Restriction on newspapers in West Bengal state libraries

1.7K Views
0 Replies
1 min read
West Bengal Government has excluded many newspaper especially English from state libraries. This obviously restricts readers' choice. This is being widely criticized.

http://www.thehindu.com/news/states/other-states/article3255425.ece

18 Replies

What to say? B)

Here, newspaper strikes has not ended till now. But we can get 'Deshabhimani' paper.....I don't know why, those papers are distributed. Actually, it's a 'Communist party' newspaper :blink:
What to say? B)

Here, newspaper strikes has not ended till now. But we can get 'Deshabhimani' paper.....I don't know why, those papers are distributed. Actually, it's a 'Communist party' newspaper :blink:


Apparently, Deshabhimani is not on strike. Be happy that at least one paper keeps you informed.
It's bad enough a decision and no government can and issue such a diktat! It's highly deplorable!
This is very horrific, how can they issue such a ban, people have got the right to choose what they want to read after all! Why this sudden restriction on the newspapers??? Instead of progressing we only seem to be regressing!! :angry:
What to say? B)

Here, newspaper strikes has not ended till now. But we can get 'Deshabhimani' paper.....I don't know why, those papers are distributed. Actually, it's a 'Communist party' newspaper :blink:


Apparently, Deshabhimani is not on strike. Be happy that at least one paper keeps you informed.


But it's only a party newspaper......with full of comments against Congress and other parties, hiding many truths behind it and making false interpretations :cheer:
The character of a government does not change and the same people criticized the earlier government for anti-democratic measures!
Why news papers are doing strike in kerala. Are they getting less salaries.
What to say? B)

Here, newspaper strikes has not ended till now. But we can get 'Deshabhimani' paper.....I don't know why, those papers are distributed. Actually, it's a 'Communist party' newspaper :blink:


Apparently, Deshabhimani is not on strike. Be happy that at least one paper keeps you informed.


But it's only a party newspaper......with full of comments against Congress and other parties, hiding many truths behind it and making false interpretations :cheer:


The newspaper does not hide the fact that this is party newspaper. So, readers are not cheated. They know that they are getting party viewpoint. Some times, we need to read papers with contrary views to probe. In my college days, I would read Blitz, a left oriented weekly, Organizer- RSS oriented and New age- Communist paper.
Mamata Banerjee has explained that the fund limitation necessitates limitation of papers in state libraries. Those criticizing her are mischievous.



http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/mamata-banerjee-bengal-newspapers-libraries/1/179968.html
The party members wanted to hide certain information but may be now it had leaked in that paper,may be that's why they are restricting.
Mamata Banerjee has explained that the fund limitation necessitates limitation of papers in state libraries. Those criticizing her are mischievous.



I think it's sheer folly on her part to make any such attempt to control press! She need not be touchy on criticism!
[quote]
I think it's sheer folly on her part to make any such attempt to control press! She need not be touchy on criticism! [/quote]

I agree! But most politicians seem to lack this very quality that is so essential, almost all are so touchy about criticism!
Why they are doing like this. People needs newspapers to know informations happening on their state. Fortunately in my state all newspapers are available. :cheer:
Mamata Banerjee has explained that the fund limitation necessitates limitation of papers in state libraries. Those criticizing her are mischievous.



I think it's sheer folly on her part to make any such attempt to control press! She need not be touchy on criticism!


Budget constraints may not allow buying every newspaper. So, some newspapers may have to be discarded in government library. One way may be to allow the local library to buy any newspapers within the budget limit. any newspaper need not be blacklisted for government aided library as long as this is lawfully circulated.
Looking at the decision itself - I find no merit in it. As to the old practice of going to library, this is dying.One more point is that her government has added a few papers which are little known. As a matter of policy no paper should even think of surviving on government patronage.That impinges on its independence!
All,i would say that its bad to ban and don't know why such act is done .
Some politicians in India are displaying this negative trait of intolerance!
All,i would say that its bad to ban and don't know why such act is done .


There is no ban as such. But all newspaper can be purchased by state run libraries. I think the selection of newspaper should be for three months. In the next period newspaper should be changed. Thus, in the whole year, most newspapers should be covered. Selection should be left to local level.

Topic Author

Topic Stats

Created Thursday, 29 March 2012 03:07
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 1.7K
Likes 0

Share This Topic