Hello everyone, a new topic for this week's GD contest!
The topic has been suggested by Rajani and considering the current flood situation in Northern India and drought situation in other parts, I think a it is a good subject for discussion.
How well is India prepared for facing natural disasters?
As usual the winner will be awarded a cash prize of Rs. 50 and the Runner-up Rs. 25 along with 50 points each.
All participants who post at least three valid replies will be awarded 50 points in the Group Discussion. The Replies should be in a constructive manner either opposing or supporting the topic.
See link for more information and rules of the contest:
http://www.boddunan.com/forums/3-contests-a-rewards/3854-introducing-the-new-contest-group-discussio
All the best everyone and happy discussion! :)
18 Replies
Well, this topic is entirely different from what we have seen in previous week's. Thanks for the suggestion rajani!
The topic is "How well is India prepared for facing natural disasters?"
Its all natural phenomena; It happens; Our survival depends on how we outsmart these sort of things.
Natural disasters are beyond the control of mankind. The point comes to my mind regarding india's preparation in this issue is We got loan from WB in july to check our natural disaster and what we donate $5million to pakistan, we are great you see starve our own and feed the neighbours seems to the policy.
we should expect the unexpected and think about the people affected not just the politicians alone.what helps are,
proper city planning,
proper drainage facilities
disaster management team
warning about forecasts.
swift action.
The topic is "How well is India prepared for facing natural disasters?"
Its all natural phenomena; It happens; Our survival depends on how we outsmart these sort of things.
Natural disasters are beyond the control of mankind. The point comes to my mind regarding india's preparation in this issue is We got loan from WB in july to check our natural disaster and what we donate $5million to pakistan, we are great you see starve our own and feed the neighbours seems to the policy.
we should expect the unexpected and think about the people affected not just the politicians alone.what helps are,
proper city planning,
proper drainage facilities
disaster management team
warning about forecasts.
swift action.
Not only Northern states, Western and Southern regions of India have also been receiving enough of rainfall this monsoon. Gujarat, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Kerala are the few states that have been lucky to get the pretty much sufficient annual rainfall. On the other hand, various districts of West Bengal are in a situation that the next thing we could imagine there is ‘famine’. : :dry:
Is not it quite disappointing on part of the Eastern states to be cursed with less than necessary rainfall, while the Northern and Western states are witnessing one of the best monsoon in the last five years?
The deficiency in rainfall is of course going to have a greater impact on the economy of these states. Or, better to say they have already been facing drought-like situation, which definitely spells into famine. Take the example of West Bengal. The state comprises of eighteen districts and out of that eleven have already been hit by drought. Being a major rice producing state of India, West Bengal requires a lot of rainfall, but the cursed monsoon (for the state) is quite an irony! :laugh:
It is quite unlikely that the Northeaster region of India has received more than normal rainfall before the monsoon hit. It was almost a flood-stuck situation, but at the time when the states need rainfall the most, it is lacking it badly! It is also unlikely that there is such a great disparity of rainfall in the same country. :dry:
Is not it quite disappointing on part of the Eastern states to be cursed with less than necessary rainfall, while the Northern and Western states are witnessing one of the best monsoon in the last five years?
The deficiency in rainfall is of course going to have a greater impact on the economy of these states. Or, better to say they have already been facing drought-like situation, which definitely spells into famine. Take the example of West Bengal. The state comprises of eighteen districts and out of that eleven have already been hit by drought. Being a major rice producing state of India, West Bengal requires a lot of rainfall, but the cursed monsoon (for the state) is quite an irony! :laugh:
It is quite unlikely that the Northeaster region of India has received more than normal rainfall before the monsoon hit. It was almost a flood-stuck situation, but at the time when the states need rainfall the most, it is lacking it badly! It is also unlikely that there is such a great disparity of rainfall in the same country. :dry:
Most of the people in our country follow Wait and See approach . So it's not only the politicians but even the common man itself. Disaster management has only a contingency plan that is implemented when the flood is ready to arrive or has already arrived. :(
Having a disaster management policy and it being implemented that involves educating children and training them as part of curriculum itself can be helpful in long run. Having training programs in offices and colleges and conducting mock drills on dealing with disasters can also be implemented
Having a disaster management policy and it being implemented that involves educating children and training them as part of curriculum itself can be helpful in long run. Having training programs in offices and colleges and conducting mock drills on dealing with disasters can also be implemented
India is in a crucial situation that it has scored the position of 11th among the topmost countries that is facing natural disaster.We do'nt need the sympathy of other countries,what we need urgently is thier help.The farmers are really facing a hard life in this disaster environment.The increased rate of floods ,earthquakes,epidemics, and storms had made a great decrease in the overall poopulation
[quote].We do'nt need the sympathy of other countries,what we need urgently is thier help.[/quote]
Your views are good Gopika, but I figure we really do not need outside help. There are unimaginable hordes hard cash in India itself and when we can donate over 5 million dollars to Pakistan, it just seems pointless to take money from others to give to a third party!
Your views are good Gopika, but I figure we really do not need outside help. There are unimaginable hordes hard cash in India itself and when we can donate over 5 million dollars to Pakistan, it just seems pointless to take money from others to give to a third party!
Yes we don't need help in financial terms from others but we do need guidance and management lessons. We can share the best practices with other countries since we are still far behind in managing disasters even now. We start panicking and all our media channels are focussed on covering the disasters. We haven't ever seen any demonstration of what safety equipment is required in the event of a disaster and how people should deal in such circumstances. What safety measures should be taken etc.
As Per This topic, I want to say that India has the power to face these kind of disasters but the lazy workers of India which are getting paid for arrangements regarding these disasters are reason of loss during natural disasters.
India is one the country which is very strong in economic power. India can face these kind of disasters, we need full arrangements, but the curruption, greediness.. these are the two main problems..
India is one the country which is very strong in economic power. India can face these kind of disasters, we need full arrangements, but the curruption, greediness.. these are the two main problems..
I think history has more or less proved that India is as yet not really prepared to deal with a natural disaster.
The very term 'natural disaster' implies that it's not something that can be anticipated much in advance. Our country has neither the resources nor even the inclination to prepare for something that might or might not happen. Our policy is more to focus on fixing the existing problems than working towards problems that might occur in the future. There are merits in this view of course. God knows we have enough existing problems to worry about!
What people doesn't seem to realise however, is that by preventing the problem from occuring in the first place, their burden will eventually get lighter, instead of just replacing one load with another.
The very term 'natural disaster' implies that it's not something that can be anticipated much in advance. Our country has neither the resources nor even the inclination to prepare for something that might or might not happen. Our policy is more to focus on fixing the existing problems than working towards problems that might occur in the future. There are merits in this view of course. God knows we have enough existing problems to worry about!
What people doesn't seem to realise however, is that by preventing the problem from occuring in the first place, their burden will eventually get lighter, instead of just replacing one load with another.
I'd just like to add a personal experience as well.
Last friday Bangalore saw an unusual amount of rainfall. Not something that can be classified as a 'natural disaster' really, but it turned out to be quite disastrous for the people caught at the mercy of the storm.
The rain clearly demonstrated the pathetic drainage system. Bangalore has never really been a victim of flooding, but after seeing cars submerged and having to walk through knee deep water to get home, I find myself sympathizing with the people who go through these experiences more regularly.
One thing in particular I noticed was that people tend to panic when faced with something out of their control and instead of rationally thinking of a solution, just react. I saw some woman frantically filling buckets of water and throwing it on the other side of the road, not realising that the water would just flow down again anyway...
Perhaps educating people on how to deal with natural disasters would prove to be more beneficial, than expecting infrastructural changes to be made.
Last friday Bangalore saw an unusual amount of rainfall. Not something that can be classified as a 'natural disaster' really, but it turned out to be quite disastrous for the people caught at the mercy of the storm.
The rain clearly demonstrated the pathetic drainage system. Bangalore has never really been a victim of flooding, but after seeing cars submerged and having to walk through knee deep water to get home, I find myself sympathizing with the people who go through these experiences more regularly.
One thing in particular I noticed was that people tend to panic when faced with something out of their control and instead of rationally thinking of a solution, just react. I saw some woman frantically filling buckets of water and throwing it on the other side of the road, not realising that the water would just flow down again anyway...
Perhaps educating people on how to deal with natural disasters would prove to be more beneficial, than expecting infrastructural changes to be made.
Well, This is the first time something like this happened, at least I did not see it happening earlier!! An entire week's GD contest washed out with miserable participation.
When I floated the topic, I was expecting many people to share in their views and also some new information in terms of how the disaster is managed in their own cities and towns when floods strike! Almost every Indian city has faced this kind of situation at one or the other time which is why I was hoping that more discussions would come up.
But since none of the participants have entered more than a single reply barring Priya and Pallavi who came up with two posts, there are no qualifiers for the usual 50 points and no winners to be declared!! :( :( :(
I really really sincerely hope that this scenario does not repeat again!!
:(
When I floated the topic, I was expecting many people to share in their views and also some new information in terms of how the disaster is managed in their own cities and towns when floods strike! Almost every Indian city has faced this kind of situation at one or the other time which is why I was hoping that more discussions would come up.
But since none of the participants have entered more than a single reply barring Priya and Pallavi who came up with two posts, there are no qualifiers for the usual 50 points and no winners to be declared!! :( :( :(
I really really sincerely hope that this scenario does not repeat again!!
:(
Topic Author
K
Kalyani Nandurkar
@kalyani
Topic Stats
Created
Wednesday, 22 September 2010 16:16
Last Updated
Tuesday, 30 November -0001 00:00
Replies
0
Views
9.5K
Likes
0