman…and a Bengali woman, who always ends up getting him into trouble.....LOL :laugh:

Picturising the so called congress as described by you, i cannot stop laughing....especially when you mentioned the mute part.....

I guess kalyani, you must also have heard of this pun!