Bhagavad Geeta says " Karam karo fhal ki ichacha mat karo" Is this possible in practical life? Can we do "work without expectation"?
20 Replies
No one ever does anything without expectations. Let us be clear on that. Rich philanthropists get tax exemptions, which are available to ordinary tax payers also. Frequently when funds are collected for flood/ earthquake victims ets a entertainment show are organised for the donors. If such returns are not there then many philanthropists do it for their spiritual salvation towards the end of their lives. It is very rare that some one is giving without any expectation.
Neha Sadana wrote:There is always an expectation against an action either its cash or satisfaction, that depends on a person. If you feel satisfied with a particular deed or charity, you will go for it again. Sometimes you expect that satisfaction and sometime it comes of its own.
Satisfaction and peace of mind are also expectations, but they happen naturally even if you expect it or not. They reflect in your inner world. You cannot demand it from anybody if it does not happen of its own. In the other case, you expect compensation against your work because you deserve it, and ask for it if you do not get.
Google search will throw lot of light in this matter. Do some homework.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Individuals_and_groups_assisting_Jews_during_the_Holocaust
It is hard but possible if we put our hearts and mind to it. It is a matter of discipline your mind. The Bible would say thus - Never tire of doing good. If we expect anything in return we would become weary and slacken in our deeds.
Sounds difficult but to attain eternal life is not an easy task.
Most of us would definitely go a certain distance within our capacity to help others without any expectations like give some money to poorer people or wouldn't mind paying a little extra to a laborer or pay whatever the smaller, street side shop keepers demand, I never argue or bargain with them because their profit margin is so little...However There may be some who have enough means to take care of their needs in life and wouldn't mind spending time and money on activities that makes them happy without expecting anything back . However for an ordinary person, it is not easy to think of doing anything without expectation in day today life , more so since people hardly reciprocate these days ..There have been umpteen number of times when I open the door in a shopping mall or a shop and a dozen people would pass through without even looking at you forget thanking you , probably knocking you and pushing you in the bargain...Now I don't bother and when someone comes through I tell them to wait until pass..
There seems to be a lot of discussion about who the real philanthropists are and who are fake ones, but I can certainly name a few who are the real people working for the good of others without expecting any returns. They are Acharya Vinoba Bhave, Dr. Baba Amte and his entire family who literally lived in naxal-infested jungles to work for the cause of the Madiya Gonds and outlawed lepers, his family still lives in those places consisting of Dr. Prakash Amte, Dr. Vikas Amte, both their wives, sons, daughters, their grandsons, granddaughters, The fourth generation of Baba Amte is now continuing the work he started. There are other similar couples such as Dr. Abhay Bang and Dr Rani Bang who work for community health in Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra, again a naxally-infested area, Dr Ravindra Kolhe and his wife Dr. Smita Kolhe who work for the tribals in Melghat, which has the notoriety of being Maharashtra's most malnourished area. Apart from the ones I have named, there are several more such people in the state and across the country.
We do not have to be them, everyone cannot make the sacrifices these people made, but the least we can do is put in our bit and help others in what little way we can.
Kalyani Nandurkar wrote:There seems to be a lot of discussion about who the real philanthropists are and who are fake ones, but I can certainly name a few who are the real people working for the good of others without expecting any returns. They are Acharya Vinoba Bhave, Dr. Baba Amte and his entire family who literally lived in naxal-infested jungles to work for the cause of the Madiya Gonds and outlawed lepers, his family still lives in those places consisting of Dr. Prakash Amte, Dr. Vikas Amte, both their wives, sons, daughters, their grandsons, granddaughters, The fourth generation of Baba Amte is now continuing the work he started. There are other similar couples such as Dr. Abhay Bang and Dr Rani Bang who work for community health in Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra, again a naxally-infested area, Dr Ravindra Kolhe and his wife Dr. Smita Kolhe who work for the tribals in Melghat, which has the notoriety of being Maharashtra's most malnourished area. Apart from the ones I have named, there are several more such people in the state and across the country.
We do not have to be them, everyone cannot make the sacrifices these people made, but the least we can do is put in our bit and help others in what little way we can.
Absolutely. Those who think that there are no people who put Service before Self without expecting returns are living in their own paradise and who cannot see more than darkness.
I agree with you absolutely that one can direct all his endeavors to be a part of such noble people in our own humble way . Do you remember that small squirrel's efforts in helping the Rama sethu in Ramayana in its own way ?
There is a lady who has planted and nurtures tree through the 4 km stretch of highway in Karnataka,,, such people are rare and one can only admire them for of the dedication they have shown to their cause.But for the vast majority , such unselfish deeds may not be always possible..
http://www.theweekendleader.com/Heroism/641/banyan-mother.html

Highly commendable effort on part of the lady who has planted trees on a 4 km stretch in Karnataka. Such stories should get wide publicity to motivate others. She also had expectations in doing so but they were of a noble nature. Hats off to her and thanks to @Usha for bringing it into the Forum.
Topic Author
nehasadana
@NehaSadana