Many people without thinking condemn the English rule over India, but one shudders to think what would have happened if the English had NOT COME to India. Hindus would continue to be ruled by Muslims and pay taxes like Jizziya etc and be second class citizens. Where would India be then in 21st century, a Muslim state ? One shudders at the possibilities in case the English had not come
17 Replies
MG Singh wrote:An important point that cannot be denied is that during Muslim rule there was no uniform legal system for all, no seats of learning, practically just the destructions of temples. It is the English who gave all that we have today.
Here I may mention that Hindu law manusmriti is worst. Even Muslim law Sharia would be better. sharia applied equally to all but Manusmriti prescribed different punishments according to caste of offender and victim. a dalit man raping an upper caste woman would get very harsh punishment whereas rape of lower caste woman by an upper caste man would be treated leniently. The British introduced very fair legal practices. all are equal before law- milkmaid to queen. Our constitution is based on this principle of equality before law. .
I am glad that you have hit the nail on the head. The inequalities in Hindu law are glaring and one reason is the sanctity of the Varna system. This must be eradicated, but I wonder if it will ever go away with the government itself championing it with reserved seats in civil services , colleges and jobs based on caste.
Topic Author
MG Singh
@emge