Naxals ambush CRPF team, 75 killed!!!!

In my opinion all the rebellions are the creation of Government itself.Their injustice deeds have created them.

Yes.. thats right Abid. The Government officials should always mind their words and deeds.. and there should always be in mind that all people are watching them!! There speeches or deeds.

We cannot blame them as it is their innate instinct to revenge like any man.So first we have to correct ourselves.

Now Digvijay singh congress Leader has blatantly criticized Home Minister on Naxalite issue for treating this as a mere law and order problem. It is obvious that the Central Government is neither unanimous nor clear on any issue.

The ruling party is not in one mind on fighting Naxals. Now, Mamata banerjee Union Minister says that there are no naxals in Weast Bengal. She does not support Union Home Minister. It is funny that there is no unanimity even among central government ministers on tackling the crucial naxal issue.

More attacks will have to be expected from them soon.So our officers have to be vigilant.

Seems that Chidambaram ji is not guilty of what have happened!!!!!!

It can not be the sole responsibility of any individual.The entire problem has to be addressed and tackled in a well-orchestrated administrative action.

yes of course... but the blame should be taken by some one.... being a home minister, he should.....

Deepti- Blame should be taken by Union Cabinet as a whole. The Home Minister does not appear to be at fault as far as his role is concerned. The fight against naxalites needs coordinated organized action by intelligence agencies, security forces, defence forces etc. under jurisdiction of Central and state governments. Development work and redress of problems of people in affected area also need be tackled. If possible, negotiations with naxalites also should be held without weakening resolve to fight against them.

Some 156 districts which are most backward have fallen prey to this Naxalite menace and the first and foremost job should be to eastablish the rule of law and break the back of the parallel administration that the Maoists are running in these regions.

Chinmoy- Do you think that imposition of President Rule or marshal law in the affected regions will work. Law and order is state subject. state governments have failed as they are not equal to naxalites. The Green Hunt was intended to break the back of the parallel administration. Instead the parallel administration broke the back of the statutory administration.

Only coordinated and team work in planned way with determination involving centre and states can deliver the goods.

@Gulshan,
But when it comes to marshal law, the powerful military is entering the scene.The game is different.Green Hunt is done by CRPF which has already proved to be ineffective.In coordinated action also, you need to have power.I don't think they can win over naxals who are getting more and more powerful.Now it is said that Maoists has got snipers also.Such emerging forces can be flushed out only by powerful military.And our constitution allows the use of military for such purpose by the marshal law.

MC- Even if you do not want marshal law, it is possible to get military involvement as there is provision for 'aid to civil power'. By requisitioning army for aid to civil power, the ultimate control vests in the state government. But I feel that so many state governments are involved and they are not equal to naxalites in resolve and action. So, these states should be placed under Presidents rule and retired military generals be appointed as Governors of these state. Such arrangement is likely to work.

@Gulshan,
You are right.Center must take control.
Do you think peace talks can do any good?

@Gulshan
As you have rightly indicated that there is a grey area involving the respective jurisdictions of the governments.Although it a is state subject but the poor records of the states show their ineptness as well as inefficiency in dealing with this menace.The state administrations have a dangerous habit of dilly-dallying on this issue and letting the festering wounds turn into cancer and then the Centre is called upon to deliver the goods.It's an untenable situation.The Maoists have thrown an open challenge to the soverignty and integrity of the nation.Any offer of talks is meaningless at this point of time and until and unless they give up this agenda the state powers have to be exercised in full to subjugate and defeat them.As far as the involvement of the army is concerned we have already seen deploymeent of it in several insurgency affected areas and I can not differentiate the challenge posed by the Maoist from the one faced from the sparatists. Instead of splitting hair on where the buck stops, let the Central government get down to brass tacks.

Chinmoy- In view of discussion by you and MC, I view that state governments cannot face teh Naxalite challenge. so, there is no alternative to putting the concerned states under President rule. The centre should put the concerned states under President Rule and appoint retired military generals as governors. The governors so appointed may at their discretion manage to appoint army officers as commissioner or District magistrates on deputation to state government. Such arrangement may help solve the Naxalite problem. In this arrangement. state chief ministers will continue and continue with development work.

Maha shweta Devi, noted writer has dared the government to arrest her for her support to Maoists.

Strangely, she does not care for rights of those whom Maoists kill. The Maoists kill not only their 'class enemies' but also cadres of other political parties apart from police in cold blood. Why does maha shweata Devi not understand that rule of law applies to all and the victims of maoist terror also need government support.

Recent arrest of CRPF persons for arm supply to Maoists is to be read along with this.