Bhagwat Geeta ban!

1.8K Views
0 Replies
1 min read
Is Bhagwat Geeta an instigator of violence, disputes and social unrest in society. Hindus may read some deeper meaning in the holy book.

But others may consider this just as a story of fight over land between cousins, namely Pandava and kaurava. Oterwise peaceful citizens may be instigated by this book to settle their differences on land and other private maters through violence. This is what a section in Siberia (Russian territory) feels. So, a ban on this book is being considered.

any comments?


http://in.news.yahoo.com/-bhagvad-gita--faces--extremist--branding--legal-ban-in-russia.html

20 Replies

What are plain facts abou Ghagwat Geetha.

This is part of Mahabharata, which is in simple terms a great war between Kaurava and Pandava- cousins- for the sake of land/ kingdom. Krishna instigates Arjun, a Panda brother to fight and not withdraw. This advice by Krishna is Geetha. Hence, some people feel that Geetha encourages fighting. This apprehension is not so unreasonable.

Here I wish to stress that even Hindus never keep a copy of Mahabharata that includes Geetha because the very possession of this book may cause quarrel and tension. If others also feel so, what is wrong.
What are plain facts abou Ghagwat Geetha.

This is part of Mahabharata, which is in simple terms a great war between Kaurava and Pandava- cousins- for the sake of land/ kingdom. Krishna instigates Arjun, a Panda brother to fight and not withdraw. This advice by Krishna is Geetha. Hence, some people feel that Geetha encourages fighting. This apprehension is not so unreasonable.

Here I wish to stress that even Hindus never keep a copy of Mahabharata that includes Geetha because the very possession of this book may cause quarrel and tension. If others also feel so, what is wrong.



Is it so?
In most our houses there is a copy of Mahabharatam, written by Ezhuthachan.
It is my personal comment that everybody should read Gita. It will help in many ways in life.
By reading Geeta we will know lot of valuable things in life.
What are plain facts abou Ghagwat Geetha.

This is part of Mahabharata, which is in simple terms a great war between Kaurava and Pandava- cousins- for the sake of land/ kingdom. Krishna instigates Arjun, a Panda brother to fight and not withdraw. This advice by Krishna is Geetha. Hence, some people feel that Geetha encourages fighting. This apprehension is not so unreasonable.

Here I wish to stress that even Hindus never keep a copy of Mahabharata that includes Geetha because the very possession of this book may cause quarrel and tension. If others also feel so, what is wrong.


In Uttar Pradesh, nobody will have Mahabharata in his house. When there is quarrel in some family, we say that there is Mahabharata in that house. Mahabharata recitation is arranged in public places and not in residences. It is believed that if you have a copy of Mahabharata in your house, there will be no peace.


Is it so?
In most our houses there is a copy of Mahabharatam, written by Ezhuthachan.
It is true or fake gulshan ji It is really happening in maharastra.
It is true or fake gulshan ji It is really happening in maharastra.


There is no doubt that "mahabharata' is a book of war between Kaurava and Pandava for land. In U.P., nobody will keep a copy of this book at his residence. About Maharashtra, I do not know.
Thank you Gulshan Ji . I am having mahabarata book in my house also but I did not face any problem.
Thank you Gulshan Ji . I am having mahabarata book in my house also but I did not face any problem.
[quote]In Uttar Pradesh, nobody will have Mahabharata in his house. When there is quarrel in some family, we say that there is Mahabharata in that house. Mahabharata recitation is arranged in public places and not in residences. It is believed that if you have a copy[quote][/quote] of Mahabharata in your house, there will be no peace. [/quote]
I think this is a superstitious.
Ram have you read Gulshan Ji view on this he said it is true.
[quote]In Uttar Pradesh, nobody will have Mahabharata in his house. When there is quarrel in some family, we say that there is Mahabharata in that house. Mahabharata recitation is arranged in public places and not in residences. It is believed that if you have a copy[quote]
of Mahabharata in your house, there will be no peace. [/quote]
I think this is a superstitious.[/quote]

No doubt this is superstitious belief. Any way this is a belief.
But I do have a copy of bhagavat gita at home :)
Ram what you Means here by Superstitious is that our faith is only for show can you explain this.
Many have Geeta at their home but no problem.If this is not a superstitious then everybody will ban this holly book.
Here are some advice of Geeta. If you are all interested I will post some more.
{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 4821]}
Such superstitious beliefs arise from lack of understanding and knowing what it really says. The Mahabharata is believed to be epic tale of war between two factions of the same family ir, Kauravas and Pandavas. But it is much much more than that. It tells us what life is all about, how to live life, duties of one's towards others etc. etc. and many more. It is very difficult to grasp it even in several readings and it is considered to have answers to all problems that one may ever face.

I have heard of this superstition and reason that is given behind it is because it has vivid descriptions of war between brothers, keeping a copy will lead to a rift within the family. Utter nonsense! instead each family should hold recitals regularly and understand its teachings.
Whatever happened ,forget it.Let see what is
{CJATTACHMENT ["id": 4823]}
Bhagwat Geeta saying:
Ram
What I thought today to post in this forum, you have done it. Actually I was searching for those words. Thanks a lot.
"Sab bhagvan ki Ichha" :cheer:
Oh Sandhya then I am sorry.Please post some another speeches.

Topic Author

Topic Stats

Created Tuesday, 20 December 2011 10:17
Last Updated Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies 0
Views 1.8K
Likes 0

Share This Topic