Group Discussion Contest August 08 to August 16th!

Bumping the thread as this was posted during downtime.

Bumping the thread as this was posted during downtime.

Thanks for bringing it back!! :) :)

What should be given more importance in order to make India grow economically, Service Industry or Manufacturing Industry??? Here service industry refers to jobs such as IT, IT-enabled BPO, KPO etc. jobs, Hotel industry etc.
If we were to have a kind of economy that would be able to sustain itself and provide jobs to large number of population, what should be it, Service or Manufacturing??

Just a few random thoughts, will keep adding ...

Personally I would go for a planned growth which includes industries and also rural sectors like agriculture and farming.Once you make rural living attractive people would want to live in villages and there would be a positive growth all round.I see that many of our villages have scant facilities and with more than 75% of the population lives in villages, we have to take the issue very seriously .So we can never think of growth without taking them into account....India can grow only when our villages see positive economic growth .

Our growth
Service industry is fine but we need manufacturing sector is more important for a country like ours where manpower is available a plenty and no shortage of skilled and unskilled labor. We are doing comparatively okay in service industry although the hub of services industry is also shifting towards far-east countries however; we should concentrate more in manufacturing sector since we are going southward as far this particular sector is concerned.
By the way, we have lost 1.8% compared to gross manufacturing with in last one month due to various reasons. Infrastructure is the main problem in our progress especially electricity and roads. I shall write more on this particular thread as this is my most favorite topic. Thanks ..

Our growth
Service industry is fine but we need manufacturing sector is more important for a country like ours where manpower is available a plenty and no shortage of skilled and unskilled labor. We are doing comparatively okay in service industry although the hub of services industry is also shifting towards far-east countries however; we should concentrate more in manufacturing sector since we are going southward as far this particular sector is concerned.
By the way, we have lost 1.8% compared to gross manufacturing with in last one month due to various reasons. Infrastructure is the main problem in our progress especially electricity and roads. I shall write more on this particular thread as this is my most favorite topic. Thanks ..

I am glad this is your favorite topic, will expect a really good discussion here! The topic actually crossed my mind when I was in a shop buying toys as a gift and all I could get was all Made in China. Nothing that I ever need looks wise and utility wise I get is manufactured in India, hence the topic!

What should be given more importance in order to make India grow economically, Service Industry or Manufacturing Industry??? Here service industry refers to jobs such as IT, IT-enabled BPO, KPO etc. jobs, Hotel industry etc.
If we were to have a kind of economy that would be able to sustain itself and provide jobs to large number of population, what should be it, Service or Manufacturing??

Just a few random thoughts, will keep adding ...

Personally I would go for a planned growth which includes industries and also rural sectors like agriculture and farming.Once you make rural living attractive people would want to live in villages and there would be a positive growth all round.I see that many of our villages have scant facilities and with more than 75% of the population lives in villages, we have to take the issue very seriously .So we can never think of growth without taking them into account....India can grow only when our villages see positive economic growth .

Yes, agricultural sector is very important especially in India where the major occupations all across country is related to agriculture and related professions. But the reason I picked manufacturing was because in spite of there being a huge demand for many things that can be produced here, many small industries and units are closing down whereas service industry is growing and making a select section of the population richer by day. But I will definitely consider agriculture as a topic for next GD.

Service industry is the best which helps our country to grow economically. In our country there are so many students are there who are going to IT and so many are going to medicine. So In future our country will grow economically through service industry mainly.

Manufacturing industry will also help to grow India economically but students or youth are not interested in manufacturing industry. They are interested mainly in IT, Engineering, Doctors, Chartered Accountants etc but very in manufacturing industries.

Service Industry will provide more jobs to the large no. of population because so much Percent of youth they are going to IT only. So they will jobs there only not in manufacturing industries

I hope India will grow in future economically, scientifically .... :lol: :lol: :lol:

Thank You,
Saritha

Service sector and manufacturing sector are no substitutes for each other. These are complementary. We need products for our use. These can be manufactured in manufacturing sector. Service sector is subsidiary to manufacturing. The various services like banking, communication, advertisement are needed to facilitate manufacturers and traders. Moreover service units also need products of manufacturing industry. Communication is service but this needs equipment and infrastructure from manufacturers. Similarly, agriculture provides raw material to industry. There is no service that does not need industrial products. Hence there is no choice. we need an optimum mix of agriculture, manufacturing and service sector.

With the low Economic phase India is facing currently I believe that the need of the hour is a planned and sustainable growth in both the manufacturing as well as service industry. While the manufacturing industry is the main source of income for a major part of the country's population the service industry also plays a vital role in the growth of the economy. So as far as importance is concerned both the sectors contribute to the development and thus are vital for economic growth.

As I said earlier that we are doing comparatively okay as far service industry is concerned but manufacturing is our main concern due to industrial growth going down rapidly. We have already gone almost by 2% in last couple of months and if the trend continues, future of country’s industries is in for a big setback.
The export of country is already in red and if this is any indication of thing to come chances are industry would have no option but to go for reducing workforce. That would be too painful for a country where people are already suffering from lesser chances of availability of jobs apart from software sector.
Therefore, we shall have to go all out to make arrangements in power sector and improve manufacturing sector, which is the backbone of any country. We cannot afford to depend on imported items, as those are not only inferior but make us poorer and dependent on others.... Tanks again...

The manufacturing industry forms the backbone of the country that is it also supports the service industry. To fuel the growth of the economy it is necessary to strengthen both the sectors.
The service sector has been one of the fastest growing in the world and is presently booming. The manufacturing industry in India is labor intensive and thus provides major employment to the less educated. Though its contribution to the GDP has been comparatively lesser as compared to the service sector. So a planned growth for the manufacturing sector is necessary while sustaining the development of the service sector.

Hello friends, back with a new topic:

The topic for this week's discussion is:

What should be given more importance in order to make India grow economically, Service Industry or Manufacturing Industry??? Here service industry refers to jobs such as IT, IT-enabled BPO, KPO etc. jobs, Hotel industry etc.
If we were to have a kind of economy that would be able to sustain itself and provide jobs to large number of population, what should be it, Service or Manufacturing??


All the best! :)

Let me first Thank Kalyani to search such a lovely topic for discussion. Among all the topics discussed till now, I liked this one most :)

I think both are necessary.
Will a day be complete without day time and night time? Also, both are human needs. Let us give equal stress to both. :)

When literate people search white collar jobs in BPO and Banking industry, illiterate people may look job in industries. A society is a combination of both.
Manufacturing industry requires some paper work too, which is done by computerised sector. Also, Service industry give help to manufacturing industry too...best example is giving financial support. Actually, it's a give and take policy and both the sectors can't stay alone without the support of other. isn't it?

Let me reiterate that service sector is mainly for support to the manufacturing and trading units. Service sector has no existence of its own without manufacturing units. Transport, BPO, communication etc only support the manufacturing units and also use inputs from manufacturing units. Being an overhead to national economy, service sector should be small. Services should be more exported than used for internal purpose.

Let me reiterate that service sector is mainly for support to the manufacturing and trading units. Service sector has no existence of its own without manufacturing units. Transport, BPO, communication etc only support the manufacturing units and also use inputs from manufacturing units. Being an overhead to national economy, service sector should be small. Services should be more exported than used for internal purpose.

Yes I agree.
If a nation has to grow, it must be able to provide food to all.......and all the other primary needs. So, first preference is for manufacturing industry. Yet, if we have to connect with the whole world, we need some services too...
So it can be told that manufacturing industry forms the bone and structure while services are 'flesh' added to complete it

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCS. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCF. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

I agree in toto. Manufacturing industry is main. Service sector is in fact a support to industry only. There is no doubt that manufacturing has always been there. The only difference is of scale, technology and business promotion methods. In the beginning of human civilization, shoes were manufactured in cottage industry without heavy machines and sold in village only mostly on barter system. There was no need for advertisement and transport. BPO, computer have only facilitated the manufacture and improved.

We need to strengthen manufacturing and use less service sector. It is better to rather export the srvices.

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCF. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

But for the past 10-15 years, technology has changed a lot. Now even an LKG student is learning Ms-paint at school.
Earlier, population was also only half (if we take the statistics of 20 years).
Earlier it was possible. But now human needs and calculations have increased enormously and manual claculations alone cannot meet all challenges. ......as it's told...when we are in Rome, do as Romans do. So we also need to accept latest technologies including services to cope up with new situations and other nations.

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCF. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

But for the past 10-15 years, technology has changed a lot. Now even an LKG student is learning Ms-paint at school.
Earlier, population was also only half (if we take the statistics of 20 years).
Earlier it was possible. But now human needs and calculations have increased enormously and manual claculations alone cannot meet all challenges. ......as it's told...when we are in Rome, do as Romans do. So we also need to accept latest technologies including services to cope up with new situations and other nations.

Now technology has improved manufacturing methods, designs and accountancy. Computer is also indispensable in today's world. But the fact remains that service sector including computer and information technology is support to manufacture. Without manufacturing industry, service sector is meaningless. Incidentally, the computers and other gadgets are also products of manufacturing units.

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCF. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

But for the past 10-15 years, technology has changed a lot. Now even an LKG student is learning Ms-paint at school.
Earlier, population was also only half (if we take the statistics of 20 years).
Earlier it was possible. But now human needs and calculations have increased enormously and manual claculations alone cannot meet all challenges. ......as it's told...when we are in Rome, do as Romans do. So we also need to accept latest technologies including services to cope up with new situations and other nations.

Now technology has improved manufacturing methods, designs and accountancy. Computer is also indispensable in today's world. But the fact remains that service sector including computer and information technology is support to manufacture. Without manufacturing industry, service sector is meaningless. Incidentally, the computers and other gadgets are also products of manufacturing units.

yes, I also agree Computers should support manufacturing industry more than services........Then only we will be able to meet our primary needs without much manual work than before.
I think BPOs should be given last preference comparing to banking and other IT related services. isn't it?

@sandhya- You mean we were not doing any productive output a couple of decades back when there was no computer. I have done my Mechanical engineering without even touching a keyboard of a computer. We have big plants started by Tatas and Birlas when there were no computers anywhere in sight. What I feel that computer is only good up to certain extent for a country like ours where there are more hands and lesser jobs.
Why make them even lesser by inducting computers in place of men who need those jobs so eagerly? However, the production of consumables and utility products is must for any county; service industry at best can be described as allied industry. I wish people knew the importance of white color jobs in production sector. Production units are not about illiterate, unskilled labors only but highly skilled workforce including, people from accounts, technical research, and whatever science can offer.
Do you know Tata is better known in the world for Tata motors, Titan, Tata steels etc than TCF. Even Azeem Premji knows the value of production therefore runs different consumer products manufacturing units apart from Wipro.
Can you imagine your life without Voltas a Tata's company, Bajaj, Maruti, Godrej, Cera, JP group, DCM, Bhilai steel and so on? BPO is all right but not considered a white colored job with any angle.

But for the past 10-15 years, technology has changed a lot. Now even an LKG student is learning Ms-paint at school.
Earlier, population was also only half (if we take the statistics of 20 years).
Earlier it was possible. But now human needs and calculations have increased enormously and manual claculations alone cannot meet all challenges. ......as it's told...when we are in Rome, do as Romans do. So we also need to accept latest technologies including services to cope up with new situations and other nations.

Only a total ignorant would deny the importance of computers today but my point is that we need more solid products to sell in the market because mere computer training or BPO is not going to feed 1.4 billion people of this country. By the way, even computers are part of the manufacturing sector and manufactured by skilled workforce. Even the software/ICs that runs a computer is product of hardware engineering, another manufacturing example.